Now tha the dust has settled, what's your veredict on this?

Now tha the dust has settled, what's your veredict on this?

It has no castles and no metroids

Overrated game

...

Decent but very overrated, clearly got the indie darling treatment

Nice shill thread.

It's a bad game by a bad dev. You can tell they made up the lore as they went along.

how do i buy rabi rabi without my normalfag friends thinking I'm a paedo?

You don't and you are.

GotY 2017

>having normalfag friends

This gets stupider each time I see it
What the fuck is Marrow? Did its dev make this image?

Its a good game

Terraria is NOT a metroidvania

Change your profile pic to cropped Nekopara porn and pretend you're ironic

Remove the furryshit and flip it upside down

I'm looking at this list and most games look like they came out in 1990

the difficulty is all over the place, it spikes and troughs seemingly at random

controls like shit, too floaty

LEGIT most SHILLED game on this board
by shilled I mean samefag aspergers groundhog day tier obsession GENERALS

Call it shill or what ever I don't give a fuck but it was my personal GOTY.
If I usually pirate indie shit and even more kickstarded crap.
This is the ONLY game I grabbed full price on steam after playing pirating it for 15 hours.
No pixel vomit graphics.
Awesome soundtrack without elecro or synthwave.
Nice story telling.
Gigantic contents.
challenging.

it's have some problem but they are minor and most of them got patched.
Free DLC too.
Maybe not the best game ever but definitely on of the best Metroidvania I done to this day.
This list is garbage.

non meme answer: too much backtracking. 7.5/10

It's pretty good
Platforming feels really bad and I feel like partially due to that the movement mechanics feel boring as fuck
Combat gets repetitive after a while

not even worth a pirate

BAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA THHHUUUUUUUUUUNNNNNNNNDDDAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

It's fine overall, but here's my small laundry list of pedantic bitching
>Pacing is too slow, especially at the start, you could beat a Metroid game in the time that it takes to get to the point when the map starts to open up
>Movement/platforming doesn't feel all that fun due to the lack of any momentum and overall slow speed
>Charm slots felt too limited, I would've preferred if they were far more liberal so that you could go wild with them
>Losing your money on death feels kind of arbitrary, it ultimately only serves to make the player waste their time if they somehow end up losing a bunch of their money early on, but quickly becomes pointless when money gets plentiful to the point of being useless
>Map system is dumb and counter-intuitive, either give me a proper detailed map or a very minimal one that essentially leaves me to my own devices, not this stupid shit that doesn't even fill out the map when I'd actually need it to

this. it's like they tried doing things differently in many cases just for the sake of being different.

>chance to lose money if you massively fuck up
it tries to give death more weight but you're really not informed of the mechanic until it happens (i think) and by the time you find out you just go, "well fuck, all that time i wasted grabbing coins was a waste. i guess i'll just treat money as disposable from now on."
>map only fills out after you've saved
why? it's not even a big deal it's just silly shit.

Is La Mulana actually good?

Yeah, it's one of the most deep and complex metroidvanias out there

But is it fun?

This

Which version do I play?

The remake.

Yes, unless you're a turboshitter with no skills or brain.

We just don't know
Only person I have ever seen talking about Marrow was that autist

good game

you can tell because autists get frightened by it

Don't believe the lies of pastas like this, it's a 10/10

If you say so

A tier list bait works the best if most of the people seeing have not played many of those games.
You put old and/or niche at the top, popular and/or newer ones on the bottom and just wait for the sweet (you)s to pour in.

>Metroidvania
>caring about the lore
Lol read a book instead of play it

>Aquaria
I get that it's held in really high esteem, but how do you get past how insanely slow and annoying singing is?
It's an enjoyable game, but I don't get how much people love it.

Alright, I bought the 2012 version on GOG. Looks fun.

>terraria
>no guacamelee

Yeah okay

DOMA DOMA DOMADOMADOMA
HA HA

Easily my favorite game of last year. Still want to know how it got made on a budget of $50k

shill everywhere

the best 8.5/10 game I've ever played
it's a simple game that more or less does everything right but doesn't do anything 10/10 incredible
great music and storytelling, even with the lore being a dark souls rip-off
the start is way too goddamn slow, especially with how huge the map is. The sprintmaster charm should have been the default movement
the combat is very barebones, the bosses really help with this but there aren't enough bosses and not enough of them stand out like Dung Defender, Soul Master, and Grimm
a lot of my complaints come from the game being too simple (movement, charms, combat)

POST THE REAL ONE ALREADY
also that reminds me I have to play Salt&Sanctuary still

>everyone that likes a game that I don't is a shill

i really really enjoyed it and ive never really played many metroidvanias. people that say it's a 2d dark souls are not memeing. it can be argued that this game's story and atmosphere do dark souls better than dark souls does dark souls

Game of the generation.

The switch release is supposed to be out today, why isn't it in the eshop?

I loved the absolute shit out of it and I've never actually played a Metroidvania game.

I'm doing my first playthrough right now and loving it

Shill general

Last I checked, there was never a definite day given for the Switch release.