Can they be classified as a "punk" band?

Can they be classified as a "punk" band?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=ZsZyzjBuXuw
youtube.com/watch?v=QcA1H7m8xw0
twitter.com/AnonBabble

No.

Why not?
They had that whole DIY/imperfect vibe that defines punk music

of course

Which is it?

who gives a fuck lmao

/thread

I do

then ur not punx and hsouldnmt be listening to it

early emo desu

obviously you fucking idiot

Yes, but only up until Leaves

>classifying music based on non-musical traits
Plz stop

>classifying music
pls stop

>music
pls stop

what band is this

sent ;)

Unwound. they're a pretty good post-hardore band with a discography of remarkably consistent quality

Post-Hardcore Punk.
A lot of people like to leave out the "Punk" after Hardcore, which leads to a lot of lost genealogy, but technically they would be.

kinda

emo is punk

autism

theres nothing autist about that, you literal autist
that's what the genre is called

is called post-hardcore you fuccking autist

post-hardcore is and has always been an abbreviation of post-hardcore punk
you should end urself for not knowing this

total autism

Yes, they're post-hardcore, which is derived from hardcore punk, which is a sub-genre of punk rock

Image

Does it matter. Just listen to the music

Punk rock is the worst music genre of all time.

Prove me wrong.

You don't know punk

The wiggles

No, I do think it's important. I love punk, punk is the love of my life. And a lot of people who listen to "Hardcore" and "Post-hardcore" then to ignore it's relationship to Punk, which makes me sad.

tend to ignore*
*its relationship
Sorry, I'm so drunk my vision is blurry.

>post-hardcore punk
Lmfao you sound very smart

>punk
no.

>"punk"
""yes.""

>Sup Forums discusses punk music: the thread

yes, because that's what they are. post-hardcore is literally "post-hardcore punk rock"

>>classifying music based on non-musical traits

that's how a GOOD number of genres are classified and organized you uneducated fool

Who are you quoting?

Also, are you really coming to Sup Forums for anything more than funposting and waifu contests, much less a discussion? What a f*g (excuse the language).

>implying Lucky acid isn't the greatest punk song under 2 minutes

youtube.com/watch?v=ZsZyzjBuXuw

>early emo
here's your reply
it's post-hardcore

mozart was a thing once

youtube.com/watch?v=QcA1H7m8xw0

how good is that part at 7:20... would've loved a longer song based on this. or just sample this shit.

pls stop

Are The Fall "punk" Sup Forums?

i'm """""""""""""""""""punk""""""""""""""""""" if you know what i mea n

:D