We can all agree that P5 had the best soundtrack of 2017 right?

We can all agree that P5 had the best soundtrack of 2017 right?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtu.be/YMKskuvJTcs
youtu.be/CKOM3lNFajE
youtu.be/DLAvHLQGOco
youtube.com/watch?v=e9r5hx47kxM
youtube.com/watch?v=9sKp2ZdBaYI
youtu.be/7XdptdO6oIk
youtube.com/watch?v=hZgZzn-Gv58
youtube.com/watch?v=iocL_PdwTPA
youtube.com/watch?v=T-xGBHMVaig
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

Yeah. I can't decide if I like it more than 4's though. There's a few songs in 5 (Whims of Fate, Rivers in the Desert, and a couple others) that I really love, but on average I like 4's OST more I think.

Nigger nier won , get over with
Also
>2017
You are so godamm stupid

It wasn't all that great, but it was high quality at least. Last Surprise can go somewhere else though, I was happy to buy one of the DLC packs to replace it.

I'd give it to Nier, but P5 is probably my 2nd fav OST of all time.

sorry anime nigger, sonic mania has the freshest beats this year.

I finished the game two days ago. While I loved the soundtrack, I still gotta give it to Automata. I don't think I've ever played a game that had this sheer number of 10/10 tracks.

P5 or NieR, hard to think of many other contenders

Xenoblade 2 is better than P5 at least

XB2, NieR and p5 had the best OSTs of the year I think.

it got repetitive really quick

hell no, nier automata was better and I say that as a jazzfag (was p5 even jazz aside from a few tracks?)

Had several great songs, but was only alright as a whole

What are the chances that Atlus gets a non-Engrish singer for the next game? The songs are great but the English is embarrassing except for maybe in Rivers in the Desert

I haven't played Nier, but open to it being better. Show me a song better than rivers in the desert and i'll agree

P5 won in 2016.
NieR won in 2017.

Persona 4 had a more memorable soundtrack than Persona 5.

I know that it's crazy to say that, but Persona 5 only had a few really great tracks while Persona 4 just had great shit playing at all times.

Nier Automata can take best OST of 2017, because it truly deserves it.

I legit thought it was a black woman singing until I looked up who did the vocals. She just has that black-woman inflection in the vocals.

youtu.be/YMKskuvJTcs
youtu.be/CKOM3lNFajE
youtu.be/DLAvHLQGOco
Automata doesn't really have anything similar to Rivers so it's hard to draw any parallels.

No. It has a couple good tracks and repetitive everything else.

Nier had both a wide array of great songs and brilliant sound design to make em shine at key moments.

XB2>Nier:A>P5

Nier, Xenoblade 2, Splatoon 2, and Style Savvy Stylist Star are all better. Odyssey had overall best song though with Jump Up, Super Star.

Haru or Chihaya for my NG+ run?

Not while Nier:A and Sen 3 exist.

Most other years it would have won, but the competition was too stiff this year honestly.

Nah Pyre won

Its between P5 or Nier. Nintendidler plese stop shoehorn your shitty kusoge.

Yep, easily.

I don't know. The music is pretty good, but I still think that Persona 5's music is waaaay to ingrained in the game that it is also a reason why it's good.

I need to play Nier, but I felt like some parts of these tracks could easily be played on other games with great effect. While Persona's music is deeply related to the visuals and art style of the game.

>The DLC packs have custom battle BGM
Wait, so you're saying I can fucking replace Last Surprise with the Raidou battle theme? Holy shit.

Of the games I played yes.

>Yep, easily.

>I didn't play anything else this year

It came out in 2016 dumbass

Funny that you say that, the singer of Persona 5's songs actually is a lot better at the english language now. I can't link any performances because Fatlus are jews though.

>JRPG has 1000 different songs that only play once or twice but only has one fucking battle theme that you end up listening to for 20 hours

no

Yeah, but the contrarians on Sup Forums are going to tell you nier won with its incredibly bland and mediocre soundtrack.

abby pls go

>muh nintendo
Console warriors aren't welcome in these threads.

Never played this game. Any example of representative good tracks?

Sonic Mania came out/

All good tracks in Mania are old Jackson remixes.

XB2 was generic "orchestral jrpg OST" nothing like the refreshing acid jazz of p5.
Great game tho

Both, there's literally no reason not to romance more than one character

It was nice but not memorable as other Persona games imo.

youtube.com/watch?v=e9r5hx47kxM

Yakuza 0's ost was even better.

That would be Cuphead

It's really nice just sounding for me, I don't know anything about music but these are things that my brain tells me are good.
But the value might wear off because you'll be spending hours listening to each one as you play through the game unless you shut it off.

>XB2 was generic "orchestral jrpg OST"
What other JRPGs allow me to explore a desert with energetic celtic orchestral music blasting?
youtube.com/watch?v=9sKp2ZdBaYI

Not when Sonic Mania & Nier Automata exist

wat

Not even, there's like three good songs but they get run into the ground and quick.

you forgot outside of the celtic whistling, the jazz piano and jazz drumming in that track too.

Yes. Sonic Mania is second and Yakuza 0 is third.

>second
nah, P5 is second

Just gonna leave this here:youtu.be/7XdptdO6oIk

Music in Alliance Alive is shit. Fix your taste.

What other jrpgs allow me to fight giant robots to music that sound like they came from an 80s Western police comedy?

youtube.com/watch?v=hZgZzn-Gv58

NieR>Cuphead>Persona 5>Mania

Which is crazy because either of those would be the best most years.

Hey guys, what about me?

The only reason people even noticed this game is because it came out on a game starved system.
If it were on ps4, I can assure you that by now people wouldn't even be able to tell it from that new Star Ocean which flopped real hard last year.

Didn't BotW win?

People never post any music from it so I guess even Zeldafags know the ost is nothing worth bragging about.

that's a cute post and all but we're talking about soundtracks

It's generic and you know it.
The only reason you're trying so hard to force it onto this thread is because you're assblasted that nintendo is underrepresented in this thread.

easily

BoTW does.

>It's generic and you know it.
Name a single JRPG desert theme that resembles Mor Ardain; It shouldn't be hard to pull up multiple JRPG desert themes with fast-paced Irish/Scottish orchestras, fusion drumming and jazz piano riffs given how generic it must be.

Xenoblade Chronicles 2 OST is better than Persona 5. Easily. Persona's OST is straight up dog shit, jazz is a trash genre that only literal niggers listen to.
Nier on the other hand would be a better choice, but it's between that and XC2 and I'd personally pick XC2.

No I’ve played both. Niers wins by a landslide. I still do like P5 OST though.

That Mor Ardain theme is so good that it made grinding for Core Crystals at that one salvage spot tolerable.

This.

XC2.
youtube.com/watch?v=iocL_PdwTPA
Even areas that could have fallen into the trap of having shit themes manage to surprise me.
I was expecting my trip through an area called the "Old Factory" to be a dull one but as soon as this theme came on I knew it was gonna be good. Straight up sounds like some Deus Ex shit too.

energetic desert themes are so rare but they're god-tier whenever they show up

youtube.com/watch?v=T-xGBHMVaig

Nier > XC2 > P5.

We are done here.

Does Persona 5 get any better as you keep playing it? The pacing is complete garbage holy shit

It doesn't and that kind of pacing is actually one of the selling point of the series.
Next time do some research before you get into a game that's totally not for you.

Play XC2 instead.

Not him but I pirated P4G on my vita a while back and expected one hell of a jrpg after all the praise I heard about it. Color me surprised when it wasn't anything it's made out to be. Dropped it like 8 hours in when I just couldn't deal with that tripe any longer. Never bothered with p5.

>when it wasn’t anything it made out to be
Because the type of game isn’t for you, not because the game was lacking

That's obviously automata you pleb.

Can we talk about the biggest fucking annoying thing.

>Vidya orchestra at game awards
>Nier wins best OST
Now you’d think they’d play some Nier tracks
>nope here’s some fucking shitty Overwatch
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE FUCK YOU GEOFF

It's probably Lacrimosa of Dana.

best part is there are better songs in that ost

>because the genre was invented by people with a different skin color than mine the entire genre is shit
Blacks don't even listen to jazz anymore retard. It's a white man's genre now