I started lessons on Saturday and I already feel like it's paced too slow. First lesson was literally only hello, who are you and I am. Should I just do more in advance myself? Obviously i should, but what? Should I go with spoonfed Chinese? Often heard it here. Cramming in vocab is vital and I don't want to skimp out on that this time (my Spanish is worthless because I never did any vocab).
Also conflicted about the Hanzi, learning simplified in class but my focus is more on Taiwan so I'd prefer going traditional. How hard is the switch? Should I just go for traditional straight away despite the book and lessons being in simplified or can I adjust later on?
Oliver Taylor
Yep classes are stupid. Do spoonfed (audio on the front and nothing else) and 20+ words a day When you're at 2k+ words and 1-2k into spoonfed you'll be able to branch out and such. Tons of chinese stuff has subtitles included so I just watch some shit to listen and pick out phrases and such that use what I do know.
>How hard is the switch? In terms of reading only, much, much easier than learning them in the first place was. But writing could still be a pain. I don't practice writing at all, but if you do it might be worth practicing writing the traditional form. It might be confusing with your class though since you would need to know both.
Thanks. I still think the classes are somewhat helpful especially as a bloody begginer so I'm just gonna wait and see if I feel like booking the next course in October.
The only thing that really bugs me is the god awful pronunciation of the other guys in class. I mean I'm far from perfect but at least I can manage to make zhi, chi, shi, ri sound different
Jayden Rodriguez
Is learning Mandarin with an App for smartphones ok? It's pretty fun desu
Logan Perez
Where are you taking classes? University? Seriously thinking about learning Mandarin myself.
Xavier Thomas
I'm started classes at a Confucius Institute. The courses are pretty much generalized all over the world I believe, they all use the same books (Great Wall Chinese) etc
Wyatt Mitchell
How do I set Anki to play only the audio on new cards? Can't find an option for that.
Sebastian Gutierrez
It's a bit unintuitive because you edit it for a single card and it changes it for all of them.
Btw I just removed all the production cards in the interest of doing more audio a day
Kayden Edwards
Thanks man. What are production cards tho
Robert Myers
The ones with English on the front
Evan King
so you're saying OP is an ugly cunt just like you?
it's fun but the real difficulty in Mandarin is the vocal aspect. an app wouldn't do much to help you improve
Jack Phillips
>the real difficulty in Mandarin is the vocal aspect So you're saying that using an app is generally okay except for speech? Because I could learn that seperately
I've been cramming Anki to the point I can somewhat okayish read light novels but I can't say anything more complicated than 'I like green tea', fml
Kayden Gray
yeah it's ok for you to get a good grasp on grammar rules as well as the usage of verbs, adjectives etc. however, spoken Mandarin and written Mandarin can be very different based on regional dialects and also contractions
Blake Lee
can someone translate this
Hunter Scott
which apps do you use?
Jason Adams
>knew every hanzi/word except for 牵挂 >no clue what it says I really need to read more
Tyler Richardson
>this city is so big, i don't wanna miss it anymore, or i may never meet it again. > not everyone have good luck to have someone in mind, >and maybe in the time you know you know when that person is thinking of you right now the grammar he use in mandarin is kind of weird to me, or maybe it just bcuz he wanna make it more poetic. and btw sorry for bad english :(
Chase Diaz
>this city is so big, i don't wanna miss it anymore, or i may never meet it again. > not everyone have good luck to have someone in mind, and maybe in the time you know you or don't when that person is thinking of you also change a bit to make it more appropriate
Isaiah Lopez
wasted 3 months of my life learning mandarin on memrise 10 hours a day learned them up until HSK5, pinyin+tone+character waste of fucking time since i realized i don't want to deal with chinese people AT ALL
Colton Sullivan
damn i kind of screw the form again ahh i am such a image board noob :(((((((((((
It's really not perfect though. You don't learn a lot about writing and pronounciation.
Hunter Anderson
This city is so big, I don't want to screw up again. Otherwise, I might die. Not everyone is so lucky to have to worry about this person. It's also no coincidence that this person is also thinking of you at all times, whether you know it or not.
Samuel Williams
...
Joseph Morris
Taiwanbro probably translated the first sentence better, I had to look up 永别 using a dictionary and it's meaning probably depends on context.
Daniel Harris
what do you think of hong kong
Jordan Flores
also i suggest you change "screw up" to "miss it" since it say "错过" not "搞砸" and yes 永别 mean "never see each other again" so it is used when someone dead or get separated
Nathan Morris
牵挂 can means "worry" sometime but in other usage it can mean 'having someone in mind' cause you 'fall in love with him/her'
Josiah Myers
so what is the person likely saying about a girl or guy?
Ian Mitchell
Why?
Ayden Russell
>Chinese thread >Feel free to talk about minority languages over Mandarin
Owen Morgan
it is unclear since the author doesn't use any gender-specific word
Mason Foster
How long have you been learning Mandarin? Are you Asian American?
Levi Butler
Do you think Chinese characters are a good writing system? How fast can you read Chinese text?
Aiden Carter
>Guys, I have an idea. >Let's use a writing system for our language that is so unnecessarily difficult that we have to teach our kids the roman alphabet first before they can understand it.
And thus Chinese was born.
Matthew Wright
>也不是正好 you know 正好 mean 'just in time' so if you translate straight 也不是正好 it become 'not so just in time' which mean 'it is coincidence' the opposite meaning of your's no faster than you can imagine :)
Luke Lewis
pls respond
Luis Ramirez
20 years since i was born :DDD
Nathaniel Green
Let me guess, you saw some webms on Sup Forums.
James Gonzalez
What do you think of him?
Michael Walker
Am I right in feeling like this is an absolute bullshit approach? Never mind that you simply can not fit 10 hours worth of studying each day in your brain and somehow expect anything to stick long term but 2500 in three months is simply too much to have any realistic learning value.
When was that and how much of it is left?
Jaxson Reed
Chinese characters have some advantages though. Since you don't write the pronounciation but the "idea", every dialect is written the same, so you can read everything that's written in Chinese, even though you wouldn't be able to understand it if someone would speak it in a different dialect. You can also sometimes guess the meaning of a word that you don't know. Also it's not like every character is completely different, it's more like they're made with building blocks. If you know how chinese characters work, you can often guess the pronounciation. Literacy is also not really a problem in China.
I'm not saying that it's perfect but it's definetely not as bad as a lot of people think it is.
Ryder Lopez
That's only 30 words a day that's not even that much. Like that should be doable in an hour (or maybe a little more) each day. You retain it because SRS is awesome (anki is way better than memrise though. Multiple choice = cheating). It's not like you know it super well but you get the annoying part out of the way, because you associate the correct sounds to each characters and you have "recognition" of that many words even if you don't know the nuance
Hudson Harris
more like hes probably dealt with actual chinese people, lol
Jacob Diaz
hey guise what is this means 我的悲伤辣么大 am in great sorrow for not knoing :^(
Ryder Moore
please stop invading us. i want to live in a white country.
Liam Green
Redpill me on 打 it's mysterious it's everywhere and has 5 strokes. I just can't warp my head around it.
Tyler Howard
my sorrow is SO FREAKING HUGE
Juan Morris
I miss living in Taiwan guys ;_;
Aaron Ward
is taiwan an acceptable place to live in for a foreigner? What language do they speak in taiwan?
Luis Brown
thank you chinese taipei
Eli Ross
they speak vietnamese it's an ok country
Jacob Walker
taiwan is so good to live ive been to twice, i guarantee. they are relaxed japanese.
Dylan Allen
I deal with Chinese in New York and I don't get the fuss.
I usually don't deal with fresh off the boat people though.
Ryder Kelly
I Have 0 (Zero) Experience with chinese, Im interested in taking courses. Should I take courses or learn myself witch I think might be too hard. Also, cantonese or Mandarin?
Benjamin Reyes
thanks for the lesson
Charles Roberts
am not of haveing many this is lonely mokou desu
Connor Rogers
sorry i was eating dumplings I'm white, and my family speaks English, but I've been learning Chinese since I was in Kindergarten (13 yrs) from Mandarin immersion schools. mokou a best
Oliver Mitchell
>since I was in Kindergarten (13 years)
are you 16
Aren't you that user who said his Chinese is shit despite learning it for the greater part of his life? Shameful.
Hudson Collins
I wants to learn lenguage, but am torn between china and the other one I just dont know what I should do desu
Carson Morris
When does elementary school start?
Connor Stewart
>are you 16 we start kindergarten at the age of 5-6 my dude >Aren't you that user who said his Chinese is shit despite learning it for the greater part of his life? Dunno. I'm not 100% fluent, but I can speak to Chinese people just fine on most topics. My reading is meh though.
Tyler Gutierrez
Which other one?
Jaxson Cruz
I hope 2ch doesn't raid this thread again.
Caleb Moore
How did you learn mandarin?
Asher Hughes
you know, the weeb one with the katanas and samurais and animus and all that
Dominic Sanchez
He literally just answered that like two posts up
Mason Fisher
Like I know what the fuck immersion schools are
Cameron Thompson
Okay
Joshua Watson
t. Sup Forums
Daniel Reed
I have for 30 years. They really aren't too different from Americans.
Dominic Perez
watching china rise is like watching the us in the 1800s just slowly developing the entire continent, they're going to be hot shit
>tfw no pure QT loess plateau wife unspoiled by the western world
Kayden Watson
Bump
Elijah Gray
Okay
Wyatt Phillips
Do non-Chinese people usually attend those schools? I was thinking about going to one but I'd feel uncomfortable if every other student was Chinese.
Jacob Scott
Not usually. It's mostly for Chinese parents who want their kids to continue learning their language. In elementary school there were about 9-10 white kids out of a class of 50. In high school I was one of two white kids taking Chinese :\
Aaron Wilson
I want to know what is the point in learning chinese if I never go to China?
Alexander Brooks
you can go to taiwan instead we are pretty much the first world version of china
Sebastian Reed
>Taiwan >first world choose one and only one.
Jaxson Rivera
Oh, so funny, but you are just part of china, chinese taipei :^)
William Johnson
why do some foreigners think this statement is triggering? normies in here just don't give a shit anymore.
Aaron Hill
try harder next time
Eli Mitchell
But why would you think am trying to trigger? In this world full of contries is better to say yes to the one thats superior to yours so for all I care, you are but part of mainland china, and nothing more
Aiden Reed
omg are you the real last taiwanese in Sup Forums beside me
Jack Clark
fine by me, I don't particularly buy Taiwan as a country either.but also for all I care, Chile is an irrelevant country in SA, and nothing more.
Jaxon Bell
Ya, I'm. what is your thought about 9/3 parade and official servants' pension overall?
Bentley Baker
look buddy, gonna give to you straight, here is list of countrys that matter in SA, somewaht: 1.Brazil 2.Argentina 3.chile [Bunch of shit goes here] 99.Paraguay
Dylan Rodriguez
they can do whatever they want 他們想怎麼搞都隨便啦
Aiden Jackson
but SA except Brazil (maybe Argentina) is pretty irrelevant anyway. so... what's your point?
Nathaniel Gonzalez
really? you have no opinion on this issue? are you planning on immigration in future?
Evan Phillips
i don't see a issue here tbqh but you can convince me why this is important anyway
Wyatt Ross
Waat? So you say we all irrelevant, right? well thats it goodnight sir