Which of these should I replay?

Which of these should I replay?

Both
But depends on gen preference at some point
A lot of people here will say Plat tho

Not OP. Haven't played a pokemon game since Diamond. Are any of them worth the trouble?

Platinum is better than Diamond or Pearl.
HGSS is a great remake.
Black and White and Black and White 2 are the pinnacle of the series in my opinion.

The shift to 3d really fucked with the series and we really haven't recovered from it yet.

Platinum’s the best in the series imho

Platinum first because it's worse imo then SS.
Get an electric type because every other trainer has a Gyarados.

platinum and bw/bw2 are god tier, xy are ok, oras sucks and sm are pretty meh

Those, along with Black and White 2, are the best Pokémon games. If you're an old Pokémon fan, you're more likely to have replayed Gen 2 more, so go for Platinum to remember the cool things about it.

What's wrong with Sun and Moon besides the graphics?

platinum, soul silver is trash

The graphics are fine.

Coming from UM: There's a too large emphasis on storytelling, making it feel like you're held back all the time.

terrible load times between everything, extremely compartmentalized areas that kill the sense of exploration, dumb trials, totem Pokémon are a waste of a concept, very linear structure (more than usual), braindead difficulty, more cutscenes than Metal Gear games while having a dumb story, extremely small number of original pokémon etc.

The graphics are fine.
It's just that the game is so slow

>being an adult
>replaying vanilla pokemon games when romhacks exist

seriously, you have to literally be a child to find the difficulty compelling

Don't bother with the vanilla games
kaizo crystal then Emerald complete national dex then volt white 2

Platinum.
Unless you played Gen II as a kid, in which case SS.

Name a good romhack and not just another "give all trainers 6 ev trained comp pokemon and a stupid level curve where you're 100 by the end of the game" romhack.

>muh being able to catch all the pokemon right away
wow romhacks are so great...

Or Sacred Gold

Sacred Gold and Storm Silver. They're really good desu

Why?

Imagine being this much of a retard?

To many improvements to list.

Heart Gold

Here's the real question:

Which pokemon is the best for a nuzlocke?

Are there any romhacks where the AI will swap out pokemon when they are countered?

Vanilla Heartgold and Soulsilver do that already.

Black and White 2 > Platinum > Heart Gold and Soul Silver > Black & White > Leaf Green and Fire Red > Crystal > Emerald > Gold and Silver > Omega Ruby and Alpha Sapphire > Red and Blue > Diamond and Pearl > Sun and Moon > X and Y

Black and White

I... I think I agree with this list. Where the fuck is Yellow, though?

Right before Red and Blue. I forgot about it.

Yeah.

It plays fine, definitely not a great pokemon game but not X/Y tier bad imo
same reasons X/Y suffered tho, the pacing is just god awful, with a lot of slow dumb cutscenes, stupid dialogue, also what
says, it feels like you are moving around from container to container rather than exploring a wonderful, jungle filled island

Are you actually so dumb that this is what you believe romhacks do?

>yellow that low

>sun/moon high tier
>Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire shit tier
are you even trying

Here, I fixed it.

>Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire anything BUT shit tier
Are you?

Pokemon threads should stay on /vp/, please post there next time.

First time I see somebody actually getting it 100% right

USUM is shit tier, son