Which is better open world game?

Which is better open world game?

Attached: botw & gta.jpg (656x686, 187K)

Other urls found in this thread:

boards.fireden.net/v/search/text/nintendo open world very first attempt/
youtu.be/kQcGILE2SeA
twitter.com/AnonBabble

Zelda is the better action adventure world, V is the better sim world.

GTA III was more the equivalent of what Zelda just did.

Let's see, play as some sissy little faggot with a broken sword who likes to cook mushrooms or play as a hardass all american negro that does cool shit like fuck whores and murder innocent bystanders while tripping pcp. I think the choice is obvious.

Threads like these are why normal people don't take toddlers seriously

BotW by a fucking mile. If you don't understand why you're either an in-denial shitter or a clueless child who doesn't understand what the fuck 'Game Design' is.

GTA V because it's actually fun to play and the world isn't copypaste filler

Both are good, but I enjoyed BotW more because the world didn't feel as empty as V

nintendo kids can get fucked but GTA5 is literally a meme game

people buy it because they consider it THE video game. you get to shoot, you get to drive, you get to walk around and talk, you get to punch. its the big cheese despite not actually being a quality gameplay experience. fuck it.

GTA you dumb nintensoy

>the world isn't copypaste filler

Attached: no.gif (437x304, 736K)

>on the rails the open world game
Seething

>but I enjoyed BotW more because the world didn't feel as empty as V

Tell me, is this bait or some derranged people seriously think like this?

BotW is GOAT. GTAV sucks.

What is there to do in GTA V outside of scripted missions?

Zelda

Depends on what you want. If you want to explore a large space with little to direction as to what you "should" be doing, BotW is the one. But if you want to be given a bunch of quests and tasks so you can earn those spicy achievements then GTA is more suited for that.

So you're saying they're both copy paste filler?

Dark Souls 1

both suck dick go play something better

Fucking thousands of activities, both on single player and multiplayer. It was designed to be a real world SIM.

I don't know about Zelda but GTA V was fucking boring.

>microstuttering the game vs shark cards
Shark Cards is better by a fucking mile

Oh yeah like...

Every building in the giant city plus 3 smaller towns is uniquely modelled. Boring of the Wild devs didn't even bother to make unique stables for each village

Back the fuck up, shit eaters.

Attached: Xenoblade_Chronicles_X_-_Boxart.jpg (283x351, 48K)

BotW redefined open ended map design.
GTA redefined microtransaction cash cows.
My pick is BotW.

Damn, a bunch of completely static, unbreakable and unenterable buildings. I remember that on the PS2.

Better than Neptuniablade 2 but still mediocre as all hell

I'm not gonna spon feed you or bite your bait. It's clear you're a toddler who never played the game.

No, this guy did

Attached: 1499132304396.png (500x209, 108K)

This is a dumb comparison because the only thing these games share is a large, seamless world. Nothing else is similar.

2 isn’t open world, but you have shit taste anyway because both were excellent.

You got as many arguments as GTA V has shit to do.

hitting things with sticks is still more fun then bad gunplay

>BotW redefined Open-ended map design
No, it didn't, and anyone that actually believes this is also a happy volunteer for the bleach drinking contest. It's the same, shitty, open-world design as many games that came before it, and Nintenbros are just catching up when, ironically, XCX already came out and had a far more interesting world to explore.

That being said, GTA is just as trash. If I had to choose between two such overglorified pieces of shit, I'd give up gaming. Fuck the brainless tards who like both.

BLESS BE GABE

>Neptuniablade 2 is excellent

OHNONONONO

Attached: xenotrash6.webm (640x360, 2.97M)

Ok Gabe

>opinionated drivel changes objective truth
I wish I had a dollar for every time some autist tries this shit.

>my opinion is stronger than your opinion
I'd recommend you to smile into the webcam, cause soon your photo will be in dictionary right next to the word "delusional"

Attached: 1516206776376.gif (540x303, 2.56M)

In V sometimes you might see 2 guys randomly trying to bury a women alive and you can help save her, motorcycle gang may randomly rob a pedestrian and you can chase them down and return/keep the money, some women may have been a car accident and you can give her a lift to the hospital, a labourer is trapped inside a Truck after some pipes fall on top of the truck and block the doors and you gotta use a Dozer to push the pipes away from the doors and allow the man to escape, before the shit explodes, sometimes you gotta help a celebrity escape from all the paperazzi, some gang may have robbed some store and randomly ask you to help them get away. You can also try find aliens, solve a murder, find bigfoot, become the paparazzi and chase down fake Lindsey Lohan, pick up hitch-hikers, derail a train. Then there's shit like Buying property, Taxi missions, Triathlon, Mountainbiking, Tennis ,Golf, Yoga, Scubadiving, Arms trafficking, Bike/motorcycle/car/ATV/Jetski races , Skydiving and basejumping, bounty hunting, Assassination contracts, Hunting animals and Treasure hunting underwater.

Zelda BOTW is boring as fuck, enjoy paying dlc just to ride a motorcycle in Zelda LMFAO

Attached: No way.jpg (821x377, 68K)

Just imagine the Zelda that will come after the mold was broken by BotW. In another 2 or 3 games I think we might actually get a game to surpass OoT/MM

GTAV was linear as shit.

I’m a complete Nintendo fanboy, but given the number of systems and scope of GTAV, it probably is a better open world game. It just has more going on.

I like the mechanics of the first game better, but that doesn’t mean much in this context.

>and had a far more interesting world to explore
That's an opinion not a fact.

BotW is Zeldas GTAIII type sandbox. Give it a break. It will happen one of these days. Japan is slow to catch up. The colsest any of them came to GTAV was MGSV and Kojima was fired and hes doing his own thing with Sony now

>BotW redefined open ended map design
That's an opinion not a fact.

NintendoGaf is fucking hilarious with its Zelda dicksucking.

GTAV was so dissapointing. The only sandbox aspect of it it's the same formula GTA1 had back in the day with no evolution in gameplay. And the missions are just boring pointing and clicking.

I afree that BotW didnt redefife open world design but Zelda is in General is based. Its the only sacred thing on Nintendo. Its about a blonde haired blue eyed kid(Link) who battles black muslim from the desert (Ganon) and has a posutive messafe in each game. Unlike GTAV which message is really dark and twisted for kids yet more play GTAV than Zelda sadly

Both games easily make my top 20 of all-time but I'm going to have to go with V here.

I'm not the user you're talking to, just making a point. Which you just strawmanned but didn't disprove.

I was actually bothered to finish GTA, so GTA

Big fucking pseud

There's a reason why gta v still charts in 2018, there's actual shit to do

I love GTA and GTAV itself in particular. It is my favorite in the series since San Andreas. However that being said it should be a crime for parents to let there kids play GTAV

GTA V sold more copies last year than the Switch and it's a game from 2013

that truly matters when you can't enter a single one of them

they look pretty but man GTAV's map manages to be even emptier than BotW's

TES 2 Daggerfall

BotW by a country mile.

BotW has a more immersive world with incricately connected systems of weather/climate/environment which encourge constant adaptation from the player and the game design allows for so much unrestricted freedom of exploration and the ability to fashion your own solutions based on how you want to approach situations. There's nothing else quite like it.

too bad it has no content outside of samey shrines and 4 tiny dungeons
sad!

>GTAV
>Content

Try playing without an internet connection, see what's left.

70 story missions, several dozen side missions and activities, hundreds of vehicles to drive and plenty of korok seed tier shit to collect

your point?

>too bad it has no content

Yeah keep living in denial kid. Its only been a year.

the irony is there is more content offline

Attached: 1403232215412dd.jpg (155x151, 6K)

Doesn't make it a better open world game. Cry til the cows come home because Nintendo redefined open world games forever on their very first attempt. Wew.

>70 story missions
70 drive from point A to point B 'missions'

>activities
yoga, golf, tennis, and cab driver, how entertaining.

>hundreds of vehicles to drive
when they all drive the same.

>korok seed tier shit to collect
Somehow even less interesting than korok hunting.

boards.fireden.net/v/search/text/nintendo open world very first attempt/

keep spamming this all you like, doesn't make your mediocre Ubisoft clone any better

Shrines and koroks are not content

>B-B-B-BUT THOSE DON'T COUNT!!

Attached: soytendo.gif (726x400, 1.13M)

What an obnoxious shitposter.
Even R* devs have praised BotW, Ubisoft devs said they changed the open world paradigm, Witcher 3 devs said that it seemed effortless but taught them a lesson in map design.
But some random nobody says that's not true so it must not be true.

>I didnt play the game
The post

Industry professionals have to walk on eggshells when speaking about Nintendo.

No mentioning their lazy games, shitty hardware, and anti-consumer business practices or they call in their Yakuza contacts and "accidents" happen...

Attached: switch blackmail.jpg (737x605, 59K)

God did they really think that overplayed shitty anime gag would still be a funny inclusion? I fucking hate what they did with Xenoblade 2.

>Shrines and koroks are not content

So 100 completely unique subterranean chambers containing their own challenges is content.

Get fucked you desperate shitter. Oh how I am laughing at you. Stay mad at Nintendo, I love your pain.

>Industry professionals have to walk on eggshells when speaking about Nintendo.

lmao its conspiracy theory time lads!

>moving the goalposts
like clockwork. Does it invalidate the praise? no it doesn't. It does help you rationalize it which is what you're doing. BotW is still a masterpiece, but please do keep posting about it nonstop for another year, that will change things.

ez

Attached: Saints_Row_2_Game_Cover.jpg (256x320, 46K)

Grand Theft Auto Five.

>BotW is still a masterpiece
Hahaha

Shitendo is determined to destroy their own legacy one franchise at a time. Looking forward to whatever cancerous gimmicks they force into Metroid Prime 4.
Tick.. tock.. tick.. tock...

Attached: disaster of the wild10.webm (853x480, 2.98M)

Yves Guillemot:
>“It’s interesting, because The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild took a lot of things that existed in Far Cry and other Ubisoft games, but did them perfectly,” Guillemot told Edge magazine. “I think the most important thing is not the systems as they are, it’s how they can be perfected; how they can give the player the best experience possible.”
Benjamin Pilch:
>Breath of the Wild showed something most designers already know, but which is hard to achieve... [these games are] evolving from classic open worlds to an open-game model - open progression following each player's intrinsic motivations, adaptive challenge curve and economy, open narrative structures, and so on.
Damien Monnier:
>Breath of the Wild has managed to bring classic open world mechanics together while not relying on them to guide the player through its world. You go and explore it because you wonder what's out there, not because a loot icon tells you to.

My expectations, and I mean for me as a Zelda fan, have changed for sure - they've raised the bar when it comes to world crafting and this sense of total immersion I get when I play it. While its world includes classic open-world activities, collectibles and loot-filled mobs, it definitely doesn't feel overloaded and allows the focus be on the exploration. You want to explore this land whether or not you are on a quest, or being tasked to collect/gather something. You know, If you were to remove all NPCs, quests and mobs, I would still take pleasure in exploring that beautiful world.

VS
Random shitposter:
>Hahaha

Hmmmmm who do I believe?

Christ, the denial is truly off the charts. Nintendo really ravaged these poor sonykids

Didn't read any of your post. Industry professional "opinions" are meaningless but we know for a fact what happens to critics with integrity who call out Nintendo's shit
see

GTA5 because you can kill niggers.

gta 5 > any faggy zelda

>didn't read any of your post
Because you're an intellectually dishonest retard who actually believes "hahaha" as a retort proves anything.
It's been an entire year, let go. Deal with the fact that it got praised and move on.

>GTA III was more the equivalent of what Zelda just did.

How?
I don't understand this, sure BOTW was fun but it wasn't anything revolutionary

>Didn't read any of your post.
AHAHAHAHAHAH keep putting your fingers in your ears, stomp your feet and shout LALALALALA you sad little child.

Keep imagining all the conspiratorial bogeymen you will let you sleep easy at night. Far more plausible than just admitting Nintendo made a good game.

I've been watching you sperg out on this board over a year now. I never get tired of watching you contort in mental anguish. Its simply marvellous and makes me feel great.

It was praised because Shintendo holds critics hostage
see

Got any more conspiracy theories there kid? BotW will still be a masterpiece at the end of the day.

>BOTW was fun but it wasn't anything revolutionary

Of course it is. But it won't start a revolution.

because other devs are too lazy to do what Nintendo did

youtu.be/kQcGILE2SeA

>Damien Monnier
>held hostage
He has literally never released a game on a nintendo platform how was he held hostage

Because when you criticize Shitendo you get fired, or worse. Remember their CEO is ex-Yakuza

see

>more conspiracy theories instead of admitting that Nintendo made a good game
Imagine being this absolutely fucking desperate to hold your worldview.

>absolute irrefutable evidence
>"conspiracy theory LALALA CAN'T HEAR YOU NINTENDO IS PERFECT"

This is the power of the cult of Based Nintendo. Corporations don't love you. They aren't your friends. You need to grow up and break this programming, user.

GTASA

The guy you're arguing with has been shitposting relentlessly every hour of every day for over a year now. He's utterly deranged and beyond reproach. The GDC Awards are currently underway and rival devs will soon shower more praise on the game and this poor fuck will still be trying to retcon the past year.

>absolute irrefutable evidence
>some conjecture about someone being fired, something that was never said nor confirmed
>LALALALA CAN'T HEAR YOU
>right after he did the exact same shit when quoted developers praising Zelda
Irony is lost on you

cunt

Some zelda cuck try tell me what BOTW offers in comparison to thisWhat the fuck do NPC's even do in BOTW? Name activities that you can even do in BOTW

Attached: 1489316889262.jpg (512x502, 146K)

>some conjecture about someone being fired, something that was never said nor confirmed

A tweet from the man himself isn't proof enough? Nintendo's programming really has done a number on you. Glad I'm not the kind of weak-willed person who falls for cult mentality

BotW with its pile of meaningless unrelated micro activities that barely ever escalate in difficulty or scope is pretty much the antithesis of good game design.

So, GTA V, which isn't really that great compared to let's say GTA:SA.

How is that proof that he was fired because of that? How is that anything but conjecture? You are literally not talking from logic and you talk about cult mentality? prove that he was fired because of that, like Gerstmann did when he confirmed it was because of Kane & Lynch.