ITT: Albums they should have stopped at

ITT: Albums they should have stopped at

Adore is their best you pleb.

...

CATALOG
A
T
A
L
O
G

COMEDY GOLD

Adore and Machina are alright, and Oceania is pretty good too.

lol

Not the same

...

...

...

fuck you centipede hz is great

yes but not good enough to be an ideal closer

imagine if the last piece of music Meme Reznor ever made was Leaving Hope. He'd be a legend.

...

I don't get this meme. Green, Maladroit, Make Believe, Hurley, EWBAITE, and White have a lot of good songs.

...

Day & Age > Sam's Town

...

>weezer
>great
Kill yourself

what a fucking lame album cover

...

It's not necessarily a bad album but its when their lyricism started to worse and they started having filler.

Irrelevant to the thread but thanks for the opinion. I'm sure everyone cares.

...

they had a couple good albums after that but yeah, basically.

Weak chin game champion

...

What a fag

why is will such a faggot all the time ?

...

wrong album

...

Crimes rules though.

Replace with R Plus 7

And Justice for All

correct

...

i agree with these

>Replace with R Plus 7
I thought about it, but despite all the great moments it has R Plus 7 is still a step down from Replica.

Crimes was a little spotty for me, even when I was super into Blood Brothers.

Burn Piano Island Burn is 10/10 though.

...

...

Is that what the actual cover looks like?

Gross

no u

>And Justice for All
I knew someone would say that. But Black was their commercial peak and a strong album. If they'd stopped there they wouldn't have tarnished their legacy like they have since.

Nice 808s

Strawberry Jam and Merriweather > Sung Tongs

>liking formulaic hipster pop

Machina 1 is their best

>liking shitty hipster folk

atleast young prayer was alright

Care to explain why you think that?

>danse manatee
>shitty hipster folk
what ?

>not posting Siamese Dream

Fug u the resistance is gr8

I think it has their best songs and their best "vibe". It also represents a culmination of everything they've done before. It has the string sections, the chuggy guitars, and the emotion and electronics of adore. I have no idea why people don't love it.

*String sections of Mellon Collie, chuggy guitars of Siamese Dream

They still had good albums after this, but never again did they have a perfect album, after 3 of them in a row.

The main writer left, why did they continue?

only one i Agree with

...

...

Agreed. New album was trash

...

Ur dumb, Take Off Your Pants and Jacket is just as good as EotS, and Untitled has some of their best tracks like Stockholm Syndrome and Down.

If you could read, you'd see that I didn't use the word "great" at all in my post.

Dude I totally agree, it shows a complete list of their sound to this point it's the yr 2000 after a decade span their time is over, age of innocence is truly their last song a perfect goodbye in my opinion.

kys

Since I Left You

...

...

Okay guys come on
Oceania was pretty good

...

>"this heavily synth album is better than this acoustic album"

I like both bruv

>make believe
>good songs

Pick one