Elliott Smith

Which is his best album and why is it XO?

that's not either or

XD

From A Basement, and it isn't even on it's final form (yet?).

>(yet?)
keep holding your breath m8 dreamworks doesn't give half a shit about Elliott. That's why they gave the reissues to fucking Plain Recordings

I'm still holding out hope that someone half competent sees the success of New Moon and does a similarly careful compilation album of his XO/Figure 8 unreleased stuff

it's either/or. it has his best songs (speed trials,between the bars, rose parade, cupid's trick, say yes)

Hot opinions coming through.

1. Either/Or
2. Self titled
3. XO
4. Roman Candle
5. Figure 8

>elliott's rock phase
ew

S/T > Roman Candle > Either/Or > Rest

Yeah but it also has No Name #5 and Punch And Judy

XO is the only one of his albums that's top tier all the way through

>le posthumous releases dont real face

>implying Either/Or isn't part of his rock phase too
>implying XO isn't just as, if not more dark than Either/Or even though the instrumentation and arrangements are more creative