How would you feel if the protagonist of the next Silent Hill was a closeted gay man...

How would you feel if the protagonist of the next Silent Hill was a closeted gay man, so the town was populated by sexy male monsters and dick creatures?

Other urls found in this thread:

silenthill.wikia.com/wiki/Abstract_Daddy
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

I feel like you need to seek help if you're merging your homosex with horror/suspense games.

but silent hill out of the first 4 literally only worked like that once

now, if the villain was a flamboyant homo and part of the horror was the player's homophobia then we'd be talking

probably wouldn't happen because that's stupid and childish

if it did I'd just think the game's stupid and childish

Merging horror and sex is nothing new, user.

That would be pretty funny

The monsters should be vaginas then duh.

I don't think that's how that works, user,

How about making monsters that are not genitals? Use some fucking imagination you spergs. Also we already had dick mosnter in sh3.

Honestly, that's not a bad concept. A gay man in denial sounds like a good fit for a Silent Hill game.
Obviously, dick creatures is going a bit far, but I'd be alright with it.

Please read what the OP wanted and see if it's equitable to your pic.

Did you even play silent hill? The town isn't affected by the character psyche. It's the clues of occult activity that shows what the influence is

So it would be like gachimuchi horror?
That would be fucking incredible, actually, thinking about it.
You could have dudes wearing leather and chains chasing you down. There's nothing more terrifying than an army of dudes with huge dicks wearing nothing but leather straps chasing you. You KNOW they're gonna show you who's the boss of this hill.

Sexy male monsters aren't comparable to sexy female monsters?

Yeah.. That sounds horrifying, user. Could you tell me more about this idea? In particular, what happens when they catch you?

>sexy male monsters and dick creatures
So the only new thing would be the gay protag?

and there is that one asian monster cuffed up screaming
FUCK YOU

I have got enough of sex-based horror, and sex isn't even that interesting. It's all about this shit since Alien.

The vaginas represent the overbearing heteronormative view that he must conform to

Miuraaaaaaaaaaaa

A floating cock monster is a lot different than a beautiful supermodel squeezed into an outfit from a sex shop showing off her titties while wearing a mask.

>The town isn't affected by the character psyche.

Holy shit, this better be bait. The cult only has clout because of the innate spiritual properties of the land that were benevolent but corrupted by the early settlers of America, Silent Hill as we know it is 100% born from the psyches of the people in it and everyone sees something different.

Or the fact that he is actually hetero in denial, brainwashed into homosexuality by rotten society and mass media.

Pussy monsters would be the symbol of his fear of his true desires.

MIURAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

I'm saying that there can be both sexy male monsters like the nurses and horrible grotesque floating dick creatures.

...

It'd be banned since Japan would tell it like it is and equate homos with pedo grooming.

It would make a lot of sense given Silent Hill. Of course, there would be no end to "teh gays are pushing their narrative in my video games REE" screaming though. Plus it wouldn't be very profitable so basically there's no reason to make this as fun as it might be.

Your argument boils down to "stop liking what I don't like" and is a thin sheet to mask your homophobia. Eat shit, hypocrite.

Is that a dig at me or are you being serious

Why are you so fucking retarded?

It's all a bit silly too since the original Alien didn't even focus much on Giger's designs. (for the better imo)

The town only projects things that cause mental distress, in this case having to pretend to be hetero because otherwise Russians will beat him up.

why is it stupid and childish?
did you find the sexy nurses from the first game stupid and childish?

Is there a new chapter out? I don't recognise this.

>I have no more fetishes with me

Oh don't worry. I have plenty enough for both of us.

There hasnt been a new chapter for 120+ days.

>a flying dick its the same as a normal person without face
yes they aren't comparable you faggot
do we have flying vaginas in silent hill?

SH1-4 never had any sexy nurses. It was Western developers who gave them short skirts and huge boobs.

>Silent Hill as we know it is 100% born from the psyches of the people in it and everyone sees something different.
...in SH2, which was an after effect of post-Alessa incident in SH1.

Pretty sure when OP said dick creatures he didn't mean floating 3D cocks drawn by teenagers, he meant something more like the other sexualized monsters of older Silent Hills. Or do you think the mere existence of something that may remind you of a penis in a game is "childish"?

thats like a mix of dick and pussy

I want furry girls

I'd be disappointed that they're trying to pull a SH2 again.

Guess I've just been missing out then. I only read the volumes once they're complete, so I'm only at 38. How far into vol 39 are we now?

>thin sheet to mask your homophobia
>mask
No one needs to hide the fact that gays should be exterminated user.

>The town only projects things that cause mental distress
Except, you know, the whole thing with Eddie having the time of his life, getting to eat pizza and shoot his bullies down.
Or what about Laura and the fact that the entire town's like one big playing ground to her?

>SH1-4 never had any sexy nurses.
Did you play SH2 and 3 at any point?

This, ladies and gentlemen is why the gays need to be subjected to shock treatment or savage beatings.

If he didn't want to admit to himself that he was gay, then having monsters representing the attraction he feels towards men would make sense.

Only ladyboys and sissy fags

They've been trying to pull SH2 ever since SH4.

Okay, I accept this. But what's the point of the cock monsters to begin with? It's too on the nose to be scary and doesn't fit psychological horror.
No it doesn't. It boils down to floating cock monsters looking retarded and having little place in psychological horror much like a giant vagina monster. If you want your rapey homosex undertones, have them, but every faggot needs to turn everything into a gay pride parade where sexual simulacra are pushed to the limit and subtlety is thrown out the window. If you want full-on homosex/rape undertones, do it like Alien with allusion. I wouldn't think a pussy monster is scary either.
Explain.

See
I guess the hard part of exploring the human psyche when it comes to sexuality, is that if you put any of it in a game people may think it's just "pandering", Like if a character was into feet and Silent Hill reflected that in some way, it would make perfect sense, but retards would think the game was just pandering to foot fetishists. Then other retards would draw porn because of it fueling the problem.

That's why if we get sexuality in a horror game like this it's rarely anything but as mainstream normal sex as possible

...

The whole Alessa incident is only possible because they lived in Silent Hill. The cult's "God" is just an entity born from the town's power, warped by the inhabitants collective darkness. Shit was going down long before Alessa.

>Or what about Laura and the fact that the entire town's like one big playing ground to her?
that sounds interesting
too bad i never played a single silent hill outside 5 minutes in that hospital in 3 where every fucking door was locked

39 is out in Japan, we will probably get it next year.

The town in SH2 doesn't work like it does in other games it seems. But, Laura got away because she's an innocent child with no guilt on her mind.
Eddie, I don't really know. Never got too deep into the LORE of the series, so I don't know how things work for him.

we have already sexy male pyramid head but i guess its not enough for faggots

I thought I told you there was no need to be upset, user.

>If you want your rapey homosex undertones, have them, but every faggot needs to turn everything into a gay pride parade where sexual simulacra are pushed to the limit and subtlety is thrown out the window.

Yeah, you're not a bigot at all.

If you think that stuff like that doesn't fit psychological horror, you probably wouldn't like Silent Hill anyway, it's full of stuff like that.

Exactly my point.

I'd be fine with it if they were really over the top.
>Walking down a dark hallway, flickering lights illuminating damaged anuses pulsating on the walls
>Door ahead opens and Pyramid Head walks out, muscled body glistening, holding his sword between his legs and shaking it around
>Turns to you and shouts, "Well hellooooo sailor!"

If he was a repressed homo, then some of the enemies should be dick girls.

>too bad i never played a single silent hill
Then why the fuck are you in this thread, practically speaking bullshit AND spoiling some of the greatest games ever made for yourself?
Go play them, in release order. Now!

>The town in SH2 doesn't work like it does in other games it seems.
That's only because 1, 3-4 had sort-of "alpha projections" that everyone was subjected to, not autopilot personal bubbles like in 2.

>Eddie, I don't really know. Never got too deep into the LORE of the series
He gets food, he gets a gun, he sees people bullying him, he kills them. He turns more and more cocky and crazy. He's enjoying it.

My whole point is it's not about making porn to pander to people who wanna masturbate to male porn.

You are literally quoting a post that's saying "we can't have any male sexy things at all because people would assume it's just pandering" and saying "wow haven't they had ENOUGH OF THEIR PANDERING ALREADY". You fucking retard.

didn't the nurses represent the fear of cheating on the sick wife?

As a fag myself he’s not wrong. Every gay I’ve ever met in person was an irritating flamboyant femboy. Why anyone would identify as gay and then seek to emulate female attribtes is beyond me

>fear of
weird way of typing "lust for"

>Except, you know, the whole thing with Eddie having the time of his life, getting to eat pizza and shoot his bullies down.

The pizza was real. He was being made fun of, which is exactly what he hated, it was his weak point. Eddie goes crazy, James and Angela commit suicide. If the town was a funhouse trying to entertain them, it wouldn't keep tormenting them by making them remember the things that caused them sadness and distress.

>Did you play SH2 and 3 at any point?

Can you masturbate to this?

What does it matter if I'm bigoted or not? What does that have to do with giant cock monsters not being scary?
I can't even tell what I'm looking at. I've played every silent hill except the one on wii and PSP.

Are you like that? Maybe the reason all other gay people seem flamboyant is because the flamboyant ones are the only ones you can tell are gay.

>practically speaking bullshit AND
its a faggot wanting to turn a game into a faggots game , yes its a bullshit thread
and if i ever decide to play it , i will forget everything i've read . tho i remember flying hospital beds from my brother playing when i was little , so i don't care for spoilers

Isn’t this almost exactly the same as sh2? What’s the problem

I think the reason Eddie gets to enjoy himself is because he's a fucking loony who doesn't feel any remorse about his actions. He even says it himself. He doesn't regret what he's done and since SH(at least in 2) prays on your guilt, he isn't affected by its evil power. Similar to Laura.

silenthill.wikia.com/wiki/Abstract_Daddy

Because they are very vocal. Because every day, each one of us walks past gay people all the time, because we talk to gay people, because we play with gay people online, but guess what, you don't know they are gay.

If anyone in this thread came across someone like me or someone like you IRL, they wouldn't know, and they certainly wouldn't be asking either. But of course, everyone would notice the guy who walks in the store with a rainbow tail talking about gay pride. It's not about "gay people", it's about attention whores. Sometimes, ironically, the most vocal "gay people" aren't gay at all.

Those are just the most visible ones. Besides the fact that people are all a mix of varying masc and femme traits and none of them are anything to be ashamed of. You sound like an Uncle Tom shoe-shining coon faggot.

No, I’m closeted even to them. I doubt that they even question it desu, at any rate I know that if I ever did come out to them they would be the first ones to spread it around. OL homos have been pretty cool though

Hatred towards the medical system, sexual repression and the fact he is the one who suffocated his wife.

>Can you masturbate to this?
You mean you can't?

How do I meet homos that do not look, act, or talk like fags then

I haven't played SH2 in a literal decade, however this level of subtlety is perfectly acceptable for what it displays -- it actually might be underplaying it a little.

You actually have to befriend people first, user

I’m good at making friends but I have never once found a normal gay guy. Maybe it’s just location, at any rate it’s getting old always being the different one whether people around me know or not

>If the town was a funhouse trying to entertain them, it wouldn't keep tormenting them by making them remember the things that caused them sadness and distress.
You're making assumptions that the "town" would be some kind of sentient being with actual agendas behind its "actions", rather than just a passive phenomenon that causes differing effects on differing people. The fact that practically none of the SH2's characters were exactly in their right minds when they got into the town is already good enough proof to question everything you experience in the game.

>can you masturbate to this
You do know that's just one of the many skins the nurses in the game has? Even my official SH2 nurse figure comes with multiple heads to choose from because of said reasons.

The SH3 nurses weren't much "better" either.

Kind of a tricky situation. You want to specifically meet people who are gay but who will show no obvious signs of being gay. I guess you'll just have to meet people and look for the faintest hints, hoping they open up some day.

>stupid and childish
even if it stupid and childish I would play them because reasons

Honestly, if you don't live in an "Urban" or "Progressive" city, you won't meet at the whole foods like a rom-com. If you live in a more rural area, try dating sites that aren't as sex focused, like OkCupid. You could also try to realize that lustful sex and companionship are sought by the weak who cannot satisfy and love themselves. If you do manage to get a date though, none of that coon-ass "I HATE FEMME GUYS REEEE" internalized homophobia shit. Even if the guy is traditional masc, hearing that shit is a big turn off to most.

I don’t hate femboys because they’re femboys, I’m irritated at how shallow and annoying they seem to be

Imagion if they Got modesevven to design all the monsters

I'm straight, and I would be able to figure this out:
>Online dating.
>Looking for homosex.
>No flamboyant fruits please, only normie gays.

Not to sound cliched but I want more than just sex. Is online dating good for actual relationships?

Hit and miss. You can't win without taking chances.

oh look, ANOTHER thread derailed by literal faggots

Well, anyone who falls into the "traditionally attractive" category is in danger of this. Male or Female, gay or straight. Most people are selfish and basic anyway, but add that with not having to work as hard for things, never feeling unaccepted, ect. you get narcissists with no empathy.

To quote Claudia: "Happy people can be so cruel."

A lot of homos rarely get the chance to talk to other cool homos user

>You could also try to realize that lustful sex and companionship are sought by the weak who cannot satisfy and love themselves.
What unbelievable condescension.

>It's internalized homophobia
No, it's the same phenomenom as girls hating vapid sluts.

Believe it.