What is the best 3D Sonic game and is it all that good in the first place?

What is the best 3D Sonic game and is it all that good in the first place?

Other urls found in this thread:

boards.fireden.net/v/search/filename/memebyDD.png/
youtube.com/watch?v=ge6hqMK4iXc
youtube.com/watch?v=MxYsalNsUxs
youtube.com/watch?v=zlNa7RQju7Y
youtube.com/watch?v=_amQfxGQAu8
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

THe only one I've played was for the wii and it was so bad that I almost threw up pineapple juice from my left nostril

Sonic Generations is the only consistently good 3D Sonic game. All others are either terrible all around or have too much jank in between the "good" parts. But you'd still be better off playing Sonic 2 or 3&K.

sonic adventure. altho its still a terrible game, its the best 3d one due to variety and charm

SPBP.

I'd say Sonic Colors. Really pretty, fun gameplay and story and great ost

Colors is barely 3D at all

Listen chump. No one on Earth besides me will give you an honest to god answer. Yes, 3D Sonic games are great, but you do need a high IQ to really appreciate and play them properly.

boards.fireden.net/v/search/filename/memebyDD.png/
This is truly sad.

Takes literally a less than a minute of my time to post this. You're the one who's sad for looking me up you fucking homo. You want to suck my dick just ask.

Honestly, Sonic Utopia.

You need a bullet in your head

Utopia is dogshit for faggots

Its actually pretty damn great, you should try it.

Sonic Unleashed.

Looking you up? You post your stupid fucking picture in every goddamn Sonic thread, you autist. Of course someone would look up how often spam this awful shit. Last (You) from me. I'd like you to continue with posting this picture, since the usage of it will pile up and you'll be known as the next FFXVfag around here. That's what you wanted, right? You attention whore.

A tie between Colors and Generations. I know Sup Forums's recently started hating Colors, but it's current the only good modern Sonic game that doesn't have any shitty half-baked gameplay styles and has a gimmick that's actually pretty decent(the Wisps). It stays consistent in its quality throughout. Generations has higher highs(better modern stages) and lower lows(the friend missions and the shitty final boss).

you know I always wonder with people like this guy. They pretend to be autistic for the lels, but putting that much effort into it just makes you more autistic than actual autists

>Sonic Generations is the only consistently good 3D Sonic game
But half the game controls like shit.
Classic Sonic's physics are completely butchered and he doesn't feel natural at all. Combine that with the fact that the game is incredibly short and all you are left with is a half decent game.

Fuck the 3D Sonic games.
Sonic Mania is the greatest Sonic game ever made due to it improving this already god-tier song
youtube.com/watch?v=ge6hqMK4iXc

Sonic colors isn't 3D though.
It's a 2D game with some 3D sections to spice it up, like Sonic Mania.

not him but it's just a simple search that shows when this exact image has been posted. It's mostly used to show how fucking autistic people like you are because they post it in every thread.

Sonic Unleashed. Yes it’s really that good, even the night stages. Last game with level design that wasn’t afraid to kick your ass

It's because of pieces of shit like these guys that I made that image and continue to spam it every thread. I figured, you all are fucking stupid as fuck, so I'm just gonna be as stupid to be petty.

how does that benefit you in any way though?

wasting your time pretending to be retarded is pretty goddamn retarded

It is a 3D game that happens to have a lot of 2D.
Mania is a 2D game with 3D special stages.

because when I see how stupid you dumb fucks can get, I die a little inside. the real reason is pure unadulterated pettiness. I'm not stopping

This reminds me of the video where the guy compiles all of Forces 3D gameplay time and it amounts to something like 24 minutes. In a 3 hour game.
3D sonic games are only 3D in name really.

Are you the guy that gets triggered everytime someone rightfully shits on the Adventure games?

so it's autism then.

Well, at least you're honest about how much of a faggot you are

Here you go.

>rightfully
hahahaha this is more motivation. matter of fact look at this other OC I made

Right here

low IQ. Team Dark is great, Team Chaotix is great, Team Rose's stages are fun, short and easy obstacle courses where you just grab rings and whatnot.

>Team Chaotix is great
I hope this is bait. Team Chaotix is basically just a demo for Shadow the Hedgehog's gameplay.

Generations > Colors > Adventure 1

Generations is the most consistently great.
Colors is almost perfect, except for waggle.
Adventure would be great without Big The Cat and Amy's stages.

The rest are absolutely Garbage.

Generations is probably the best.
Unleashed can be great if you go in with the right mindset.
Both Adventure games have charm, but are a bit too unpolished.

>Hating on the best Sonic character

>except for waggle
You can play Colors with a Gamecube controller you know.

Why are you such a fucking faggot? Why are you such a boring ass fucking low T dull loser that hates fun?

Unironically this.
The only good boostshit game (and I'm including the Rush games in that) and the God of War sections are fun too.
Also has some of the best music in the series.

...

Reread the post

...

The fighting itself isn't great, but it's okay enough. I actually really enjoyed looking around for the medals in those stages.

Why did everyone have a shit eating grin during the Adventure-Heroes era?

They were too cool for school.

Because it's fucking kino you dumb fuck

Sonic Unleashed

any game that was not boostshit.

...

...

>precise platforming
I liked SA2, but the physics was not the greatest part of the game, not by a long shot.

...

Too bad unlike SA1, all of this slope jumping is unintended by the developers. They just wanted you to run in a straight path.

The only correct answer. Generations fags get fucked. Werehog sections should have been & Knuckles though.

still it's as good as 3D sonic (MADE BY SEGA) has ever been. it feels as good to control as mario oddyssey, and it's close to how classic sonic worked. webm related, spindash+jump to travel feels better than cappy dive in mario oddyssey

not my point. i agree that the levels were designed as shit hallways, but the physics were so good that once you learned to spindash jump, you had a whole different game. I wish some degenerates made custom stages with this playstyle in mind.

Unleashed would have been the greatest Sonic game ever made if it was & Knuckles 2.

>Sonic and Knuckles get fused together because of dark gaia magic bullshit
>all of the bantz and fighting they would do as they spoke to each other while trapped in the same body

It would have been amazing.

...

Green Hill Paradise

is not as good as Utopia.

That's because it has classic Sonic.

If it was modern you would hate it.

>best
Adventure 2.
>all that good
None of them.

I don't care if it's Classic or Modern, I'm just talking about controls and level.

Nah man, the controls are just way better.

I actually like Modern Sonic more than Classic Sonic. I wish Modern was in Utopia.

Guy who made it hates everything post classic Sonic.

SRB2.

youtube.com/watch?v=MxYsalNsUxs

looks like a generic boostshit game but better because field of view, allowed to spindash (but a really badly nerfed one), and not a narrow hallway

still hate boost with a passion, would not play. but this is definititely a direction sega should take if they decide to stick with the garbage boostshit playstyle.

>SA1 started the "boost pads and scripted sequences all over the place" design philosophy, and had a bunch of shit nobody wanted, like fishing and survival horror.
>SA2 was even more linear and automated, but had a Chao Garden and fun multiplayer to compensate for its faults.
>Heroes has shit physics and tedious melee combat.
>Shadow has shit physics.
>06 is a buggy mess, with shit physics, and tedious melee combat.
>Unleashed has shit physics, Werehog, and too many 2D sections.
>Colors has shit physics and too many 2D sections.
>Generations has shit physics, too many 2D sections, and Classic Sonic gameplay that's barely better than Sonic 4. But it also made some attempts to flesh out the boost gameplay more, with customization options.
>Forces is more automated than anything else listed, has shit physics, a half assed create-a-character with bland run-and-gun gameplay, and a once again shitty Classic Sonic.

They're all deeply flawed. They literally can't make a 3D game without fucking up at least one fundamental component. Adventure 1, Adventure 2, Unleashed, and Generations manage to compensate for their glaring design flaws the best. I love them to death, but I could never call them "good".

I hate cocksuckers like that. They need to get brutally tortured and mutilated.

I don't get it. If you enjoy racing games so much, the Boost games should be higher.

You probably spent like 10 minutes to type up a blatantly wrong criticisms on all of them you piece of fucking shit.

Shut up brainlet wojak poster

i enjoy high speed 3D-space platforming (Adventure1/2) more than racing games in a narrow, restricted hallway you boost through & with forced 2d platforming sections with shit physics (boostshit). if i wanna play a racing game i'll play that, I don't want sonic to control like a car.

I am planning on building a 3D Sonic game design concept that considers that the series never tried to approach the 3D sandbox game style the way Mario did.

You might want to give Lost World a look, it's slightly similar.

why not make your job simpler and steal a game with perfect sonic physics (sonic adventure 2) and make custom stages for it?

>if i wanna play a racing game i'll play that
so then why don't you play the Boost games? They're racing games. They have NOS, drifting, Sonic controls like a car, and you do Time Trials.

i think the sonic forces soundtrack is one of the best sonic soundtracks.

You forgot the Storybook games.

Didn't he say once that he'd never join SEGA if they offered him to make Utopia official since they'd force him to use Modern Sonic?

>sonic adventure 2
>perfect sonic physics
Stop trying to spread your retardation via text.

do you find this enjoyable?
if you had the choice between moving like a fridge or moving as freely as you can in mario oddyssey, which would you pick?

another weebm

kill yourself

Sonic Lost World still focuses on linear stages with getting to the goal.

Sonic Adventure 2's engine would work fine, but mechanics would need to be tweaked to account for a sandbox game style. The main problem is that all Sonic does is rushes to the goal, I think that while that may be fun it requires limiting what Sonic can do in a 3D space.

Sonic needs a non-linear goal that allows any exploration of a map to be considered a way to make progress. If levels just required Sonic to obtain a specific score in SA2, at the very least, then you could already build more open levels for him to run around in. I think that's too shallow, so a game would need to be built with a non-linear design in mind that speaks to Sonic the way Collecting Power Stars did to Mario.

>wanting your sonic game to control like a literal phone game

>controls like shit
Classic sonic is far from controlling like shit. He might not live up to his legacy but saying he controls even poorly is lying.

You first, mong.

Generations, and yes.

>M-MU-MUH PHYSICS
Fucking low IQ brainlet.

I wouldn't say he controls like shit.
Jumping is a little stiff and rolling doesn't do jack shit, but you can insta spin dash to make up for it.
It's not perfect and I'd much prefer actual classic sonic, but it's serviceable and the levels he goes through are good enough to be enjoyable.

(You)

HURRRR DURRRR I LIKE BOOSTSHIT I LIKE TO MOVE LIKE A FRIDGE HURRR

make yo power moons be master emerald pieces if you want to force le open world meme

i think linear but wider space and platforming options can work for SA2 physics engine as-is, though

youtube.com/watch?v=zlNa7RQju7Y

>having to strawman because you know you’re wrong
Dicked.

>colors
>waggle
nigga

>waggle
Use a different controller then

youtube.com/watch?v=_amQfxGQAu8

this doesn't look half bad desu, the physics look very close to SA1/2 with enhancements like momentum post homing attack

Excellent retardation