Odyssey unironically belongs at the top

Odyssey unironically belongs at the top.

make the real good games and good games swap places and have NSMB and NSMBU swap places and you'll have yourself the truth

You're missing the Super Mario Bros. 2 you double nigger OP

The Galaxies are overrated.

It's a good list desu. I'd put the Galaxy games a bit lower and 3D World a bit higher but everything else I agree with for the most part.

People agree with dunkey what a shocker

I'd make a couple of changes but it's a fine ranking

Let's hear your list then.

I liked how he took a shot at Yooka Laylee

I wonder what his rankings are of the Mario RPG’s.

The Galaxies deserve to be lower.

This.

Like almost everyone?

>3 better than world

yoshis island is the only good game in this pic

>mario 64, mario 3, mario world, fucking sunshine
what a shit list

>World not at the top
ah, why even bother?

This

pretty much agree except the galaxy games should swap places with sunshine

>auto scroll courses

I don't understand why everyone hate 3d World. The special course area is where the fun begin.

Mastapeece should be the top rank's name

Galaxy 1 and 2 are the best mario games ever made, prove me wrong.

They went too far with the linearity, it feels like a very slow 2D mario, it's great but it is clearly one of the worst Marios.

No replay value. I got 120 stars on my first playthrough on a single sitting, just to realize post game is the same exact game but with slippery shoes and a higher jump.

And what about Mario 3d Land?

3>world

This will make worldbabys SEETH

you should have taken some breaks.

Linearity was understandable, IIRC the levels are shorter, besides portability helped a lot.

STILL

Move Sunshine into it's own category titled Bad Games.

Which game are Dark Soul of Mario game? And why not Sunshine?

I couldn't I fucking love that game.

>We have Edith Finch, which is basically the game adaptation of Gone Home
Why do we have this guy again?

>a complete game is better than an incomlete game shat out for a tight release on a new console

who would have thought

I completely agree though I have really fond memories of Sunshine. I think the games above it are better, but Sunshine holds a dear place in my heart anyway.

>Dark Soul of Mario game
mario 64 hacks

>thinks Bloodborne and DS3 are better than DeS and DS1
How bad can taste get? I didn't think it was possible.

Its way more hardcore than dark sole tho

6 Golden Coins should be higher.
Galaxy games should be much lower.

good enough, but these:

this is true

This mother fucker.

>putting Mario Land 1 and 2 with that low tier shit
>3D World/Land are somehow better
The rest is fine by me but come on now. Switch them and we're good.

Galaxy games are weird. First impressions were god-tier but then they got old and I never want to play them again. Meanwhile I've played Sunshine and 64 ad nauseam and they still hold up. Fucking incredible games.

I played 6 Golden Coins so much, it definitely deserves at least Real Good, maybe not Mastapeece. It's on par with Warioland 1.

oh, another nitpick: new super mario bros is not a good game

Lost Levels if you count only official Mario game.

I didn't like the first SML
The second one is top tier and is arguably the best 2D one by far.

the gameboy games are extrmely short with shitty hitboxes and bosses, take off those nostalgia goggles

Dunkey has such shit taste in 3D platformers. Mario 64 is absolute mediocre at best and l i t e r a l l y only nostalgiafags disagree

Sunshine should be in its own bad game category. Worst 3D Mario.

Mario 64 is a classic and literally only people with arin-tier skill disagree

>shitty hitboxe
I never had a problem with this. The only real problem I had was the lag caused when more then two things were on the screen. The DX version fixed this and still think SML2 is the best 2D Mario game.

3D World is my favorite game in the series

you can die anytime you like faggot

Came here to say this

this, best music too, the staff roll is the best mario song ever made

NSMBU kicks NSMB's ass user. Not only is it a much more fleshed out game without retarded giga mini powerup spam, but it has NSLU which is without a doubt the best entry in the entire NSMB series.

Odyssey isn't even good enough to be in the mastapeece section. It's just a "real good game" at best.

>Sunshine is bad meme
Being a contrarian doesn't make you smart Sup Forums

The only thing World did better was secret exits and the world map. 3's level design is objectively superior.

It was good back when there were no other 3D platformers during gen 5. Crash and Banjo were both direct upgrades.
I get that it was babby's first nintendo game but Mario 64 is not that good.

>SMB3 > SMW
Literally how? Legit question here.

>First impressions were god-tier but then they got old and I never want to play them again
It's because Mario has a significantly reduced moveset and is stuck at a constant speed. Combined with levels that try to be like 64/Sunshine but are too small and pure platforming sections that pale compared to 2D Mario or latter entries like 3D Land/World you get dull game.

How will SMW fags, ---------EVER------- RECOVER

SMB to Mario 3 is a bigger jump than Mario 3 to World.

And overall physics and aesthetic. It's a shame they shit the bed with the powerups, since everything fun was taken out but the fucking cape stayed.

t. Underage who never played these when they released

Better powerups, better level design in general, doesn't have anything as retarded as the cape.

Better power-ups, more power-ups, better level design.

I bet you weren't even alive when SMB3 was released.

Doki Doki Panic is a good game.

of course, it's Mario reskin is the game of the year, all years, forever

>NSMB Wii being that low

That was the best in the series. Had the fucking best time playing through that shit with my bro

This is master-level baiting

NOT a mario game.

>and is stuck at a constant speed
this is never a good idea. Makes movement boring as fuck

It's a fantastic game and I love it much more than Odyssey somehow. I was so excited for Odyssey and yet ended up very disappointed at how lackluster it was in terms of music and style

Asshurt worldfags getting shit on is good.

They are the sunshinefags of 2d mario

SMB3>NSMBU>SMW
is this correct?

>Sunshine in masterpiece zone and not on bottom
>Mario Bros, Mario Land, Mario Land 2 not masterpiece zone

Fuck off

What the fuck makes SML1 a masterpiece?

I personally enjoy SMS more than 64 and Galaxy but it is probably a worse game
Though Yoshi's Island deserves to be top tier, it's fucking perfect

Galaxy>Galaxy 2>Sunshine>Odyssey>64

NSMBU is basically the same game as NSMB Wii, they have to be on the same tier.

NSMBU is the most underrated 2D Mario game by a landslide. God tier platforming mechanics and ridiculously polished level design.

If NSMB1, 2, and Wii didn't exist people would be consistently ranking NSMBU as one of the best in the series. But because the NSMB label got overused for mediocre garbage the name itself just became associated with mediocre garbage.

>Galaxy 1 above Galaxy 2
I'm not even going to bother with the rest of your shit list because it's already wrong.
>b-b-but muh storybook

Good controls
fun level design
incredibly memorable aesthetic and music

They are present in both games?

>edits out Odyssey in the Big Boys tier

half the people here dont even know this is a dunkey thread

>Dunkey likes Sunshine
gross

Being a great 2D Mario is a good thing, though. It is the best 3D Mario for sure.

t. soyny poster

True, but all are 10/10, so who cares?

What Mario games fall under "not that good"?

The GBA ports.

Yoshi's island > 3 > World

ports of the same game.

Sunshine

seconding ports and this