What is the musical equivilant of this """""art""""""

What is the musical equivilant of this """""art""""""

Other urls found in this thread:

dannydocandthehistorymakerz.bandcamp.com/releases
youtube.com/watch?v=lNI07egoefc
youtube.com/watch?v=ANA8SI_KvqI
youtube.com/watch?v=d7ez-gIt08I
youtube.com/watch?v=7SVbYSTGtWw
youtube.com/watch?v=WPuLvKvalKk
rateyourmusic.com/~Montie_Ray
montietalksmusic.tumblr.com/
independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/art/news/a-pair-of-glasses-were-left-on-the-floor-at-museum-and-everyone-mistook-it-for-art-a7049551.html
youtube.com/watch?v=e3bP7PHXIV4
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

Field recordings

mashups.

Marcel Duchamp is alright besides that piece of shit

This is so sad to look at (the OP, not Duchamp)

dannydocandthehistorymakerz.bandcamp.com/releases
これでしょ

Noise

death grips

21 pilots

IONISPHERE R MUTT is literally in one of their lyrics

Why do you pretend to enjoy noise "music"?

Harsh noise is not music.
It's just sound.

Stay pleb Montie

Monticello why do you make the same threads over and over again? I associate so many images with you from both here and tv

organised in a specific fashion, hence music
is monti the most pleb baby on 4chen? probably

best answer you're going to get tbqh

Vaporwave

Music is a combination of organized sounds and silences. Noise is music.

Exactly.

Found the butthurt poseurs.

4'33

how can one trip be so ignorant

I don't(???)
It's just that seeing a snarky comment on how the fountain is not art is exactly the kind of thing 14 y/o me would do, and nothing is more cringy to me than seeing people repeat the shameful attitudes I used to have.
I'm not yet sure you are capable of grasping the concept of a "concept".

Everyone who considers noise music or that thing in the OP picture art should watch this
youtube.com/watch?v=lNI07egoefc

Found the people who take bait easy

Here come the modern art apologists and pretentious hipsters

youtube.com/watch?v=lNI07egoefc
youtube.com/watch?v=ANA8SI_KvqI
youtube.com/watch?v=d7ez-gIt08I
youtube.com/watch?v=7SVbYSTGtWw

...

And yet you probably enjoy music that utilizes noise in some way but you would classify that as music. Even though you enjoy those noisy elements.

Is this music?

youtube.com/watch?v=WPuLvKvalKk

you could improve your life

"It's summer and I don't know who Montie is because I just am fresh off the boat from Sup Forums haha"

Faggot

good argument

Music with noise elements is music
Noise alone is not music

Butthurt

>people care about me because i trip

>noise is not music
why? what would you define as the level of 'music' required in a piece to somehow elevate noise to being music

Marcel Duchamp is a genius, you fucking pleb

>Marcel Duchamp is a genius, you fucking pleb

you came here last year you twat what the fuck are you talking about

everything says is absolutely true and you need to stop using your tripcode you fucking unloved piece of attention-whoring garbage

pic related, kys

he kind of is though

Why do you tripcode?

>why? what would you define as the level of 'music' required in a piece to somehow elevate noise to being music
Emotion, noise has no emotion

It is obviously 4'33
Actually laughed out loud, this is so sad.
I have a good counterargument which I lack the interest to write, just know it exists.
And aesthetic relativism only meant the demise of art at the point in which people started repeating the deconstructionism of the modernists without expanding on it. Nowadays, any piece of art that holds as its main statement "this can also be art" is only sufficient to those who completely misunderstood The Fountain. To propose a rock as a sculpture, exactly as Duchamp proposed the fountain, is to think that the main element of Duchamp's piece isn't the fact that it is not a classically made sculpture and the due thought process - but the sole fact that it is a fountain. Those works of giant synthetic shits or white canvasses you hear of, those are not more than different shells to an already fulfilled message.
Also, Duchamp never seemed to me like a full on Nihilist, he always built something on the remnants of what he tore down. In this case the singing by "R Mutt" perfectly poses the question on the state of authorship in a society of mass production.
And that is obviously not a Pollock in the video, kek.

No shit.

entirely subjective
perhaps you should be asking yourself how people get emotion from noise music in order to become a more aware and astute listener yourself.

Then why use it in music you retard lmao

...

internet celebrity ITT RIGHT NOW fuck

>quality in art is objectively traceable
don't actually explain what those objective standards are, though. don't explain how they are responsible for the works mentioned in the video, either. (protip: the classic arts shown in the video are responsible for these so-called standards, not the other way around)

you're also missing the dude's point: he's not saying that the stuff presented isn't art, but that it's bad art, which is a completely fair opinion to have (though his reasoning is fucking retarded).

getting upset over contemporary arts is such a lame thing to do, especially considering pretty much everyone who does has never done anything to contribute to the arts themselves.

all in all, you should end your life.

rateyourmusic.com/~Montie_Ray
montietalksmusic.tumblr.com/

naw, that's more like pic related desu

Duchamp is one of the greatest artists of the XX Century. OP is an idiot

Piper Perry

Montie is not a contributing member of this community.
He is just an attention seeking cunt.

Who is this faggot

Conceptual art in a nutshell

independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/art/news/a-pair-of-glasses-were-left-on-the-floor-at-museum-and-everyone-mistook-it-for-art-a7049551.html

You have such a punchable face

Everyone is

MUH QUALITY
MUH CRAFT

youtube.com/watch?v=e3bP7PHXIV4

I don't think you understand Duchamp which is ridiculous considering just how unpretentious the entire idea of a readymade is.

I actually hope that you commit suicide. I'm not just saying that to hurt your feelings.

I wanna mush your face in and fuck your asshole desu :3

Are you trying to make an argument or something?

I love this one, but it is only a mix of many pre-existing ideas (futurism, cubism and stroboscopic motion photography)

I agree 100%

It's a urinal laid on it's back. It spits piss back at anyone who uses it.

dog barking outside is music

>organized
>he thinks improvisation and field recordings are not music

I really should get onto breaking this trip
Maybe I'll set up the job one of these days.

do you know what organization means

Artificial, soulless work that really just sets the artform back.

I want Duchampfags to fuck off

If it wasn't for him, those lazy fucking little shit eating millenials majoring in art would be making decent stuff instead of this modern suprematist bullshit that tries to push the boundaries of "WHAT IS ART" like if it wasn't overdone for the last fucking century.

At least noise music can be decent (Luigi Russolo for example), and even if it is bad it's going to stay niche and not shoving it's throbbing cock everywhere like that pretentious Anti-art bullshit

Fuck yeah another Montie thread

Duchamp's work could in fact be seen as a critique on the avant garde art revolutions that took place during the modernist era (impressionism, expressionism, cubism, abstract art). If you're still doing readymades as an art student now, you should read up. The battle is fought.

That's pretty much what I said here except I still defend Duchamp despite his influence

You are not our friend, Montie. People cannot become friends with some random internet people, especially on Sup Forums. Oh, and:

Ironical shitposting is still shitposting.

pop music is not music

m8 the glassess themselves after being put there are a piece of art anyway, the point being that people tend to feel different to an object dependent on its context
OP's picture is Fountain is fairly ironic given that duchamp was going for more or less the same idea

this piece was made during the dada art period so something that fits into the characteristics of that period
>nothing matters
>random
>death

and who ever bags on Marcel kys you uncultured swine

>Artificial, soulless
why are those attributes undesirable?

Sigur ros

Montie, you're an annoying faggot. What makes you more annoying is your fucking tripcode and name. See

>fountain is 99 years old
>plebs still whine about it
>art students still rip it off thinking they're groundbreaking

Is it the most important work of the 20th century or what?

no, cause at least they're catchy

>I have a good counterargument which I lack the interest to write, just know it exists.
I'm interested, if that is any help.

What do you get from this?
At least be originally brain dead. You've done this thread 3 times now it's bland and been done already. Please just make your autism new, because now you look more like a dumbass than you already were.
>Do something new already

hey_look_i_posted_it_again.jpg

People who can't like Duchamp are the biggest fucking pleb babies.

No

Why do you pilot the tripcode?

>People who like Duchamp are the biggest fucking pleb babies.

Who are your favorite artists/composers?

Or perhaps he's wondering why someone would shoot a man, before throwing him out of a plane?

>inb4 your fav artist is van gogh

>An H3H3 video
This HAS to be bait.

Go back to /noise/.

Dean Blunt mah boi

this

Holy shit, these videos are fucking awful. The first one is an actual art teacher who's stuck in a pre-19th century mindset of what art is.
I mean, these people are cherry picking obnoxious pretentious stuff and claiming all of this is modern art, while it was first done before their fucking grandparents were even born. There are loads of contemporary artists who do good shit, this is like thinking people aping Reich and Stockhausen are examples of the music industry being pretentious.

you are such a sad cunt i can't believe it

you spend the whole of your free time making sarky comments on Sup Forums people like they should be treating you like one of the cool kids.... its sad

do you have family? do you have friends? don't you think you ought to nbe spending more time with them?/

fuck my life i wanna go home

i wanna go home

...