>>402423543

People already did.

How do you manage to make Mania into something awful? I would definitely rather play Advance 2 over this.

How well did Advance even play? It didn't really seem as good as the Genesis games, maybe because it was on the Gameboy's hardware. At least to me at least.

Better than 1 and arguably CD, but not as good as 2 3 or Mania.

Modern Era is currently standard and provides a lot more creative freedom and cool elements to the series. This is a big reason why I and many others want Mania to eventually become like an Advance series successor.

What the fuck is even happening in that video? Looks like trash.

The Advance series had all kinds of movement options but the screen crunch was too fierce to get the most out of it without rote memorization.
Didn't help that the level design ended up becoming a congested mess of tiny hallways the longer the games went on.

It would be great to let the Mania team have Modern Sonic so they could have more control over the series direction. I would love Sonic to return to the glory days of the Adventure/Advance era.

Sonic fans needs to come to terms with the hardest truth of all.

The handheld Sonics aren't very good. We praised them because they were so clearly better than the modern console Sonics but they completely abandoned how the game works in 2D.

Wash away your nostalgia and embrace objective fact. Advance was made by hacks. The only Sonic that works was the Sonic made by Yuji Naka and Yasuhara.

Sonic Advance was good. Hindered by a small screen.

Naka was involved with the Advance series though. Also people forget the trash that was Sonic 1.

Fuck off classicfag, holy shit.

>Has proper physics
>Momentum and platforming
Sonic the Hedgehog is great. To think it is trash is to think the whole series is trash, but then thinking that brings into question your actual sub-par taste.

>Marble Zone
>Labyrinith Zone

Spring Yard and Scrap Brain are only mediocre.

They play pretty close to the classics, only on a smaller screen. I really don't know how people can't get their classic Sonic fix from these games.

Why do people make these garbage mods? Holy fuck.

literally no one wants your garbage JUST hedgehog, sega is never gonna fuck with that garbage after sonic forces

Except it has a higher metacritic score than Mania. Probably more profitable too.

>voices in a 2D sonic game

You have some pretty bad taste in thinking Spring Yard and Scrap Brain as mediocre. Scrap Brain only got beaten out by Manias Titanic Monarch as the best final zone.

The only one that is anything like the classic games is Advance 1 and it isn't particularly good at it

The other two are basically where the SONIC IS ABOUT SPEED faggots came from

Sonic 1 is fine. It and CD have a distinctly different design to levels and gameplay but I think it's still a well above average platformer. Yeah, it's not as good as Sonic 2 or 3&K but those are designed very differently and it's an unfair comparison imo, especially considering 1 built so much of the foundation the later games built on.

1 also has this thing where levels alternated between ramp/slope based and a second type that was more traditionally block based, while every game following on from 2 went exclusively ramp based because that obviously worked better, but I think people fail to appreciate half of Sonic 1's levels were designed like platforming levels, which you don't really see in the rest of the franchise.

Not until Colours.

>is it really the style of Sonic that people care about or the gameplay

Both, but obviously people can tolerate the modern style more than the modern gameplay.

t. dimps defender