Why is this a thing?

why is this a thing?

What a thing?

PFNO is superior to TLCW.

I humbly disagree.

thats because you have shitaste

Doesn't seem humble at all

besides who fucking cares, both albums are rated well, it is just .01 off.

Hate this shit. Can't stand fucking reddit mouse

reminder that Built to Spill are still releasing quality albums while Modest Mouse have sunk to the point of making Imagine Dragons-tier 'alternative' slop.

>Scaruffi drone

WEW

yeah but first 3 modest mouse albums > bts' entire discography

That's a very strong, yet baseless opinion you have there, user

no

name a single bts album that's better than any of those three. i'll wait my dude.

perfect from now on
not very hard

spoken as someone who clearly hasn't even listened to built to spill lol. bts 2nd through 4th albums are brilliant.

Perfect From Now On is better than Modest Mouse discography. More innovative and challengin. Isaac Brock can't even sing properly

>excluding Ultimate Alternative Wavers

both are amazing but i think TLCW beats out PFNO by a fair margin

PFNO may be more well-written and atmospheric, but TLCW just has such raw, infectious passion and emotion. and nothing built to spill can do can compare with jeremiah green's drumming on TLCW.

it's trash compared to their later stuff

That's not a reason, user

There's Nothing Wrong With Love, Perfect from Now On, and Keep It Like a Secret are all better than any Modest Mouse album. And I think Modest Mouse is pretty good

Because MM is slight more popular but that doesn't mean anything and this thread shouldn't exist

It's not, though. How can you listen to Shameful Dread, Nowhere Nothin' Fuckup and Get A Life and not see that UAW is at least on par with There's Nothing Wrong With Love?

yea, agreed. UAW is a pretty dope album, pretty underrated but I still think BtS really stepped it up on their later albums.

what list is this?

how can you even imply that PFNO lacks passion and emotion? just cuz Martsch isn't always screaming at the top of his lungs doesn't mean it lacks any of that. to me, PFNO is very personal and emotional. I'm with you on the drumming on TLCW tho.

>bad production
>songs drag on forever

There's Nothing Wrong With Love is my favorite BTS record because it has everything UAW lacks. It's snappy, songs are short and it's an incredibly enjoyable listen from start to finish. fucking fantastic lyrics as well.

i like both