Rate the discography of your favorite Band/Group/Artist, and we comment on each other's taste.
Kill em' All: 9/10
Ride the Lightning: 9.5/10
Master of Puppets: 10/10
...And Justice for All: 8.75/10
Black Album: 7.75/10
Load: 4.5/10
Reload: 4/10
St. Anger: 2/10
Death Magnetic: 5/10
Other urls found in this thread:
docs.google.com
twitter.com
Metallica's only 10/10 should be RTL, MoP is only an 8/10
You also rated Black Album way too high
Kinda agree with the rest
Anyway, here's one for the band that I hate to love, Manowar
Battle Hymns : 7/10
Into Glory Ride : 7/10
Hail to England : 11/10
Sign of the Hammer : 9/10
Fighting the World : 7,5/10
Kings of Metal : 7/10
The Triumph of Steel : 2/10
Louder than Hell : 5/10
Warriors of the World : 6/10
Gods of War : 4/10
The Lord of Steel : 4/10
Demilich - Nespithe (10/10)
Spirit They're Gone Spirit They've Vanished - 8.5/10
Danse Manatee - 4/10
Campfire Songs - 6.5/10
Here Comes the Indian - 9.5/10
Sung Tongs - 7/10
Feels - 9/10
Strawberry Jam - 10/10
Merriweather Post Pavilion - 9.5/10
Centipede Hz - 6/10
Painting With - 8/10
EP and Live
Hollinndagain - 5/10
Prospect Hummer - 6/10
People - 5.5/10
Water Curses - 7.5/10
Fall Be Kind - 9.5/10
>Load and Reload bad
>Death Magnetic not as good as their first 4 albums despite having an identical style
>Black Album anything above a 5
Bloody Kisses 3.5/5
Dead Again 3/5
Life is Killing Me 2.5/5
October Rust 4/5
Slow, Deep and Hard 3/5
The Origin of the Feces 3.5/5
World Coming Down 4.5/5
Load and Reload are just kind of a weird subject for me. I just do not enjoy listening to them with the exception of a select few songs [spoiler] Devil's Dance is actually my favorite Metallica song [/spoiler]
For Death Magnetic, I love Broken Beat & Scarred, All Nightmare Long, and Cyanide, everything else is decent or average. Since you bring it to my attention it really should be higher.
Black Album is a hit or miss with people. I can easily understand why people don't like it, I think a lot of it is enjoyable.
This is a good post.
Pretty good ranking of AnCo (LPs, not too familiar with their EPs except Prospect Hummer, which was a bit of a letdown considering Vashti and AnCo are two of my favourite artists). I'd rank MPP a tiny bit lower, PW significantly so, and I'd definitely add a point or two to CHz!
Here's mine:
Joanna Newsom:
Walnut Whales 7.5
Yarn and Glue 7.5
The Milk-Eyed Mender 9
YS 9.5
Joanna Newsom & The Ys Street Band 9.5
Have One on Me 10
Divers 9.5
Tim Buckley 4.5/10
Goodbye And Hello 8/10
Happy/Sad 9/10
Blue Afternoon 7.5/10
Lorca 9.5/10
Starsailor 10/10
Sefronia 6/10
Look At The Fool 3/10
Fair enough I guess. I feel Load/Reload cops a lot of flak for being "sellout" even though it's probably Metallica's most experimental album. Death Magnetic was an important album for me as it was the first time I really took music seriously (previously it had just been a background thing for me). Yea the production could be better, but I'm glad James didn't go full "YEA" like he did on Beyond Magnetic. How you feel about DM is how I feel about Black.
Pablo Honey
4/10
The Bends
6/10
OK Computer
7/10
Kid A
9/10
Amnesiac
8/10
Hail to the Thief
6/10
In Rainbows
9/10
The King Of Limbs
10/10
A Moon Shaped Pool
6/10
Steaming Train EP: 8/10
I Told You So (split single with Razorcuts): 6/10
Talulah Gosh/Don't Go Away: 10/10
Where's the Cougar Matey?: 8/10
Testcard Girl/Way of the World: 6/10
Demos EP: 3/10
Backwash: 10/10
Funny story, Death Magnetic was my first album I ever listened to in it's entirety. I just think it gets overshadowed by the original four albums. But there is definitely nothing wrong with liking their newer stuff, sellout fags can fuck off.
Out of curiosity, what are your thoughts on St. Anger?
Remission: 9.25/10
Leviathan: 9/10
Blood Mountain: 7.5/10
Crack the Skye: 10/10
The Hunter: 5.5/10
Once More 'Round the Sun: 7/10
It's... Ok
It could be a good album if half the songs didn't go for 8 minutes. It's not like they were progressive like on AJFA. I didn't mind the rawer song and while the lyrics are cringey, that's rarely been a complete turn off for me.
You should throw up your own rate.
Eh, I'm not good with scores. Most of the time when I do one I immediately think it should be different and can never find a score I'm satisfied with, RtL would be a 10 for me though.
Wretch: 9/10
Blues for the red sun: 10/10
Welcome to sky valley: 8/10
...and thr circus leaves Town: 7/10
TVU & Nico - 10
WLWH - 10
TVU - 9,5
Loaded - 8
>Death Grips
ExM - 9/10
TMS - 7/10
NLDW - 6/10
GP - 7.5/10
NotM - 10/10
JD - 6/10
BP - 8/10
Absolute autism
Kid A 9 yes, AMSP 6 no
LCD Soundsystem
8/10
Sound of Silver
10/10
This is Happening
7/10
Frank Zappa
Me and 2 buddies are still in the process of completing it. (Over a year now)
I suck at writing reviews but you can look at the scores for the albums and let me know what you guys think.
Pledged 2500$ to the Zappa Kickstarter
docs.google.com
Manic Street Preachers
Generation Terrorists - 5/10
Gold Against the Soul - 6/10
The Holy Bible - 9/10
Everything Must Go - 10/10
This Is My Truth Tell Me Yours - 8/10
Know Your Enemy - 6/10
Lifeblood - 9/10
Send Away the Tigers - 6/10
Journal for Plague Lovers - 8/10
Postcards from a Young Man - 3/10
Rewind the Film - 7/10
Futurology - 8/10
Metropolis pt1 9/10
Metropolis pt2 7/10
Superflat 10/10
This Heat - 9/10
Deceit - 8.5/10
Health and Efficiency - 8/10
someone do ferraro or merzbow.
on that note, do you think anyone other than merzbow has listened to his discog?
Yes?
Listen to his stuff besides pulse demon for a second
Danse is better than that, and Feels and HCTI aren't that good
TKOL isn't the best, but it's sure as hell underrated
(also my favorite band)
>LCD Soundsystem
7/10
>45:33
8/10
>Sound of Silver
10/10
>This Is Happening
8/10
Spirit They're Gone, Spirit They've Vanished - 12/10
Danse Manatee - 7/10
Hollinndagain - 8.5/10
Campfire Songs - 7/10
Here Comes the Indian - 8/10
Sung Tongs - 8.5/10
Feels - 9.7/10
Strawberry Jam - 9/10
Merriweather Post Pavilion - 9.5/10
Centipede Hz - 7.5/10
Painting With - 6.5/10
Barter 6: 15/10
Slime Season: 11.5/10
Slime Season 2: 11/10
Slime Season 3: 11.5/10
I'm Up: 9.5/10
1017 Thug: 10/10
1017 Thug 2: 9/10
1017 Thug: 8/10
I Came From Nothing: 8/10
I Came From Nothing 2: 9/10
I Came From Nothing 3: 8.5/10
Rich Gang Tha Tour part 1: 9.5/10
Rich Gang Tha Tour part 2: 8.5/10
Young Thugga Mane La Flare: 9/10
Young Rich Homie Thuggin: 8/10
Black Portland: 7/10
The Strokes
Is This It - 10/10
Room On Fire - 10/10
First Impressions Of Earth - 7/10
Angles - 8/10
Comedown Machine 7.5-10
Future Present Past - 7.5-10
Black Sabbath: 7/10
Paranoid: 10/10
Master of Reality: 9.5/10
Vol.4: 8/10
Sabbath Bloody Sabbath; 10/10
Sabotage: 7.5/10
Technical Ecstasy: 5/10
Never Say Die: 9/10
Heaven and Hell: 8/10
Mob Rules: 8/10
Born Again: 6/10
Seventh Star: 4/10
Eternal Idol: 6.5/10
Headless Cross 1/10
Tyr: 4/10
Dehumanizer 7/10
Cross Purposes 8/10
Forbidden 5/10
The Devil You Know 6/10
13 + the end EP: 6/10
13 + the end EP
phew
>Joanna Newsom & Ys Street Band
Wow can't believe she just compared herself to an actually good artist, disgusting.
Rating people that posted some of my favorite artists
STGSTV-10/10
DM-7.5/10
CS-7.5/10
HCTI-9.5/10
ST-8/10
Feels-8.5/10
SJ-8.5/10
MPP-8/10
CHz-6/10
PW-6/10
Pablo Honey-5/10
The Bends-7.5/10
Ok Computer-10/10
Kid A-10/10
Amnesiac-9/10
HTTT-7/10
IR-8/10
TKOL-6/10
AMSP-8/10
>Swans
Filth-9/10
Cop-8/10
Holy Money-7/10
Greed-7/10
Children of God-9/10
The Buring World-6/10
Body to Body, Job to Job-7/10
White Light From the Mouth of Infinity-8/10
Love of Life-7.5/10
The Great Annihilator-8.5/10
Soundtracks for the Blind-10/10
My Father Will Guide Me Up A Rope to the Sky-7/10
The Seer-9/10
To Be Kind-9/10
Live albums:
Public Castration is a Good Idea-9.5/10
Swans are Dead-10/10
We Rose From Your Bed with the Sun in Our Heads-8/10
Not Here/Not Now-7.5/10
The Gate-9/10
EPs:
Swans-7.5/10
Young God-7/10
Die Tur Ist Zu-7/10
Closing Time - 8/10
Heart of a Saturday Night - 7/10
Nighthawks at the Diner - 8/10
Small Change - 6/10
Foreign Affairs - 7/10
Blue Valentine - 6/10
Heartattack and Vine - 5/10
Swordfishtrombones - 6/10
Rain Dogs - 9/10
Franks Wild Years - 5/10
Bone Machine - 9/10
The Black Rider - 5/10
Mule Variations - 8/10
Alice - 9/10
Blood Money - 8/10
Real Gone - 7/10
Orphans: Brawlers, Bawlers, and Bastards - 9/10
Bad As Me - 8/10
fair ratings
What about The Glowing Man?
Killing Is My Bussiness: 8/10
Peace Sells... But Who's Buying: 10/10
So Far So Good So What: 7/10
Rust In Peace: 10/10
Countdown To Exctintion: 10/10
Youthanasia: 9/10
Cryptic Writing: 7/10
Risk: 4/10
The World Needs A Hero: 6/10
The System Has Failed: 7/10
United Abominations: 8/10
Endgame: 9/10
Super Collider: 3/10
Dystopia: 10/10
Classic era Yes
s/t-7.5/10
Time and a Word-9/10
The Yes Album-8/10
Fragile-8.5/10
Close to the Edge-9/10
Tales From Topographic Oceans-9/10
Going For the One-8.5/10
I like The Yes Album the most, I don't know why it's overlooked on Sup Forums. Starship Trooper and All Good People are both GOAT and that's the majority of the album. Besides that, I think your rating is all right.
8
7.5
9
8
8.5
7
7.5
Yes Album is good, don't get me wrong but Close to the Edge and TFTO are better. I also think Time and a Word is in their top 3 which in itself is an unpopular opinion
martyrs among the casualties - 9/10
fall of troy - 10/10
Ghostship demos - 10/10
Doppelganger - 9/10
Manipulator - 9/10
In the unikely event - 8/10
OK - 8/10
Adrenaline: 8/10
Around The Fur: 9.5/10
White Pony: 10/10
S/T: 7/10
Saturday Night Wrist: 8/10
Diamond Eyes: 9/10
Koi No Yokan: 7.5/10
Gore: 5.5/10
>King Crimson
ITCOCK - 8.5/10
ITWOP - 8/10
Lizard - 7.5/10
Islands - 7/10
Lark's Tongue in Aspic - 8.5/10
Red - 9.5/10
SABB - 7.5/10
Discipline - 8.5/10
Beat - 5/10
TOAPP - 4/10
THRAK - 6.5/10
ConstruKction - 6/10
TPTB - 6.5/10
This is what i would have posted to. I think youre to hard on death magnetic its fine.
I agree with this sentiment, its not that theyre bad its just not muh metallica
Lark's 10
Kill em all 6/10
Ride the Lightning 8/10
Master of Puppets 10/10
And justice for all 9/10
Black album 7.5/10
Load 6/10
Reload 6.5/10
St anger 5.5/10
Death magnetic 9/10
wait rly how is diamond eyes higher than adrenaline though
maybe he's a djent fan
You underrated cryptic writings, but otherwise accurate.
notm being 10 makes these ratings acceptable
Yeah, you can slide down those ratings and it'll make sense, because they're all in the proper relation to one another.
i'd bump the scores for this heat and deceit up 1, other than that this is good
it's not out yet tbhs senpaitachi :>)
>Lark's not 10/10
Chelsea Wolfe
The Grime And The Glow 6/10
Apokalypsis 8/10
Unknown Rooms 7/10
Pain Is Beauty 12/10
Abyss 8/10
Pablo Honey: 4/10
The Bends: 6/10
OK Computer: 9/10
Kid A: 10/10
Amnesiac: 7/10
Hail to the Thief: 5/10
In Rainbows: 8/10
King of the Limbs: 8/10
(Haven't listened to Moon Shaped Pool yet, I hope I get the chance)
Experience: 8/10
Jilted Generation: 9/10
Fat Of The Land: 10/10
Always Outnumbered, Never Outgunned: 4/10
Invaders: 7/10
The Day Is Me Enemy: 6/10
8.5
7
6
9
10
6
7
I'll try DG too
Exmilitary 7/10
The Money Store 9/10
No Love Deep Web 9/10
Government Plates 9/10
Niggas On The Moon 10/10
Jenny Death 6/10
Bottomless Pit 9/10
Phil Elverum
Don't Wake Me Up: 7.5/10
Window: 6/10
It Was Hot: 8.5/10
The Glow Pt. 2: 9.5/10
Little bird/Blood: 7.5/10
Mount Eerie: 9.5/10
No Flashlight: 9/10
Lost Wisdom: 8.5/10
Dawn: 9/10
Winds Poem: 9.5/10
Clear Moon: 6.5/10
Ocean Roar: 6/10
Sauna: 7/10
Seven New Songs: 10/10?
good except switch NLDW with exmil and you're golden
Gojira
mainly for FMTS to be honest
Terra Incognita 7/10
The Link 7/10
From Mars To Sirius 10/10
The Way Of All Flesh 8/10
L'Enfant Sauvage 7/10
Magma 3/10
>le exmilitary is the best album meme
ExM - 9
TMS - 10
NLDW - 7
GP - 7
NotM - 8
JD - 7
BP - 8
Pablo Honey
5/10
The Bends
7/10
OK Computer
9.5/10
Kid A
10/10
Amnesiac
9/10
HTTT
7/10
In Rainbows
9/10
TKOL
6.5/10
AMSP
8.5/10
Elliott Smith
Roman Candle 8/10
S/t 10/10
Either Or 10/10
XO 9/10
Figure 8/10 :^)
FABOTH 8/10
>Nick Drake
Five Leaves Left 9.5/10
Bryter Layter 9/10
Ping Moon 10/10
way 2 rank Kid A where it belongs
at the top
>Swordfishtrombones - 6/10
:^(
at no point did anyone say this, user. it's better than NLDW though
shit, i read NOTM
but that's even worse, I thought NLDW wasn't much, but after a few listens it sunk in and it's definitely better than exmilitary imho
it doesnt really matter my DG ratings constantly evolve anyways
Tweez - 8.5/10
Spiderland - 10/10
Slint EP - 7/10
take it however which way you want, exmilitary more 'listenable' full of bangers -- first album that broke the ground. NLDW more intense. deeper, harder to pull apart. more bold and experimental but it doesn't have quite the catalog as exmil and isn't as fluid.
really it just comes down to preference they're all genre shattering works of art regardless of what the meme-hating fags say.
RC 7/10
S/T 10/10
E/O 9/10
XO 10/10
Figure 8 7.5/10
FABOTH 8/10
Bump up Death Magnetic.
>10 - OK Computer
>10- Kid A
>10 - In Rainbows
>9.3 - Hail to the Thief
>9.1 - A Moon Shaped Pool
>8.6 - The King of Limbs
>8.4 - Amnesiac
>7.6 - The Bends
>7.0 - Pablo Honey
>10 - Funeral
>9.8 - The Suburbs
>9.3 - Neon Bible
>9.0 - Reflektor
>10 - A Rush of Blood to the Head
>9.2 - X&Y
>9.2 - Viva La Vida or Death & All of His Friends
>9.1 - Parachutes
>7.8 - Ghost Stories
>7.0 - Mylo Xyloto
>6.8 - A Head Full of Dreams
>slint EP
>not 9/10
>tweez better than slint EP
user I...
how can you be a fan of coldplay and radiohead at the same time? doesn't that defy physics?
Even worse, he thinks 4 of Coldplay's albums are better than Amnesiac.
Hybrid Theory - 5/10
Meteora - 4/10
Minutes to Midnight - 3/10
A Thousand Suns - 8/10
Living Things - 5/10
The Hunting Party - 6/10
>Death Magnetic
>Better than Ride the Lightning
SAW: 8/10
SAW 2: 9/10
...ICBYD: 10/10
RDJ: 8.5/10
Drukqs: 9.5/10
Syro: 7/10
Volume 1: 5/10
Holy Mountain: 8.5/10
Dopesmoker: 10/10
The Clarity: 7.5/10
Debut : 5.5
Post : 7
Homogenic : 8.5
Vespertine : 9
Medulla : 8
Volta : 4.5
Biophilia : 7
Vulnicura : 8
Pixies:
Surfer Rosa: 8/10
Doolitle: 9,5/10
Bossanova: 10/10
Trompe Le Monde: 8/10
Indie Cindy: 6,5/10 (Not the same thing without Kim Deal, but i liked it anyway)
Hell Paso 4/10
¡Alfaro Vive, Carajo! 3.5/10
Acrobatic Tenement 7.5/10
El Gran Orgo 5/10
In/Casino/Out 9/10
Vaya 7/10
Relationship of Command 8/10
Is This It: 8,5/10
Room on Fire: 9,5/10
First Impressions of Earth: 3/10
Angles: 6/10
Comedown Machine: 7/10
Future Present Past EP: 0/10 (Absolute dogshit)
Switch The Hunter and Once More and you're spot on mate
I almost choked with laughed when I read the Barter 6 rate, thanks for the kek my duder
Because it's better
Magma is at LEAST a 6/10 my boi
1980 s/t. 9/10
What's This For 8/10
Revelations 7/10
Fire Dances 7/10
Night Time 10/10
Brighter Than A Thousand Suns 8/10
Outside the Gate 6/10
Extremities Dirt & Various Repressed Emotions 8/10
Pandemonium 8/10
Democracy 7/10
2003 s/t. 9/10
Hosannas from the Basements of Hell 7/10
Absolute Dissent 8/10
MMXII 7/10
Pylon 7/10
Please Please Me - 3/10
With The Beatles - 3/10
Meet The Beatles - 4/10
Hard Days' Night - 5/10
For Sale - 3/10
Help - 3/10
Rubber Soul - 5/10
Revolver - 5/10
Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band - 7/10
Magical Mystery Tour - 6/10
The Beatles - 6/10
Yellow Submarine - 5/10
Abbey Road - 7/10
Let It Be - 4/10
>favorite
look at this young man. he looks so happy, so at peace in the grass with his music. can that happen anymore? can that happen to me?
>s/t not being 10/10
From Genesis to Revelation 5/10
Trespass 8/10
Nursery Cryme 9/10
Foxtrot 10/10
Selling England by the Pound 9/10
The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway 10/10
A Trick of the Tail 9/10
Wind & Wuthering 9/10
And Then There Were Three 8/10
Duke 9/10
Abacab 7/10
s/t 8/10
Invisible Touch 6/10
We Can't Dance 4/10
Calling All Stations 3/10
13 Songs - 8/10
Repeater - 9/10
Steady Diet of Nothing - 6.5/10
In on the Kill Taker - 9.5/10
Red Medicine - 10/10
End Hits - 7/10
The Argument - 9/10