Time for the age old question

Time for the age old question.

Floyd or Crimson?

Making sure to avoid newfags therefore didn't put Dark Side or In the Court

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=PncSKrOAwl8
dubtrack.fm/join/progkrautpsych-rock
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

King Crimson btfo Floyd

Floyd is my favorite overall for the quality of their songwriting, I like the mix of prog/art rock with accessibility. KC was a more advanced band, technically and compositionally, but they could be a little too cerebral and they took themselves too seriously.

In the Court is obviously way better than Dark Side, but I like Piper at the Gates more than anything Crimson's done

Its close but the edge goes to Floyd.

Gilmour > Fripp

Echoes > Starless

Wish You Were Here > Red

2 of Progs best right here

Neither. There are lots of way better prog and psych bands from the same era. Having to choose one though, probably Floyd.

Crimson by a landslide

Animals>Red>WYWH>DSoTM>Piper at The Gates of Dawn>ITCOCK

hot opinion, friend :)

desu senpai CttE is better than anything either of them put out

Floyd was more consistent

both boring dadrock. next question.

>le born in teh rite generation AHaha fuck you dad !

Such as?

I'd gladly tell you the answer if I could give KC a listen on YouTube.

King Crimson >>>>>>>>>>>>> Pink Floyd

Neither. Both are shit tier prog albums

you anti-wrong generation faggots are almost as annoying as le wrong generation dickheads

bump for TRUTH

I think I enjoy Red more than any PF album except Wish You Were Here, though

>Gilmour > Fripp
Fripp is superior in every stat.
>guitar skills
>songwriting
>artistic integrity

Kill yourselves

I just think there's better prog you easily triggered faggot

>Fripp is superior in every stat.
not in selling albums
or Guitar solos

Well post it or fuck off

666

Egg
Gong
Can
Amon Duul II
Eloy
Yes
Neu!
Univers Zero

WYWH>Everything else

Only Yes and Can comes close to these so you're full of shit

this shouldn't be did? clearly fallen angel is one of the best progpop tracks ever, and pink floyd were the first band of guys who weren't very talented but tried really hard and still managed to do well. pink floyd is proto post rock, and it's okay because they were the first ones.

dumb opinion

Since all you queers only seem to know 2 KC albums here's both bands' discographies in an objective power ranking
(Excluding "More" because it's a soundtrack and "endless river" because how it happened was a travesty)

Larks' Tongues in Aspic>
Wish You Were Here>
In the Court of The Crimson King>
Red>
Animals>
Discipline>
Dark Side of the Moon>
Meddle>
Three of a Perfect Pair>
The Wall>
Lizard>
Thrak>
Ummagumma>
The Final Cut>
the construcKtion of light>
A Saucer Full of Secrets>
Starless and Bible Black>
The Piper at the Gates of Dawn>
In the Wake of Poseidon>
Atom Heart Mother>
Islands>
Beat>
The Power to Believe>
The Division Bell>
A Momentary Lapse of Reason

>le epic gilmour solos xd

nothing Gilmour ever made comes close to Fripp's solo on this youtube.com/watch?v=PncSKrOAwl8

who invented psych rock?
who invented prog rock?

>Psych
The Yardbirds
>Prog
The Moody Blues

Your point?

>unironically trying to justify Gilmour because he sold more albums

The only objective way to measure quality

drink some clorox, gilmour

They were questions, not a point. Why are you such an angry person?

I'm not angry, just curious. Why are you such a meanie?

it's a doggy dog world out there

holy shit you must think Oasis is good then

Why are they bad?

figure it out for yourself you dumb fuck

It's "Dog eat dog." You fucking philistine

also, as if my opinion is going to change yours, only to then pull the subjectivity card

stop with the b8

just playing doubles advocate

dubtrack.fm/join/progkrautpsych-rock

come play some tunes

>Gilmour > Fripp
yikes dude

ITCOCK > Piper > Red = Meddle > WYWH = Islands = Larks' Tongues = Animals = Ummagumma >> DSOTM = Wall

so on so on

>all of those
Holy fucking shit dude

your list, while obviously not perfectly correct, is largely very good. the only travesty is having three of a perfect pair above lizard. your reasonable and objective ranking of the final cut is commendable.

dubtrack.fm/join/progkrautpsych-rock
dubtrack.fm/join/progkrautpsych-rock
dubtrack.fm/join/progkrautpsych-rock

that's because Dark Side fucking blows.

That's the joke you fucking autist.

ItCotCK > WYWH = Red > Piper = Larks Tounge > Animals > DSotM = Piper = Lizard = ItWoP > Saucerful >>>> The Wall

Captcha: ROAD alarms

There is nothing wrong with preferring Gilmour. Of course Fripp has a higher capacity in every stat but he is a lot less consistently consonant than Gilmour. Do you expect people to prefer exercise and eating healthily to doing drugs?

yeah, what the fuck

quit being a pussy and pirate it

wrong

>trying to avoid newfags
>puts wywh

>friend of bowie
>not doing drugs

"Devil's Aggravate"
fucking idiot

Why should I care about either when there's Jethro Tull?

King Crimson>Jethro Tull>Pink Floyd

>clearly fallen angel is one of the best progpop tracks ever
everyone raves about the title track and Starless but Fallen Angel is by far my favorite track from Red

any color you like > moonschild

early Floyd and early crimson I roughly hold in the same regard, with maybe a little leniency to crimson
late Floyd (post-DSOTM/the wall) < crimson (new wave, post-larks' tongues in aspic) objectively

I like crimson more though in general

Fripp is infinitely better than Gilmour

It's nice seeing The Final Cut get some recognition. It's a lyrical masterpiece dragged down by a lack of contributions from the rest of the band.

Crimson by a mile. I'm sure most people picking Pink Floyd here are just babbies who have only listened to Floyd and barely heard of Crimson.

>Fripp
>Selling albums
>Achieving commercial success
He literally said that King Crimson's music is not to be enjoyed. It's like you know nothing about him.