I'll start it off.
Solid album overall, but Echoes is a little excessive
I'll start it off
Matthew Green
Gabriel Miller
I never liked Echoes
as far as long proggy pink floyd songs go, ive always prefer Shine On because part 8 of that is the best thing theyve ever done
listen to it, its like funk, new age, rock, psych, prog, art, electronic etc all wrapped together
Sebastian Edwards
And that's why WYWH is the best Pink Floyd album. It also has that lounge feel that bands like Bark Psychosis meddled in. Part 9 is my favourite though.
Colton Bennett
>guitar arpeggios with effects pedals
das it
Ayden Cruz
I like echoes but I agree WYWH is their best album
Thomas Carter
Echoes is cool because of the mysterious strange feel in the beginning and then it goes into the middle of the song with the weird sounds and interesting atmosphere with the wind and stuff
then it just ends pretty strong i think because of the heavy sounds guitars
I love shine on you crazy diamond but I think Meddle sounds more grand than WYWH for some reason
Christian Collins
meddle is just a pleb version of Shine One
meddle even has a "funky" part like funky dung from the Atom heart Mother suite, except both of those are shit compared to Shine On part 8
Joshua Young
i mean echoes not the album meddle
Andrew Hill
I don't know about "Best album," as Roger suffered lyrically on most of the record, but Shine On is a very well-made track, and I love their idea to bookend the album with it. Storm did a very nice job with the album art as well.
I personally prefer Atom Heart Mother as an album, as each member contributes to the writing more equally, and it's just so comfy throughout.
Levi Flores
atom heart mother as a whole is lame and forgettable