Seems like the site is working again. So let's discuss this accurate chart I made

Seems like the site is working again. So let's discuss this accurate chart I made.
I can understand if someone feels that the tier list can be tweeked a little, but I think we can all agree that the F tier should remain as it is.

Hifumi is best girl, couldn't care less about the rest of the list.

Yeah let's put the same girl in there twice.

>makoto
>not E rank
Wait 100 more years before posting again.

I almost made an A+ rank just for her, but I decided against it in the end.

Holy shit, this is such a garbage chart.

Thank you for being objectively correct

>I can understand if someone feels that the tier list can be tweeked a little, but I think we can all agree that the F tier should remain as it is.

So you basically just wanted a thread for shitposting about futaba?

>ranking P5 girls
You have much to learn.

>F is for Futaba
Fucking
P O T T E R Y

Finally a good list. My wife Hifumi is truly best girl.

Holy shit this list is garbage,Mitsuru beats any P5 girl anyways so I don't care.

Not spesifically. I just feel like it's not worth including people that has such a bad taste that they like Futaba.

For example, if I were to discuss what type of food is better. Chicken, Beef, Fish etc. Then I would feel justified to not include people that thinks feaces is better than any of the other choices.

S+: Kawakami, Futaba
A: Chihaya, Makoto, Tae, Caroline, Justine
B: Hifumi, Sae, Haru
C: Ann, Ohya
D: Shadow Sae, Lavenza

Switch Lavenza and Kawakami and Tae with Futaba and this would be accurate.

Ohya should be in F but otherwise not bad

Here's an actual, not shit chart.

A: Kawakami, Chihaya
B: Ann, Tae, Futaba, Ohya
C: Haru, Twins
D: Makoto, Hifumi

I do not care about your tier lists I just love my wife Ann.

This is the part where I'd normally start posting cute haru images but the board is broken :(

>Kawakami high up
Already flawed.

I've noticed many people here doesn't like her. For what reason? She has that nice big sister role, and she is a cutie as well.

Here is the objectively correct tier list.

S+: Shadow Sae
S: Sae
A: Futaba, Tae, Kawakami
B: Makoto, Ann, Haru, Lavenza
C: Chihaya, Hifumi, Caroline, Justine
D: Ohya
F: (You)

This but Hifumi a bit higher and Kawakami lower.

hey just started the game
first arc felt fantastic but this second one with the art shit feels dreadful
first one had a lot of shit going on at once with the mystery backstory going on with why joker was captured, an antagonist that felt like a real bad guy, and some really nice foreshadowing

but what the fuck is with this second section? the things going on are shitty at worst. so what if a kid killed himself because he couldnt have his way

She has a drinking problem, is ugly, has a worthless confidant bonus and is just generally uninteresting.

Hifumi was a fraud user. But you can blame Makoto for that I suppose.

Because most of these people here are babbies scared of alcohol.

You switched up the Niijima sisters there (I too suffer from dyslexia) and Anne is one tier too gifg for me. Hifumi a best.

>like the doctor the most
>she has an awful english dub
oh well

So play in JP. Her voice is great there.

So yeah you wanted a futaba shitposting thread

She likes to drink, so what? Didn't seem like it was a problem. I don't remember her confidant bonus, but that doesn't matter so much for best girl title.

>is ugly
Oh... You are trolling.

I dunno, I already am pretty used to the dub and I really like some of the dubs. Ryuji, Morgana, and Sojiro are awesome and I would hate to give them up. The coach was really well done too. A lot of the female characters dubs seem pretty bad though. Not too far in though.

>Playing english dub
animegirlrestingherheadinherhand.jpg

Yes, she has a problem. You would know that if you did her confidant. Why do you think she basically lives at the bar?
>you don't agree with me so you must be trolling
Let me stop you right there.

Then let's talk. Why do you think Ohya's garbage?

Usually I stay with nip dubs on nip games but that's mostly because dubs are usually pretty bad. When there is the choice for a well done dub then I usually pick that. I find it easier to relate to the characters and keep up with the story when I can immediately understand and internalize what they're saying. Also I really liked the P4 dub so figured this one would be pretty good.

I got her to max rank as well romancing her. I don't remember the drinking being a real problem, but maybe I am just miss-remembering.

Come on, how can you say she is ugly?
Not the best looking in the game, sure. But ugly!?

>Kawakami and Haru that low
>Ohya above F rank

I'm actually vomiting

I've already told you why, but you don't want to have an honest discussion.
She goes through entire bottles of liquor in a single night. The bartender comments on how much she drinks on several occasions. And it's not even that late in the night when Joker visits her.

>he goes through entire bottles of liquor in a single night. The bartender comments on how much she drinks on several occasions

So she likes to drink. I don't see a problem with it.

>she's uninteresting
She's far more engaging than Makoto or Hifumi.

Makoto has plot relevance. Hifumi is almost the same but without the drinking problem and with shogi instead of clickbait journalism.

Hifumi fags need to die, she is literally a nothing character

Makoto is best girl

What a shitty list, as expected of a Hifumifag

Kawakami is anything below shit tier.
She's attached to ryugi.

Literally just move Haru to S+
Don't really care about anyone else, all I know is that Haru = Hifumi and Futaba is absolute garbage teir and deserves F rank.

Good taste except Ohya is trash and Lavenza > twins.

Makoto's plot relevance is so forced it hurts. But besides that, I meant in terms of her Confidant. It has to be the dullest out of the entire game. And it's not even about her.

Makoto is best girl, Hifumi is legit Larry 2.0

i didn't care for haru when she was first introduced but she really grew on me by the end of the game, if i wasn't already dating makoto i definitely would've gone for her. futaba's good too

>implying larry 2.0 is worse then makoto

Persona 5 is a shit game, fuck off

Thread is now a P3 thread, who is the best waifu and why is it aigis

>Aigisfag
>calling anything shit

P3 is a shit game. This is now a P2 thread.

Maya a best!

>implying any girl from the newer games even compares
LMAO
Outdated trash

Literally any girl is better than babby’s first waifu