So which one was more retarded?

So which one was more retarded?

you

Bastarbowl was way worse.

>get drawn out into a trap
>get your army into a trap too as a result
>have your archers melee
>a magical wall of bodies somehow appears behind your lines in a convenient spot for the enemy
>stand there as enemy's infantry walks towards you and slowly forms a phalanx around your army
>oh and they even managed to get some of their infantry to go all the way around and behind the wall of bodies too without you noticing
>only survive because CIA saved you

Jon and Davos are now literally two of the most retreaded military tacticians/officers in Westeros.

Should have let Sansa lead the army, now way she could have fucked up more than they did. Or better yet, bear loli.

two seasons for the same battle ...

First check em.

Second, how come Stannis didn't come out with the trenches?

It's a CIA saves de day again episode

i think their excuse was that show Stannis was "a broken man", and that's why he went full retard

Okay, I'll bite. What would you have done?

Literally anything else would have saved more Stark/Wilding lives.

20 threads about the same damn thing is pretty retarded.

Please keep your shit contained.

>They couldn't find their way out of the horseshoe strategy

Are you going to answer the question or not?

>stannis loses ALL of his horses

Don't charge at the start. Or just, walk a bit to the left of the wall of dead bodies so you don't get surrounded. Don't tell your archers to charge into melee, have them shoot enemy archers/approaching infantry.

Fucking anything.

was getting Horseshoe'd part of your plan?

>Some random dude you just met: Duuuude you should totally chain your ships together.
>Cao Cao: Splendid Idea!

Stannis didn't have any horses.

How was he supposed to know he is fighting against a weather manipulating wizard?

>they took all the horses, my lord
>my lord, the red woman left the camp
>she was seen leaving on a horse.

20 good threads

You are for making this thread. Now FUCK OFF.