Overrated or legitimate classic?

Overrated or legitimate classic?

Attached: A7747529-39EA-4F9F-B3D4-289849B0C315.jpg (300x216, 44K)

I want to remind everyone that something being overrated does not mean it's bad.

Classic.

Okay, sure

It's simply rated

Classic.

I replayed got pissed off at the sewer shark level kept drowning
Overrated piece of shit

Both.

Aw, name a classic that isn't overrated.

Masterpiece

I think it's great, and I played it many years later on an emulator.

I like collectathons

Good game, but horrendously overrated

I liked Banjo Tooie better honestly.

one of my favourite games of all time. GOAT soundtrack too, I haven't played it in 10 years and I can still remember the songs from all the different worlds

yeah

Super metroid
SM64
Crash 2
Chrono trigger
Alien soldier
Street of Rage 2
Sonic 2
Donkey Kong Country
Suikoden 2
Okami
God hand
Silent hill.
IMO Overrated.

never liked thismdk64 or conker. even as a kid

Do people actually consider it a classic? It's just a good N64 game, nothing more nothing less

Classic

>>SM64
>>Crash 2
>>Chrono Trigger
>>Sonic 2
>>Okami
>>Donkey Kong Country
>not overrated
Calm down lad

What's overrated about them ?

Neither.
It's probably the best of the collect-a-thon genre, second to or ahead of tooie depending on if you like world interconnection or dislike needing to leave worlds unfinished.

But it didn't really set a foundation for subsequent games and its fanbase doesn't sperg out nearly as much as SM64s or OOTs

Legit classic, doesn't have SM64's trick-jump platforming but it keeps you interested all the same if not better.

Nothing, they're just well known which obviously means overrated and therefore shit.

>SM64
First big attempt at a 3D platformer, obviously shows a lot of rough patches and doesn't deserve the worship it gets now
>Crash 2
Improved on the first immensely but still limited due to hardware
>Chrono trigger
Held up as the god of all JRPGs, when it's basic as hell. Only thing great about it is the art style
>Sonic 2
Basically the same as 1. In general sonic is overrated, it's platforming with a twist and "hip" designs
>Okami
Stylistic approach to zelda I enjoyed, but the puzzles were simple and the combat added width but no depth. The focus on combat made it tedious
>Donkey Kong Country
Ugly as sin and controls like ass

they aren't bad games, I actually like most of them, but they seriously don't deserve the heaps of praise they get as "best games of all time"

inb4 someone reductively responds to my points

You are a moron who ask games for standard that didn't even exist and for some wouldn't exist without them been released.

The only game that never deserved it best game of all time is Zelda nes and more recently BOTW.
As compared to the games of their times they give nothing new and in the case of Zelda nes it make the genre horrible and tedious to play.

Why shouldn't old games be judged by a modern standard? a "classic" should be timeless

>Super metroid
>SM64
>Crash 2
>Chrono trigger
>Donkey Kong Country
>Suikoden 2
>Okami
>God hand
>Silent hill.
Absolutely overrated.

>First big attempt at a 3D platformer
(Not true, by the way.)

Alpha Waves has it beat by 6 years.

Classic

You are even more retarded than expected.

If we go with your 1 digit IQ logic Metropolis is garbage overrated movie because no dialog,color and CGI. and the pacing is strange.
Please never talk to me again.

I see what you did there.

>hur dur you can't judge games outside of the context of their times

You can if they're good.

Legit classic.

I didn't even read your post but i can tell you are a big contrarian fag.

A better reason why Metropolis is shit is that they lost a lot of footage and you can't watch the whole movie. It's like a book with pages missing. The most important aspect of any game is being able to play it.

Your examples implies that I think there are no good old games, which is not even remotely true. A modern standard doesn't mean "if it doesn't have x it's shit or if it looks old it's bad"

Super Metroid is an example of an old game that holds up perfectly and is a classic. Hell going even further back, Missle Command is also a classic that stands the test of time. A good classic utilizes it's tools to create something that isn't bogged down by their then current trends

Didn't I say to never talk to me again ?
Nigger that was true maybe 10 years ago but now the movie is 99% restored. (minus a shorter ratio for some rush)

Excuse me for not downloading the latest Metropolis patch, I have the gog.com version. I remember when they used to finish games before shipping them out.

It’s overrated trash, a kowabonga piece of shit. Shit le quirky character, hopeless cynical nihilistic undertones reflectef by the claustrophobic level design, shit control, no real drama, collectacoon

Yeah FWMS released a patch for vanilla metropolis 10 years ago. with all DLC and compatible with DX12 and widescreen.kys

A bit of both.

SM64 is overrated as fuck

I liked the sequel better because of how it had great bosses, legitimately good minigames and had a much greater scope. The only advantage Kazooie has over Tooie is that old fucks like us don't have the time anymore to justify 100 percenting Tooie.

this is a legit classic. One of the best 3D platformers ever.

Attached: 1465051971566.jpg (1374x1600, 396K)

Sooo over rated

Classic. But Jesus Christ this is game legitimate nightmare fuel.

Pretty well rated. I like the sequel even more though.

Attached: etrian-odyssey-iv-npcs.jpg (1280x1024, 1.38M)

I still can't believe how this is a kids game

It's a classic, but it is overrated only when people compare it to Tooie.

Clanker's is such a weird difficulty spike, probably 'cause it's THE water world of the game. Even the swamp is easier and that's the next world.

What exactly makes the game "overrated"? Whenever someone exclaims that something is overrated I usually just get the impression they want to boldly show off how different and controversial their opinion is since they almost never elaborate on what exactly they had an issue with.
If you think Banjo-Kazooie is overrated please give me three clear and concise things about the core gameplay that weren't up to your standards. I'm genuinely curious.

Both

Played it for the first time with Rare Replay. Legit couldn't stand this game for how mindless it was, but was an instant fan of the second and it became a top 5 game for me. I see BK as a potential fantastic game for the time that got weary in 2004-2005 and then after the HD era was simply to clunky. It HAS to exist in order for the sequel to exist you know?

Both.

overrated classic

The majority of the list is overrated retard.

Classic

Yeah i'm shocked it got away with it too

I can't remember anything too bad from the first game, the second game was a lot edgier, though.

>God Had
Pretty much the definition of overrated.

I played t for the first time last year, so i had no nostalgia goggles, It is really great.