Wtf happened to pitchfork? I used to love then and now they give second rate Gucci Mane ripoffs a best new music
What did they mean by this?
Leo Carter
Other urls found in this thread:
Jordan Nelson
wtf i hate pitchfork now
Landon Ramirez
they're paid, but still generally a good indicator of what is worth giving a listen
David Butler
why does Pitchfork give an obligatory 5 points to every single fucking rap album?
Do they really only like rap and post rock?
It's embarrassing this site even exists.
Samuel Murphy
How about you stop going on pitchfork
Dominic Wilson
They'd be called racist if they ignored mainstream rap
Never mind that they only review hyper-mainstream rappers and never venture into the underground, which contradicts everything they used to stand for
Jeremiah Perry
>gave Sleep Cycle (AOTY imo) a 7.6
>give every generic rap album under the sun a BNM
Jacob Allen
>album where every song sounds exactly the same got a higher rating than Blank Face LP
Ayden Campbell
Except of course Rodeo, one of the most experimental and interesting trap albums ever made gets a 6.0, a fucking 6.0, because Travis apparently sounds like other people. These are the same retards that gave Kodak Black and Kevin Gates high scores because those rappers totally aren't derivative.
Dominic Wood
Somehow white guilt has infiltrated the music reviewing industry.
Gabriel Diaz
...
Cameron Roberts
>Gates
>A Gucci Mane ripoff
Improve your shitposting skills. If serious, yeah I definitely agree that Islah doesn't deserve that rating mainly because Gates has released much better stuff and he's made more mainstream in this album, but still no Gucci Mane ripoff you end up sounding just as ignorant as P4K.
Jeremiah Thompson
Theyve literally been doing this since mid 2000s, but you can't remember because you were fucking 3 years old
Hunter Torres
>Kodak Black
He's such shit. when I hear him, it makes me think of all the things I hate about rap.
Robert Hernandez
They are both southern trap rappers who rap about the same stuff and have a similar sound and aesthetic
Oliver Torres
>a bunch of 20 something privileged white trust fund kids (i know some aren't technically white but they're white on the inside)
+
>no knowledge of music theory and music history
+
>no exposure to albums and genres outside of a p4k approved bubble
+
>impetus to be socially progressive whilst staying profitable
=
>affirmative action approach to reviewing music
Wanting to bring attention to talented, lesser known musicians of color is not inherently a bad thing but that's not what pitchfork are doing despite operating under this guise. Sometime's I'm not even sure if they're aware that their taste in trap and other trendy genres is bad and/or outdated.
When they do get it right it's never because they genuinely believe the music is good, rather because the music is trendy and so 1. it has to be good or 2. regardless of the quality, a positive review to a buzzing artist will translate to an increase in ad revenue
Nathan Russell
Does anyone here have any actual opinions on the album? They definitely overrated it, but it wasn't the worst thing ever. It was certainly better than views if nothing else.
Ayden Green
Hi antnee can you make a cal only YouTube channel please
Luis Thompson
Nah, Kevin Gates is like something between the typical southern trap rapper and someone like Drake. His whole shtick is to juxtapose the usual ghetto and drugs and stuff with a more emotional side which often deals with his mental health problems.
Kevin Adams
he has a point, Sup Forums is full of morons
Logan Watson
They gave lil yachty a 4 point something
Blake Harris
>tfw Lil Yachty is the only trap rapper I like
p4k is so full of shit
Kevin Sanchez
They're trying to be Rolling Stone + Source + Jet magazine
I would just disregard their scores entirely. Their scores are all purely political and based in affirmative action instead of objective musical analysis.
John Rivera
6.5 at best
Blake Evans
Damn, he snapped
Easton Scott
I have more respect for him now. Dude made some good points.
Wyatt Fisher
I'd have been happy with a 7.2 - 8.0, just not BNM though
Connor Bell
>just checked him out and listened to Minnesota
Yikes
Nolan Mitchell
Pitchfork basically did the same thing with Rodeo that Fantano did with MBDTF, pick one thing they dont like and use that to justify a bad score while ignoring thr overwhelming amount of positives. However imo this should be circlejerked more than Fantano's MBDTF 6. To think that in any way Kodak Black is even approaching what Travis Scott did on Rodeo is a joke, and to not apply the same logic and say that Kodak sounds like Lil Wayne is retarded.
Jaxon Morris