...
Friendly reminder that if you consider this to be post-punk, you're fucking retarded
Easton Gomez
Xavier Price
I consider it rock.
Its all rock.
Stop being so autistic with rock genres.
Henry Bennett
why?
Robert Hall
"Post-Punk" isn't a genre. It's just a term made up by the British music press when the UK started generating bands that were ripping off Talking Heads, Television and Patti Smith instead of The Ramones, all of whom were part of the same scene and just considered "punk."
Luke Young
all genres are made up moron
Parker Ortiz
ok. I am "fucking retarded"
Parker Bell
so what are some real post punk albums
William Rodriguez
Everyone who has posted in this thread so far is actually correct.
Genres are made up, musical scenes are much larger than genres and tend to incorporate multiple named genres.
Matthew Bell
it's poptism-core
Ian Jenkins
learn to read rtard
Julian James
It's not really post-punk because it came out while the original punk scene still existed
James Rogers
so they are first wave punk?
Xavier Wood
...
Josiah Brooks
It's polyphonic dadrock.
Gabriel Perez
#ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK #ROCK
ITS JUST ROCK
Brody Walker
public image limited - second edition
Andrew Allen
lots of post-punk albums came out when the original punk scene still existed
television basically started the original punk scene years before this album anyway so it would make sense that they were ahead of the curve a bit
Jason Cox
Rock; Art Punk
Jaxon Williams
It is punk influenced, but still totally different. How is that not pp.
You fucking sperg, the "post" label only requires the punk scene to had existed at the time, because it means that post-punk actually took influence from punk.
If it was like you say, post-rock wouldn't even exist.
Grayson Sanders
Does this sound like Marquee Moon to anybody?
Cooper Jones
Art Punk
Michael Nguyen
lmao i bet no one in here has even read simon reynolds book on post punk
Dominic Cooper
>in favor of experimentation with production techniques and non-rock musical styles such as [...] jazz.
>previous musical styles did serve as touchstones for the movement including particular brands of glam, art rock...
Literally Marquee Moon
link?
Jose Turner
>post-punk
>opposed to rockism
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Cameron Long
You're right. It's just shitty dadrock.
Ian Phillips
not a genre
Lincoln Hall
what constitute a 'genre'?
Benjamin Sanchez
u can find an epub on slsk or aaaargh or something
Juan Cruz
>Rejection of aesthetics perceived as traditionalist.
Marquee Moon on the surface sounds like a typical rock album. The jazz influence is in the composition, not the overall sound.
Brandon Fisher
whatever the term 'art punk' lacks
Justin Ortiz
You sure convinced me.
Julian Martin
I hate all of you
Nathan Torres
Good. We hate you too.
Jeremiah Myers
Define "we"
Jose Reyes
All of us.
Isaiah Robinson
What's so funny dude haha
Angel Wood
Define "us"
Luke Ross
I will never not be impressed by your focused and open-minded discussions, Sup Forums.
Austin Evans
We