>persona 5 didn't get best soundtrack
Impossible, it must be rigged. Neirs ost was good but it wasn't nearly as catchy, soulful, melodically constructed and overall grand as p5. Anyone who say otherwise is a robot.
Persona 5 didn't get best soundtrack
Tyler Morgan
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
youtu.be
youtu.be
youtu.be
youtu.be
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtu.be
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
twitter.com
Jack Howard
Rivers in the desert is still the best track of the year. I dont give a fuck about anything else.
Blake Price
I blame Last Surprise and the inability to change it without buying dlc.
Eli Morgan
The lyrics are awful, though.
Gabriel Lewis
Soundtrack of the year for me's a toss-up beteen Persona 5, Xenoblade 2 and Sen 3
Adrian Perez
How mediocre...i mean it's catchy but lyrics are retarded
Nolan Harris
>is a robot
it's not a game
Angel Wilson
Blooming Villain would like a word
Jaxon Rivera
>weebs
>good musical taste
youtube.com
off yourselves
Camden Morris
How are they awful?
Michael Walker
Person 4 would have won best OST if it replace P5.
Dominic Williams
Persona 5 OST is great.
Nier Automata has the best OST of all time.
Jose Sanders
>divinity original sin 2 didn't get best rpg
>Impossible, it must be rigged. Persona was good but it wasn't nearly as catchy, soulful, melodically constructed and overall grand as Divinity. Anyone who say otherwise is a robot.
Thomas Rodriguez
Soundtrack is a hard thing to judge.
Like, there's hearing the songs as is, so you'd be able to enjoy them on their own merits - but playing the game, meanings are attached to these songs, thus making them more important to the listener(presumably.)
Nier: A probably just mixed the music and narrative better in their own eyes instead of just having catchy tunes.
I dunno, lol
Liam Ortiz
It probably would have won if they kept it in their native language. While some of the musical compositions are great, the singing is just feels like some Jap trying her best to do English karaoke. It's certainly not on the level of burn my bread or the other shit, but it's still pretty awful.
Carter Perry
Not sure if trolling, but the singing in Nier is a made-up language, not english. Which is partly why it's so cool
Christian Martin
The OST of P5 is terrible, and im a fucking fan of the saga.
Adam Davis
Nier had a glorious OST but persona 5 comes a really close second
Michael Roberts
Joseph Campbell
I hate to be the nostalgia freak but apart from Rivers in the Desert and Beneath My Mask I don't remember P5 topping the memorable variety of P3 and P4's music.
Jonathan Carter
>p5 didn't get best artstyle
>p5 didn't get best soundtrack
>p5 got best RPG even though the dungeoneering is fucking shit
Leo Collins
Now you remember Wiping All Out.
That one is even worse.
Isaac Butler
P5 came out last year, bro.
William Baker
Persona music in general isn't very good, especially the vocal tracks. There are a few stand out tracks in each game but they're only good and not great. P5's ost isn't close to equaling Nier's but I guess it had to be a nominee because there's not much competition.
Noah Anderson
Thing is, how do these even get picked? Isn't a taste in music, at the very basic level, a highly subjective thing? So how can there be 1 best ost? My advice is dont give a damn about what anyone says, if you like it you like it.
Brandon Perry
>but the singing in Nier is a made-up language, not english.
I had no clue since I didn't play the game. Though, like you said, it's made up. There isn't anything to even compare it to. I can see the novelty in that. With Persona, you can pinpoint the moments where there are clear mispronunciations or just straight up awkward use of words and syllables. it's jarring and to me, takes away from the music entirely leading it to not be considered one of the greats of this year when it comes to soundtracks.
Ayden Green
>Soulful
Josiah Cox
P5 has a really mediocre OST. also. you can't keep making shitty pop songs with garbage lyrics and always get away with it. you will have a high number of followers but that doesn't mean it is actually good. even on the shit show that is the music industry this happens all the time
Wyatt Williams
>Xenoblade 2
Mor Ardain is one of the most hype field themes I've heard in ages
youtube.com
Uraya's day theme apparently brought Mitsuda to tears when he first heard it too.
youtube.com
Gavin Richardson
Nothing like a pop song with garbage lyrics.
Luke Martin
Keeper of lust is the only memorable track. And it's much worse than Unavoidable Battle or Hari Hara.
Isaiah Rodriguez
youtube.com
What P5 track comes close to topping this?
Aaron Campbell
But XV had the best OST, anons
Owen Cook
P5 is a great game with a great soundtrack, but Nier's is one of the best soundtracks in any video game ever.
Love me some Yoko.
youtube.com
Sebastian Garcia
youtube.com
I found a burned CD with this. Some good shit.
Anthony Rivera
>no a beautiful song
Connor Hughes
>download the whole ost
>1 good song.
>its the night battle song
Xavier Nelson
lol
Wyatt Gonzalez
Persona 3 would have won best soundtrack AND GOTY.. c'mon P5fags..
Brayden Murphy
Derp, didn't realize you were talking about p5.
I can see your complaint, but it's never really bothered me. I just found it made the music more unique with the "engrish" vocals
Evan Ross
There's something wrong with you if you don't like this youtube.com
It sets the mood perfectly.
Logan Clark
nails is pretty good, user
good taste
Dominic Phillips
>Neirs ost was good but it wasn't nearly as catchy
I don't save these memes.
But this post truly deserves a brainless Wojak reply.
John Harris
Get your shit tastes out of this thread faggot
Aiden Wright
Made in Abyss OST would win if it was a game
Thomas Rogers
Yes, the OST really sets the mood for the mind-numbing repetitiveness of the game.
youtube.com
Kevin Green
Generic orchestral music will always beat something unique or different
Camden Davis
RPGs aren’t always about dungeoneering, you know. It’s called a Role Playing Game because you are playing a special role in a Highschool life simulator. Hell, you could even call Animal Crossing or Stardew Valley RPGs, even though combat isn’t their main focus
Jonathan Gomez
Lets not forget its memorable daytime music.
P3 had the unforgettable Want to be Close, P4 had the melodic and catchy Heartbreak. And P5... has mall music.
youtube.com
Andrew Davis
Gravity Rush 2 wasn't even nominated for best soundtrack?
Brandon Wright
>melodically constructed
what the fuck are you trying to convey here? people who listen only to AMVs and video game OSTs have no fucking clue about music. I bet you have a vidya OST on your fucking mp3 player
Cooper Jackson
>unforgettable
>melodic
>catchy
You know these words don't really mean anything, right?
Aiden Hernandez
Tell that to the OP.
Daniel Reed
Agreed. I thought Persona 5 had some really outstanding tracks that could easily compete with the best tracks from the other games, but all in all, it generally had more mediocre and forgettable stuff and wasn't as good overall.
Julian Reed
Want to be Close is kinda poo
Blake Roberts
>Implying something can compete against this.
youtube.com
Aaron Garcia
Shoji Meguro is a fucking hack, face it
Also Nier:A's soundtrack not as good as original nier and overall I don't give a fuck about these awards
Still Meguro fucking sucks and you should know it
Gavin White
its shit
Oliver Ortiz
Shit thread OP, stop using meaningless words to make it sound like you know anything about music.
Nolan Cook
>Digital Devil Saga
>Strange Journey
>bad
Nocturne's OST is a meme
Robert White
Just wanted to stop by and say this song is not good and neither is any vidya music
Jordan Barnes
...
Anthony Baker
This. Nier's OST wasn't even as memorable as BotW's.
Andrew Richardson
The most memed songs of Nocturne are really a meme, but it has some good tracks in it.
Zachary Gray
Not him but they're like some Neffex shit or something. The hook is cool but all it does is say the same thing in different ways. "Gotta do this, now or never"
Nolan Russell
>but playing the game, meanings are attached to these songs
>Nier: A probably just mixed the music and narrative better in their own eyes instead of just having catchy tunes.
Thank you for actually understanding what makes a game soundtrack so great. Nier went above and beyond with handling its music with transitioning 8-bit and quiet versions of most of the tracks. And they didn't just transition for scripted events. The overworld music would also dip in and out of their "quiet" versions when traveling which added so much to the atmosphere.
Robert Williams
Wow, three fucking games
why did you forget about Catherine?
Still overall he's a shitter and never surpassed even P1 OST
youtu.be
Asher Bell
>only 6 good songs in Persona 5
>multiple are just extended versions
>Nier's entire soundtrack is good
Lmao
Andrew Gonzalez
Go to school and have a part-time job. Fantasy we all wanted to live through
Caleb Myers
I like River in the Desert specifically because the unclear vocal delivery lets me hear it as another instrument and ignore the garbage lyrics entirely. Same with Beneath the Mask, which is my favorite vidya song of the year.
youtube.com
Aiden Nguyen
>Go to school and have a part-time job
>never have homework, you can skip the job whenever you want, get paid the very same day and be treated like a long time friend whenever you step there
Who wouldn't want to live in that world?
Adrian Howard
>unironically playing games designed for socially anxious soyboys
No thank you
Michael Price
>P5 best soundtrack
>Anyone who say otherwise is a robot
>mad that Nier won
You this much of a fucking brainlet? Compared to P5, Nier's soundtrack had meaning to it and fit well with the narrative. It was filled with emotions and power. Plus, the music made the game more immersive. Don't judge me wrong. I did enjoy the tracks from P5, but, Nier was just objectively better. Nier deserved the reward.
Jason Foster
Want to be close is repetitive as fuck.
Blake Jackson
kys
Ethan Morales
did the last guardian come out this year? The award is a travesty if it did.
Ryder Richardson
How can songlets even HOPE to compete?
youtube.com
youtube.com
Kayden Peterson
I agree. The music single handedly made me keep coming back and playing Persona 5. And I was smiling and shaking my hips in my seat the entire time.
Juan Lopez
I love this song. I don't get the love for Rivers in the Desert at all.
William Allen
>get to the final dungeon
>this song with lyrics is played
>just stand around to enjoy listening to it
Parker Rodriguez
It came out December last year. The deadzone for awards. Too late for that year, won't be counted for next year
Adam Rodriguez
>needing lyrics
youtube.com
Cooper Lopez
>P5 OST
>Engrish
Yeah, P5 OST is bad.
Daniel Foster
>Watch Persona super live.
>P3 and P4 singers are shit at singing.
>P5 singer literally shits on them.
Why did it take so long for the series to get a good singer?
Chase Clark
xenoblade 2 > Nier: A > P5 > the rest
really it's a toss up between Nier and Xenoblade
Joseph Foster
They're the same singers for about 90% of the games
Colton Sullivan
Who cares
Did you fucks forget that MGSV also won best OST against Bloodborne?
Easton Davis
if u really think p5 deserved it u really are blind on your love for p5, i can respect that
but nier tho, they even went the extra mile to redo pretty much every track on chiptune for the hacking minigame
then u got multiple versions of the ending credits, specially ending the ending E one.
in p5 pretty much every track was violin, guitar, and synthetic sounds
nier had a ton of shit on it and those vocals just hoo boi
imo p5 was pretty weak in the vocals department, like shape shifter rivers in the desert, wake up and never see it coming were the only -really- good ones.
I'd rather just listen to the p3-4-DAN-reincarnations album tracks again than p5
but again, nier tho
Michael Evans
Post yfw the band started playing rivers in the desert
Dylan Stewart
I’m actually happy that Keichii Okabe can finally have some recognition on him because he’s an amazing composer. He did amazing compositions for Drakenguard 3 and NieR: Gestalt.
Sebastian Powell
That was done by Yoshitaka Suzuki though.
Ian Miller
What about Keigo Hoashi? He did around half of the soundtrack and gets no credit. He also did the best track.
youtube.com
Camden Morgan
Persona's 5 soundtrack is too repetitive, it was really good at first but became old fast.
Colton Ortiz
The game that won best soundtrack didnt even get any of its soundtrack played.
Sebastian Nelson
I blame Mementos. As much time as is spent in there, it was a terrible song.
Asher Ramirez
Honestly, this was the GOTY, but what did you expect from today's rigged and corrupt system?
Persona 5 will be remembered, and that's all that should count for us.
WHO AM I?
AM I NOT UNIQUE
Tyler Fisher
i've seen this comment more than once
was it really a problem?
i once visited mementos like 5 times and it was ok for me
Jeremiah Moore
Pic related or it didn't happen
Evan Nelson
Wait. If we are talking about rigged competitions... does that mean the Phantom Thieves will change the heart of those who give the awards?
Benjamin Cruz
MAYBE I'M NOT HERE AT ALL