If a song has lyrics, its a shitty song

If a song has lyrics, its a shitty song.
It means it can't convey emotion through sound alone.
Prove me wrong, you can't.

Other urls found in this thread:

soundcloud.com/2-spoopy/vol-3
twitter.com/SFWRedditImages

that's bullshit
also borp

bo[spoiler]skeleton[/spoiler]rp

I dont get it

You're first mistake is putting limitations on music.
All music reflects intention, even if it is shallow.
Some music is intended to be fun, and to only stimulated emotion on a base level. Such as making you dance, while other music is deeper. It seeds itself and the roots reach into your very soul.
Faggot.

there aren't any spoilers on this board. everyone go home.

True, this is why all I listen to is electronic music. Since the beginning of recorded music you can hear hints of electro, and now more than ever people are waking up to the "scene" and in the future there will be no more nickelbacks it will all be electronic. As deadmau5 said putting words in a song is stupid

Honestly I hate listening to human voice, so I only listen to stuff that have no singing at all.

But your argument is stupid. Many people listen to songs on languages they don't understand, so clearly the lyrics are not the means of conveying emotions there. A more accurate definition would be:
> If a song has lyrics, its a song with lyrics.
> It means the author wanted lyrics in it.

Listen to Ennio Moriccone - The Ecstasy of Gold
Tell me you hate her voice, and that you cannot feel the connection between drama, discovery, and humanity in a such an inspiring way.
If you can't, you are not a human being

Kill yourself immediately nerd

this times one thousand

everything from ennio morricone is downright brilliant

Oh sorry didn't mean to disturb your Taylor swift listening

For me the human voice is just like another instrument that may or may not fit the music. It's not bad to not like singing at all, it's just the same if someone said he doesn't like flutes or bagpipes.

It just means his mother screamed at him his whole life

bo[skelton]spoiler[/skeleton]rp

not every song is meant to convey emotion.
there

Yet they can compliment each other so following your logic:
If a song doesn't have lyrics its a shitty song.
It means it didn't use everything it could to convey the emotion and you're getting a half assed product.

Shut the door on your way out and enjoy whatever you listen to, nobody cares. Sup Forums loves to bash you for it though.

some songs are meant to tell a story.

wow
That's like saying sex is not meant to feel good
Or that food is not meant to sustain you
You are a retard

If you can't tell the story without lyrics it's a shit story

>his song can't tell a story without lyrics
lmao @ ur life

>>skeleton

What detailed story can you tell without the precision of language?
Non lyrical music is very limited in that, while it can be used to its own advantage to demonstrate emotion, it lacks the ability to tell detailed stories.

my fucking sides

underrated post.

not true, no limitations on music

the only music i really truly enjoy is all about conveying texture emotion feeling through music and sounds


soundcloud.com/2-spoopy/vol-3

give it a try, i bet you've never heard anything like it, whether good or bad

bump

bo [spoiler]skeleton[spoiler] rp
Wait what? Spoilertags don't work on Sup Forums...

>You are first mistake
Someone told you you used 'your' wrong, but you never learned to use it right.

Damn shame. You're supposed to use "your" in this sentence.

wow holy shit this is good


nice bait

the apostrophe adds posession to a word
saying you're means it is his
you're brain doesn't work well

hope this is bait...if it doesnt have lyrics its not a fucking song, its just music......fucking autist

he's baiting out reddit fags

Considering the only punctuation in your whole post is an unneeded apostrophe, you probably shouldn't be giving out grammar lessons.

You're an idiot...
Of course it's a song
We call a piece of music a SONG

Lesson's*

Touché

jesus christ the bait is unstoppable

or anybody that ever posted on those cheap bb forums