Scaruffi on "Slow Riot for New Zero Kanada"

>Moya (one of their masterpieces) begins in cerebral manner in chamber music for strings but hovers then in a sweet melody in tumultuous crescendo
>calls the field recording on BBFIII "cloying" but says it develops into a majestic crescendo instrumental
He gave it a 6/10... I don't get it

6/10 is good.

autimus prime

But that contradicts what he is saying, and he has shit on albums and gave it a 6/10.

he's a mathematician. numbers are more important to him than they are to the average person, so a 6/10 is like an 8/10 for a normie.

He has shit on albums that got a 6/10 before.

He never gave Swans more than a 8, but he gave like 4 of them. His writing makes them sound like the greatest rock band ever.

he uses complex differential equations to come up with the final scores so sometimes one 6 will be seemingly better reviewed than another 6.

He rates albums based only on innovation, so he can think that something is very well done but if it's not innovative it won't get a very high score

But I don't understand why he gave the EP a 6/10, if he liked most of the aspects of it, other than the length of the vocal sample, but is that a factor that would knock 4 points down?