ITT: Post a classic album and what you think is their modern equivalent.
>pic related
>both are artists who have very weird singing voices that people either love or hate
>both have complex, abstract lyrics and unconventional song structures/lengths
>both have a signature instrument they play (Dylan harmonica, Newsom harp)
>both albums are very ambitious and lengthy (BoB is one of the first double albums ever made, HOOM is a triple album)
bump
this is a lot harder than i thought but your examples are really good
Bumping this thread for potential.
Bump good idea user
bump
Agreed
revolver and one directions 4
great start OP, wish I had something of my own to contribute
bump for potential
Wow this is literally perfect
Too bad i can't come up with any good comparison
...
...
Bump for interest
I forgot to explain,
>Both have a raw, natural sound.
>Both are folky and acoustic but incorporate very subtle elements of psychedelia.
>Both get basically the same overall reaction.
what's the album on the left?
The Band - Music From Big Pink
bump. i'll make one l8t3r
both albums have beautiful and emotional pop songs, and dreamy tracks as well
I like this alot
At least in terms of concept
You had me really excited until I read it. The final cut is so good.
...
Yeah, I'd say this is pretty accurate. I might associate Feels more with Wish You Were Here though, just because they were both the last album the artist did before they started to take another artistic direction - with Animal Collective that was going in a more electric, pop-based direction and with Pink Floyd that was a more cynical attitude with Roger Waters overshadowing the rest of the band - and they both have this glistening, fleeting quality to them. The very end of Turn Into Something and Shine On You Crazy Diamond, part 9 both evoke the same kind of vibe for me, and definitely feel like the end of something.
I might pick Pop Tatari instead of Niggas On the Moon.
obviously one is a lot more legendary than the other, but i get similar feelings listening to the two.
b u m p
...
is that album actually good or meme
total meme
it's a meme
...
not even joking
Kind of a stretch to be honest. I can see some similarities though
how are they even remotely similar?
i disagree with this heavily but that is okay
...
Whoops, wrong pic
Damn...
good meme
More like Pet Sounds and Illinoise
mene
does this mean Sgt. Pepper = Kid A?
hell yes
>does this mean Sgt. Pepper = Kid A?
>the slightly more hyped one that's actually not quite as brilliant as its predecessor
Absolutely it is.
what makes OKC more brilliant than Kid A?
musically Kid A was far more diverse and innovative than OKC, OKC was basically just a really, really well-done alt-rock album.
>revolver better than sgt pep
I can deal with this
>okc better than kid a
No.
SHeD uP
I would have gone with Person Pitch
I'd actually argue this
I posted both the beach boys anco one and the beatles radiohead one. Good feedback though.
...
I thought of this one in the sense that this was the album for both bands to change everything about their music.
I see it.
...
both artists took the sound of their respective noise rock scenes and deconstructed the hell out of it
which albums?
That would be Fifteen Big Ones.
STOP
damn...
Yes
Royal Trux - Twin Infinitives
The Hospitals - Hairdryer Peace
...
they are equivalent in that they are both considered the best of hiphop in that era not really in terms of how it sounds
>diverse
Agreed
>innovative
Nah, like Revolver, OKC had a perfect blend of what the band once did and what they would later do. For instance Revolver had psychedelic influences that weren't as full blown as they would be on Sgt. Pepper, but also that keen crisp pop sensibility that they had on previous albums. OKC had plenty of electronic elements on it but also had Bends style alt rock on it too. It wasn't as embellished as Kid A per se. In all honesty Kid A isn't any bigger a leap forward from OKC as OKC was from The Bends. So I have trouble calling it more innovative from that point, perhaps equally innovative, but not more. Kid A was a bigger "commercial" risk than OKC was, but aside from that it still wasn't a better album, at least not to me anyway. OKC flows so smoothly.
This