I don't get it

...

listen to it a few more times friend :^)

if you haven't already, look into the lyrics. they add so much to the album.

Listen to it again, it's pretty good aside from the cringy vocalist.

All you need to know is that Don stepped outside.

CREEPING UP INTO THE SKYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY

Quiet parts are a good atmospheric album, I don't get the loud parts yet though

Same.

It's weird because I love GY!BE, and this board gave me some great recs for it, but this kept coming up and I just can't get into it, even slightly.

I've tried listening to it three or four times. The last time I was stoned, and when I'm stoned 99% of the time anything will sound 10/10, I've listened to music I thought was trash and loved when I was high. But it just kinda freaked me out.

What am I missing?

loud parts are the good parts
Especially Washer and Captain

try out Tweez or Big Black's Atomizer. I wouldn't start with Spiderland

that's fine