Who was right on this Sup Forums? Anthony, Pitchfork, or Marcel?

Who was right on this Sup Forums? Anthony, Pitchfork, or Marcel?

Nobody.

out of 5, it's about a 3.75-8

objectively

not even memeing - my personal score is probably closest to marcel's (even tho his actual review was garbage + he's irrelevant). did not like wildflower at all.

surprisingly, i'd say p4k had the best review overall.

Yourself.

>he's irrelevant
kek

Exactly. Why do you guys need someone else to tell you what's good?

NME

it's a meme you dip

pitchfork

i personally think the album is an 8.7 though. it's great and it will be remembered fondly 16 years from now when the avalanches release the follow up to their follow up

don't take it so seriosly

NME is irrelevant. plus it was almost the same score as Marcel's.

M e h
e
h

NME is irrelevant, but do you really think some little faggot teenager is?

marcel is not just some random guy who's only known on Sup Forums

The independent

Me
I like it
Fuck all that trash

what did they give it?

...

9.3 BNM

pitchfork was closest, even tho it's an 8, but they inflate scores anyway

plebs

>call yourself The Independent
>be owned by a Russian oligarch

anyone have the m4a?

None of them are right. Music critics are cancer.

>Objectively
Music is subjective, idiot.

I want a music critic that only gives qualitative reviews, as in, no numerical score whatsoever. Giving a number just encourages parroting taste by assigning a score to something that is purely subjective, and it encourages people essentially taking sparknotes of an album by telling them exactly how to feel about it.

anthony

The Quietus used to be good at this but nowadays their reviews are either clickbait or pretty threadbare and short.

Conversely, The Wire used to be pretty needlessly pretentious but they've toned it down in recent years. Probably one of the better publications even if Sup Forums likes to make fun of it.

Tiny Mix Tapes was pretty on the money

Download link?

he pretty much is. hey marcel btw

what makes you think this?

I was right

Anthony, of course.

daily reminder that any music critic who openly admits that they browse here is a shit critic

Please get off this board Marcel. You aren't even of age yet.

Eloquentmark

if i have to repeat another user's sentiment from another thread:

i really wish you could step outside your fucking meme sphere for once and be open to actual discussion, because it makes me sad that i deliver valid counterarguments and you just stick to spouting your shitty fucking overused memes without providing any sort of real response. it just shows how little you care.

stop this shitty fucking meme. well known music people don't browse this board nor do they care about us. stop being an asshole who thinks everything revolves around this shithole. it's just like the shitty "go to bed dean" and "go to bed james" memes that fucking idiots kept spouting for weeks on end.

you never brought up a counter argument. you just said "he is known elsewhere", with absolutely no reference, source, or point.

If that is valid, then I present you with my counter argument:

You're wrong.

my source is look it up. look it up on any of his social media pages or simply just google search results.

and what kind of counterargument is that? where is your proof that you're the correct one in this situation?

Your counter argument is just as weak, that was my entire point.

hey marcy!!

GET THE FLAC AND CONVERT IT YOU NIGGER

marcel isn't the main focus of the post you idiot. fuck off.

my nigga

The Quietus had the best review honestly.

It's always so obvious when you're posting, Marcel.

Do you even try to sound like someone else?

He's literally only relevant on Sup Forums and RYM

What did Montie say?

no. see:

Me.

stop this shitty fucking meme. it's so fucking shitty and stupid. fuck off.

Im not even memeing. I equally hate the "goto bed"'esque memes but you're making it painfully obvious that you are in fact Marcel.

Especially considering no one on Sup Forums actually gives a fuck about him and certainly wouldn't respond so aggressively.

i am literally not him. you seem quite immature imo.

Haha ok Marcel ;P