Second Thread here Guys, here's the last one: Rules: Every "Top 100" list I've come across has been really bad and not nearly as inclusive as it should be, so, how about we make one?
The rules are as follows:
Rule 1) Name a song that you think deserves to be in a list of greatest songs ever.
Rule 2) If you see a song that you agree to be in the Top 100, reply to it with a "1", to confirm your vote for it.
Rule 3) Songs without any replies are a 0 and will not be included in the list, songs with 1 reply have 1 vote, 2 / 2, 3 / 3 and so on.
Rule 4) If a comment includes more than one some, reply to that comment with a 1 and the song that you think deserves to be on the list.
Rule 5) I will be taking the first thousand songs with either 1 vote or more, then I will hold a poll to slim the list down until we eventually get the top 100.
So, Sup Forums, what is the greatest song of all time?
Just to make it clear - we don't re-'1' songs that we already voted for in the first thread, do we?
Evan Fisher
1
Brody Hall
1
Red House Painters - Katy Song
Tyler Powell
maudlin of the Well - Birth Pains Of Astral Projection 1
Jason Cox
Also, should we repost songs we posted in the last thread?
Mason Cruz
Neutral Milk Hotel - Oh Comely
Ayden Brooks
yo, these were in the last thread and got votes so we don't need to relist them i don't think
1
Higgs Boson Blues - Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds
Parker Taylor
1
Bjork - Unravel
Connor Jackson
Red House Painters - Medicine Bottle
Kayden Sanchez
1
Oliver Reed
To that I would guess yes, since posting the song doesn't count as a vote, and so that new people can vote for songs in the old thread.
Cameron Watson
David Bowie - station to station
Gavin Long
(>tfw Ian vocals never) 1
The Gun Club - For the Love of Ivy
Hudson Torres
Once in a Lifetime - Talking Heads
Nathan Long
Kanske Är Jag Kär I Dig by Jens Lekman
Only one vote is necessary to get it into the running as long as its before the 1000 cut. repost songs that didnt get any votes, but there is literally no point to reposting, say, Oh Comely. it got a ton of votes in the last thread.
Leo Morris
Pixies - Where is my mind
Alexander Davis
I enter:
Aphex Twin - Rhubarb Angelo Badalamenti - Laura Palmer's Theme A Silver Mt. Zion - Could've Moved Mountains Duster - The Landing The Microphones - I Want Wind to Blow Slint - Washer
1
Parker Diaz
Not OP but I we shouldn't re-1 songs we already voted for in a previous thread. Obviously nobody can control whether all the votes for a song are from different people, but we should just think of it as a moral obligation.
1
Anthony Rogers
Death Grips - Up My Sleeves
Alexander Jenkins
yeesh
well i'll 1 i want wind to blow
1
Owen Scott
Microphones - I want wind to blow
(I know some user already posted this grouped in with a bunch of other songs, but I'm posting it separately)
Colton Lee
1
LIL UGLY MANE - Uneven Compromise
Zachary Ross
1, The Landing 1
Hmm.. Aesop Rock - Gopher Guts
Michael Ramirez
Talking Heads - The Great Curve
Gavin Young
1 for I Want Wind to Blow
Nicholas Garcia
pyramids - frank ocean
Brandon Fisher
voting 4 Microphones
1
Neutral Milk Hotel - Naomi
Jace Gutierrez
rule 3 makes this unnecessarily complicated. lets not worry about vote count and just gather submissions now, then vote when they've all been assembled
Brayden Butler
Death Grips - Guillotine
Andrew Russell
Television - Marquee Moon
1
1ing Rhubarb, The Landing, I Want Wind to Blow, and Washer
Michael Rodriguez
(laura palmers theme) 1
Lua - Bright Eyes
Jordan Kelly
1
Christopher Richardson
I agree .Counting how many (you)'s each song gets in these threads silly and biases things too heavily towards songs posted earlier in threads.
David Sanchez
yup, and we should limit to one song per post
Juan Cruz
Washer 1
>Billie Jean - Michael Jackson
Owen Evans
1
Joshua Murphy
1
Easton Parker
Heroin - The Velvet Underground
Gavin Butler
Nirvana - All Apologies
Nathaniel Morris
1
Charles Diaz
1
Fugazi - Turnover
Dominic Rogers
IN THE FLOWERS!
1 1 Washer 1
Brandon Garcia
Swans - Oxygen
Robert James
AnCo Brother Sport
Jonathan Scott
Sonic Youth - Teen Age Riot
Jacob Watson
Slint - Good Morning Captain
Mason Diaz
1 for Washer and I want wind to blow 1
Connor Thomas
wait wait
Lua - Bright eyes or Lua - Conor Oberst & Gillian Welch? I like the latter a little better.
1 either way but yeah
agreed
1
Sodom, South Georgia - Iron & Wine
Jayden Rogers
1
Nolan Phillips
1
James Cox
1
Nathan Gonzalez
1
john coltrane & johnny hartman - lush life
Juan Watson
1
Luis Flores
kanye west - runaway
Kevin Torres
Stand by me, ben e king
Chase Bailey
1
1
1, Washer
1
1
1
Sister Ray by the Velvet Underground.
Jose Lewis
Reoccurring Dreams by Husker Du
Jaxon Sanders
1
Of Montreal - The Past Is A Grotesque Animal
Ian Hernandez
Joanna Newsom - Only Skin
Ayden Brown
1
1
Fritter by Mercury Rev.
Sebastian Jackson
1
Gone by Kanye West
Cooper Robinson
1
Owen Sullivan
Stressed out by 21 Pilots
Ryder Jenkins
Toto - Africa
Samuel Young
Skream, Summer Dreams
Nolan Howard
brian eno third uncle
Jonathan Robinson
1
Leo Ross
Washer 1
Noah Wood
1
Zachary Perez
1
Everything else is shite
Jace Anderson
Opeth - Blackwater Park (song)
Nathaniel Williams
1
Gavin Kelly
1
Hudson Harris
Limousine by Brand New
Lincoln Bell
1
found the right answer for #1 overall >The Beach Boys - I Get Around