What are your thoughts on Game Informer's top 300 games of all time?

gameinformer.com/b/features/archive/2018/03/19/readers-choice-top-300-games-of-all-time.aspx

What are your thoughts on Game Informer's top 300 games of all time?

Attached: Gameinformer.png (710x1325, 1.3M)

gameinformers are a bunch of fucking newfag shills

incorrect

its ok

Name 300 better games

I haven't played OoT, I absolutely love ME2 even though it is different than ME1 which I love even more. However I've tried playing Skyrim multiple times and end up dropping it out of disappointment every time. I played The Last Of Us for about 2 hours and dropped it. Will go back to it eventually but it was literally worse than Uncharted 1 and Tomb Raider reboot. TW3 I actually completed but thought the game overstayed it's welcome HARD and I had to really push myself to go on at certain points. Certain other points were amazing though.

In short I think the list just shows how everyone but me is stupid and how nu-gamers are a bowl of aids-ridden dicks who just parrot what is popular and think it's their own opinion.

Attached: invisible_tits.png (432x288, 70K)

But last of us was meh and Skyrim was a pile of shit.

>gameinformer

Attached: 1417378268920.jpg (472x472, 49K)

Flip that list upside down and you have my top 5

>game informer
who the fuck read this shit? its just a catalog for game stop.

>The Last of Us is listed above OoT
Did the people who made this list even watch TLoU? It barely has any fucking gameplay and the story is cringy as shit.

>no GTA SA
>cinematic shit on 4 and 2
>nostalgia OoT

fucking discarded
discarded

I didn't know there was a game simply called donkey Kong.

>zelda niggers still crying about it
lmao, though nothing will top the undertale best game of all time vote,

Sonybro/Nintentoddler/PC here.

While i'm a fan of both Last of Us and OoT.

They both have no business being on top of 5.

Vanilla Skyrim neither.

what a fucking cancerous list full of nostalgia fagging and bad taste

>He thinks people only like OoT for the nostalgia factor.

>Slav
>USA
>Japan
>USA
>USA
Where is the promised diversity, GameInformer?

>ME2
plebs

No surprise.
Despite what Sup Forums says those were in fact the best received most played and liked games.
Most of Sup Forums are pretentious hipster faggots who played games so much they neglected their own lives and became bored with any game that wasn't some 2.5d Mongolian waifu hopscotch jrpg with voice activated battle system running at 60fps.
This list is basically what the average gamer who still likes videogames enjoys.

OoT is a good game, I play through it like 5 times a year. I've completed it over 100 times and I never get bored of it.

nobody gives a shit about gameinformer

This. if you ever want to find a game you'll enjoy, never ever listen to Sup Forums

It doesn't take a genius to realize these top X number of games/movies/etc are based on popularity and not quality.

Will never understand why Skyrim is as liked as it is, but that Top 300 list is pretty damn solid and covers most of the games worth playing.

>Africa
>Africa
>Africa
>Africa
>'freeka

That better user?

>didn't listen to Sup Forums when talking about Dragon Age 2, wished I did because I hated that shit
>listened to Sup Forums when talking about Vermintide 2, game is pretty good having fun
there probably are some more but I don't remember now
I actually trust/v/ and /vg/ when it comes to video games more than review websites and web celeb reviewers

Attached: 1503747254752.png (640x432, 333K)

It was a lot of people's first real RPG, and is probably really impressive in that context.

Neither Left 4 Dead on the list. Banjo-Tooie is. Shit list.

meant to reply to

Not a single Ace Combat, what a bunch of cunts.

300 games and it doesn't include Stalker, what the fuck

SA is in the list asshat

It is purely nostalgia. Wind Waker is miles better and it's never on any of these lists.

but not at the top 5, or even top 10

I think they got it right with TW3 being in the Top 5, but I don't think it's the best game of all time. I personally think it's silly to rate games of vastly different genres against each other like most """journalists""" do. They should be compared by their specific genres. On that note, TW3 is certainly the best Western Fantasy RPG of all time.

>Dragon Age II and Andromeda
>no SSX
>no Ace Combat

A broken clock is right twice a day

>don't listen to Sup Forums
>fall for both Bordermemes games, Destiny 2, and Overwatch

>listen to Sup Forums
>introduced to wonders like Serious Sam, Dark Souls, Persona, Tactics Ogre, et cetera

If you're not a mouthbreather, actually passable at vidya, and don't just stare at page 0 for the ebin memes to repost on your r/Sup Forums feed, Sup Forumsirgins can pretty reliably recommend something you'll like.

>readers choice
what a surprise, normalfags have no idea what they're talking about. at least 1-4 are good games (even though they're not top 5 material) and dogshit skyrim only managed 5. all this on top of the fact that any numbered list of the best vidya is automatically faggotry.

I think it's not the games that are in there but the order of them

But two out of three of the games you listed first are genuinely good games. Destiny 2 isn't. Well, it is in it's core but it's fractured by greed.

There's no objective way to rank all those games, so I wouldn't obsess over it. Everybody should play the Top 100 at least, regardless of the order.

Get out of here stalker.
All of the games are buggy, frustrating pieces of shit with a large nugget of gold in them. Except clear sky, it just has a smaller turd in it.

Do you honestly think there are many people who would unironically say that any of the SSX games is their favorite game ever? And as for AC, it's a pretty niche series.

>ME2 makes another top 5

"No"

It's the most polished and well-received ME game and there's nothing you ME1fags can do about it.

>Mass Effect Andromeda on the list
lmao

The Pre-Sequel is not genuinely good under any definition of the word. Borderlands 2 I can sometimes get away with enjoying if I turn dialog to zero. Overwatch is just hot trash for e-sports kiddies, though. I'm not sure how people even still play that shit. They must just be autistically obsessed with a single character and one-trick every match. Everything about Paladins is better.

you're gonna tell me Mass Effect 2 deserves to sit alongside games like Skyrim and OoT, games that literally changed the landscape of video games.

>two Sonybro games
>no PUBG
>OoT nostalgiashit instead of BotW
>no Sea of Thieves
Fuck this shitty corrupt industry

It's been 3 years and the "the witcher 3 is good!"-meme still prevails. Is possibly the best co-elaborated ruse of all time.

This

>skyrim at 5
>me2 at 4
>tlou at 2
>tw3 at 1
Underage "I've only played 5 games" the list

Attached: 1520879685585.jpg (900x599, 99K)

This is a reader's choice poll. Not only do they tell you that it's a reader poll, you can tell because winners of these usually are from the past 4 or 5 years.

Journalists always have one of the following at number 1. They have for the past 20 years: Super Mario Brothers 3, Super Metroid, Tetris, Link to the Past or The Legend of Zelda

Banjo-Tooie is much worse than the original.

shit as always

game journalists were a mistake

Attached: 1520619763476.jpg (493x740, 48K)

It deserves to sit alongside Skyrim and OoT, but they weren't anything spectacular.

You're half-right. There are no objective way to list games that are similar in quality other than subjective tastes but when you get shit like Skyrim being #5 when it's a stale, janky piece of shit and its only reason being that high is that it's popular then there's a problem. Even witcher 3 doesn't deserve to be that high because of how fucking boring and repetitive the combat was.

The only area where WW was better was in its presentation. Otherwise it's a rushed rehash of OoT's gameplay with even easier dungeons, QTEs in combat, monotonous sailing everywhere, and an annoyingly long fetch quest to pad out the missing second half of the game. It did little to move the series forward, doubled down on some of OoT's weakest elements (the first dungeon is a forced stealth section), and introduced some of the series' worst elements (lengthy tutorial sections, vehicle based overworld, dungeons that are revisited several times). It doesn't deserve to be anywhere near a top ten lost.

>fallout 2
>284

>fallout 3
>22

Into the trash it goes

Attached: 1521681331115.png (493x271, 145K)

>says never
>gets proven wrong

Attached: Maximum backpeddleng.gif (480x270, 568K)

>OoT nothing spectacular
>literally changed the way 3rd-person action-adventures were played
>up to this date it's influencing gamedesign
>NOTHING SPECTACULAR

Go back to plebbit, nigger.

The top 300 on the website is different from the top 300 in the magazine.

Attached: a3r4frazwe3.png (300x256, 88K)

It's a good game. A great game, even. But there are countless better games by today's standards.

Well that's odd

#gamergate

We should just be happy Skyrim isn't #1 on these shitty "best of all time" lists anymore