ITT:

rate your favourite artist or band's releases out of ten and others tell you why you're wrong

>s/t - 7/10
>devotion - 8/10
>teen dream - 9.5/10
>bloom - 9.5/10
>depression cherry - 9/10
>thank your lucky stars - 7.5/10

AnCo:

STGSTV: 8.5/10
Danse Manatee: 5/10
Campfire Songs: 7.5/10
HTCI: 9/10
Sung Tongs: 10/10
Feels: 8/10
Strawberry Jam: 8.5/10
MPP: 7.5/10
CHZ: 5/10
Painting With: 4/10

EPs
Prospect Hummer: 5.5/10
People: 4/10
Water Curses: 8/5/10
Fall Be Kind: 8/10
The Painters: 5/10

ODDSAC: 8.5/10

Dinosaur Jr

Dinosaur 5/10
You're living all over me 10/10
Bug 9/10
Green thumb 8/10
Whee you been 9/10
Without a sound 6.5/10
Hand it over 6/10
Beyond 7/10
Farm 8.5/10
I bet on sky 8.5/10
Give a glimpse of what yer not 8/10

Debut - 9/10
Post - 8/10
Homogenic - 10/10
Vespertine - 10/10
Medulla - 6/10
Volta - 8/10
Biophilia - 9/10
Vulnicura - 8/10

>S/T not a 9
>Devotion not a 10
>Teen Dream not a 8
>Bloom not a 8.5
>Depression Cherry not a 10
>TYLS not a 9

Three imaginary boys 7/10
Seventeen Seconds 9.5/10
Faith 10/10
Pornography 10/10
The Top 7/10
Head on the Door 8.5/10
Kiss me Kiss me Kiss me 9/10
Disintegration 10/10
Wish 8/10
Wild Mood Swings 5/10
BloodFlowers 8/10
The Cure 4/10
4:13 Dream 5/10

>s/t above bloom and teen dream

>Beach House
>good

lol u got us good

not bad, user. im within +/- 1 of all your ratings.

Pablo Honey 6.5/10
The Bends 7.5/10
OK Computer 10/10
Kid A 9.5/10
Amnesiac 9/10
HTTT 7/10
In Rainbows 10/10
TKOL 8.5/10
AMSP 9/10

King Crimson:

ITCOTCK - 10/10
ITWOP - 9/10
Lizard - 7.5/10
Islands - 7/10
LTIA - 10/10
SABB - 9/10
Red - 10/10
Discipline - 8.5/10
Beat - 8/10
TOAPP - 8.75/10
THRAK - 5/10
TCOL - 9/10
TPTB - 7.75/10

LCD Soundsystem
S/T - 9/10
Sound of Silver - 10/10
This is Happening - 8/10
The Long Goodbye - 7.510
45:33 - 6/10
I didn't include Introns or any of the other remixes

Switch HTTT and Amnesiac and I'd agree.

Floyd:

PatGoD: 10/10
Saucerful of secrets: 7/10
moar soundtrack: meh 6.5-7/10
ummagumma: live-9/10, the rest 4/10
atom heart: 6/10
meddle: 9/10
obscured by clouds:6/10
dark side: 8/10
wywh: 10/10
animals: 8/10
the wall: o_0 6/10
the final cut: 6/10
momentary lapse and endless river: 6/10
division bell: 7/10

roast me blokes

Down Colorful Hill - 9.5/10
Rollercoaster - 9/10
Bridge - 7/10
Ocean Beach - 8/10
Songs For a Blue Guitar - 10/10
Old Ramon - 9/10
Shock Me EP - 9/10
Ghosts of the Great Highway - 9.5/10
Tiny Cities - 7/10
April - 9/10
Admiral Fell Promises - 8/10
Among The Leaves - 7/10
Benji - 8/10
Universal Themes - 6/10
Common as Light and Love Are Red Valleys of Blood - edge/10
Jesu/Sun Kil Moon - 6/10

I enjoy his new shit in concept and lyrics since I love extreme naturalism and shit like Knausgaard but not so much the actual music. Especially MK being such an overwhelmingly talented singer and guitarist and deciding he just doesn't want to do either of those things anymore.

I Could Live In Hope 9.5/10
Long Division 8.5/10
The Curtain Hits the Cast 9/10
Songs for a Dead Pilot 7.5/10
Secret Name 7/10
Things We Lost in the Fire 9.5/10
Trust 9/10
The Great Destroyer 5/10
Drums and Guns 8.5/10
C'mon 8/10
The Invisible Way 6/10
Ones & Sixes 7/10

>Surfin' Safari - 5/10
>Surfin' USA - 6.5/10
>Surfer Girl - 7/10
>Little Deuce Coupe - 6/10
>Shut Down Volume 2 - 6.5/10
>All Summer Long - 8.5/10
>The Beach Boys' Christmas Album - 7/10
>Today! - 8.5/10
>Summer Days (And Summer Nights!!) - 7.5/10
>Beach Boys' Party! - 6.5/10
>Pet Sounds - 10/10
>Smiley Smile - 7.5/10
>Wild Honey - 8/10
>Friends - 8.5/10
>20/20 - 7/10
>Sunflower - 7.5/10
>Surf's Up - 8/10
>Carl and the Passions - So Tough - 6/10
>Holland - 7/10
>15 Big Ones - 6/10
>Love You - 8.5/10
>M.I.U. Album - 4/10
>L.A. (Light Album) - 6.5/10
>Keepin' the Summer Alive - 2/10
>The Beach Boys - 5/10
>Still Cruisin' - 3.5/10
>Summer in Paradise - 2/10
>Stars and Stripes Vol. 1 - 3/10
>The SMiLE Sessions - 10/10
>That's Why God Made the Radio - 5.5/10

>painting with has a worse score than DM

step aside, pleb

anco:

SGTSTV - 9.5/10
Danse - 5.5/10
Hollinndagainn - 8.5/10
Campfire Songs - 10/10
HCTI - 9/10
Sung Tongs - 10/10
Feels - 9/10
SJ - 8.5/10
MPP - 9/10
CHZ - 7/10
Painting With - 8/10

Prospect Hummer - 10/10
People - 10/10
Water Curses - 8.5/10
Fall Be Kind - 10/10
The Painters 9.5/10

Pretty Hate Machine - 7/10
Broken 7.5/10
The Downward Spiral 10/10
The Fragile - 9.5/10
With Teeth - 7/10
Year Zero - 8/10
Ghosts - 6.5/10
The Slip - 6/10
Hesitation Marks - 7.5/10
Not The Actual Events - 8.5/10

>sunflower 7.5

you motherfucker

>painting with one point behind HCTI
>prospect hummer better than feels
>people better than MPP
>The Painters better than Strawberry Jam

Please listen again to Essplode (similar to STGSTV era), Throwin' The Ball Round (SJish), Bad Crumbs (Hollindagin), and Ahh Good Country (good as anything on Campfire Songs)

You are whack, my man.

Knife Play - 8/10
A Promise - 9/10
Fabulous Muscles - 10/10
La Foret - 7.5/10
Air Force - 8/10
Women As Lovers - 7/10
Dear God I Hate Myself - 5/10
Always - 4.5/10
Nina - 4.5/10
Angel Guts: Red Classroom - 7.5/10
Plays the Music of Twin Peaks - 8/10

>feel good lost 2001
6/10
>you forgot it in people 2002
10/10
>bee hives 2004
8/10
>S/T 2005
9/10
>EP to be you and me 2005
7.5/10
>forgiveness rock record 2010
8/10
>EP lo-fi for the dividing lights 2010
6/10
>new unnamed lp 2017
please god let it be at least 9/10

i rate danse so low because they sound so awful compared to their live versions

and lablakely dress sounds a whole lot better on hollindagainn

jimmy mack and kinda bonkers are superior to unsolved mysteries and winter wonderland but everything else is on par, also it's new so i hype it

people is indeed better than MPP

i just can't get into the studio versions of daffy duck, loch raven, and flesh canoe quite as hard

i usually give danse 5.5-7

GWS- 8/10
The Pod- 9/10
Pure Guava- 10/10
C&C- 9/10
The Mollusk- 10/10
White Pepper- 7/10
Quebec- 8/10

you missed 10 on dark side and 7.5 on atom and you are fine

This is Your Bloody Valentine/Geek - who cares/10
The New Record - 6/10
Sunny Sundae Smile - 8/10
Ecstasy/Strawberry Wine - 7/10
YMMR - 10/10
That one EP with an Isn't Anything single - don't remember lol/10
Isn't Anything - 8/10
Glider - 8/10
Tremolo - 7/10
Loveless - 10/10
MBV - 8/10

I never really liked Teen Dream.

Move OKC and AMSP down a smidge and yeah

>new unnamed lp 2017
>please god let it be at least 9/10
Yaaaas, although I'm pretty sure Kevin Drew is a nutjob now my hopes are still high.

PatGoD: 10/10
Saucerful of secrets: 8/10
more soundtrack: meh 6.5/10
ummagumma: live-9.8/10, the rest 5/10
atom heart: 7.8/10
meddle: 7/10
obscured by clouds:6.8/10
dark side: 10/10
wywh: 10/10
animals: 10/10
the wall: 10/10
the final cut: 6/10
momentary lapse :6.5/10
endless river: 6/10
division bell: 8/10

How can they be your favourite band with such low ratings?

LCD Soundsystem (studio albums)
S/T - 8/10
Sound of Silver - 10/10
This Is Happening - 10/10

Okay it's actually more like an 8. I'd put it on the same level as wild honey and surf's up

STGSTV, DM, Campfire songs and prospect Hummer should be higher