So we can all agree that this is objectively their best album right?
So we can all agree that this is objectively their best album right?
Agreed.
yeah, easily
Agreed
So let's rank the others.
I say Animals is second
That's not piper
Animals > WYWH > Meddle
My rating
Wish you were here
Dark side of the moon
Animals
The wall
Meddle
Piper at the gates of dawn
Ummagumma
(I haven't listened to any others)
Why not Dark Side of the Moon?
Fully agree
WYWH is a mediocre piece of shit that should just have been a 30min EP. I say this as someone who fucking hates those threads about reducing an album's size.
No. Not at all.
It's probably one of the blander things they've done. Have a Cigar is actually underrated as hell.
This. Shine On You Crazy Diamond is overblown to hell and back.
Is Money the most overrated song of all time?
It's the worst song on the album.
Their most boring album and I've listened to the division bell.
The great gig in the sky is objectively the worst song on the album
Kill yourself faggot
Money overrated? Yes
Of all time? Hell no
Sweet child of mine is probably the most overrated rock song of all time
heh, good one fella
agreed
You are right
Us and Them > Time > Eclipse > Great Gig in the Sky > Any Colour You Like > Money > Breathe >Speak to Me > On the Run
The Wall>WYWH>DSOTM
WYWH>AHM>Animals>DSOTM>Obscured by Clouds>The Wall>the rest
You poor fuck.
No. We can't.
But Us and Them is the worst song on the album...
...
Are you guys actually being serious? I mean the piano is great and the atmosphere is also great. But the girl screaming like a banshee in the background makes me skip the song almost every times listen to the album
easily
Meddle >Animals>Rest...
For sure, but that's kind of what 70's rock was about.
Holy shit, end yourself
This is really the only Floyd album I care for so yeah
Piper>Meddle>Saucerful>WYWH>Animals>Ummagumma>Dark Side>AHM>Wall>Division Bell>Final Cut>Lapse of Reason>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>The Endless Meme
(Haven't listened to the soundtrack albums yet)
>meddle and piper below the wall
>dark side second place
Piper exists
any colour you like is best
You are correct guy, just swap Meddle and Saucerful and you're there, pretty close second and third though.
most definitely
Pompeii is a very close second