Who did it best?
Who did it best?
Bentley Reed
Other urls found in this thread:
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtu.be
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
twitter.com
Christopher Rodriguez
u2
Thomas Kelly
U2
Daniel Rogers
The Fall, Wire, Chrome and Killing Joke in that specific order.
Jose Nguyen
Conceptually: The Fall
Technically: Wire
Jaxon Cooper
What's essential post punk core?
Brayden Phillips
Interpol
Elijah Hill
U2
Ryder Gomez
U2
Ian Sullivan
U2
Ian Cruz
Siouxie
Michael Carter
Fucking memes.
Talking Heads
Parker Collins
>not saying Joy Division
okay, contrarians
Logan Cook
The Chameleons > Joy Division
Adrian Lewis
the chameleons
this desu
Adam Mitchell
Talking Cat Bob pls go
Matthew Scott
>Yanks
Aiden Harris
Dont forget about Magazine, Sup Forums
Charles Brown
Complicated question.
If you mean in terms of making it into a viable popular music genre... U2... The Cure... Talking Heads...
In terms of playing good rock n' rawl muzak but updating it... Joy Division... Killing Joke... Mission of Burma... The Fall...
If you mean in terms of breaking down genre barriers with a punk attitude about it and sorta reinventing prog... This Heat... Devo... PiL... Pere Ubu...
Aaron Sullivan
Pere Ubu
Christopher Hughes
Pylon.
Blake Garcia
>All of music has been shaped by this one concert
Asher Jenkins
My favorite.
Owen Davis
How the hell did Killing Joke go from post-punk and goth rock to sounding like Ministry
Isaac Cruz
Lack of integrity and jumping on the popularity bandwagon?
Jaxson Bailey
Pandemic is a great album
Easton Morgan
>Sounding like Ministry??
What album are you talking about? Hosannas?
Mason Rodriguez
Are Television post punk?
Chase Ortiz
I mean pandemonium lol
Angel Phillips
youtube.com
best track
Kevin Edwards
Great answer actually
Noah Russell
to be honest, this...
youtube.com
youtube.com
is a pretty logical evolution of this...
youtube.com
youtube.com
there's a reason why one of justin broadrick's early bands which would eventually evolve into godflesh took their name from a killing joke song
nah, that was the two new wave albums that they put out in the mid-80s(one of which the band disavowed and the other which wasn't intended to be a sellout pop album but became one when the record label brought in a second producer and had him remix the already recorded and mixed album for the sake of making it more commercially viable)
in the top 10 rock albums for the 80s
Leo Nguyen
Nice to see Killing Joke get some love around here. Great fucking band.
Dylan Robinson
Joy Division perfected the sound with Closer. Every post-punk album after that is simply derivative and inferior, though not necessarily bad.
Benjamin Wilson
Oh my fucking god.
And hero please
Colton Bell
>implying U2 weren't post-punk
Nicholas Miller
The Pop Group you fucking mongs
Robert Murphy
Public Image Ltd
Colton Rogers
lol no
Logan Sanders
siouxsie and the banshees or suicide
Blake Jenkins
This Heat you stupid gits
Chase Richardson
Franz Ferdinand
Asher Hughes
women
Bentley Nelson
this
Jonathan Williams
Wire and This Heat.
Jason Lee
this is too vague but either or all of the following:
>heads (tampered with the punk formula instrumentally to a degree where the music wholly embodies the literal meaning of "post-punk")
>joy division (the above, but more pertaining to the music's atmosphere)
>wire (best band)
>human league (one of the first and best to do the synth thing)
Josiah Miller
The Sound > The Chameleons > Joy Division
Isaac Hughes
This Heat, The Pop Group, Pere Ubu the list goes on...
David Rodriguez
this is the correct answer
Jonathan Edwards
Finally a motherfucker who gets it.
Bentley Russell
The first three PiL records are the epitome of post-punk
Isaiah Smith
Pop maru
youtube.com
Jeremiah Barnes
Gavin Mitchell
they all sound the same desu
Bentley Clark
implying they wrote a better song then this youtu.be
Levi Green
Television you uncultured fucks
Austin Ross
Fuck all you for not mentioning the most obvious answer.
Owen Evans
Seems like a pretty good threeway distinction in postpunk, and your picks are very good overall. Good post.
Kevin Kelly
this
Andrew Murphy
Siouxsie and the Banshees
Austin Rivera
How is this even a question?
Benjamin Young
XTC
youtube.com
Elvis Costello
youtube.com
Camden James
lolno, the chameleons is just interpol in the 80s
Zachary Thompson
except Chameleons is at least fucking bearable
Elijah White
I think Joy Division perfected it in the very beginning, but I really really enjoy this album.