Album vs thread

You know the drill.

Perfect From Now On.
LCW has better lyrics though.

LCW
KLAS is best BtS album

Glow Pt 2 vs Mount Eerie

Cop

perferct from now on. No one beats those beautiful guitars

Perfect From Now On

...

Cop
Why have BtS never gained the popularity/success that Modest Mouse have? On par if not better.

Because Float On

bts all the way

Carry the Zero >>>>>> Float On

...

I prefer Freddie

Remain In Light

Always Discipline

Eh, I like Built To Spill better, but I can't really imagine Carry The Zero ever becoming really big. Float On is the tier of pop song you'll hear 3 decades after its release.

popularity doesn't correlate with quality. I prefer BtS anyway, so bias i guess

TBK

Mount Eerie

Prolly Discipline

Doug Martsch is a much better guitarist than anybody in modest mouse, but Isaac Brock is the better lyricist.

Yeh I would agree with that

Perfect from Now On

Glow Pt. 2

Remain in Light

Hail to the Thief

Siamese Dream vs. Mellon Collie

Gibbs

LCW

Perfect From Now On, b/c LCW is great but imo has some dud tracks

TBK

Madvillainy is goat forever

RiL

HttT

Glow pt.2

...

MM's original trio with Doug on lead sharing vocals would be a wet dream

Yeah this is pretty much it. LCW is a great album, but Brock's lyrics pull a lot of weight

Agreed.
Although Isaac and Doug both have fairly different guitar styles. Isaac sounds more post-punk whereas Doug is almost like baroque classical.

Perfect From Now On
Mount Eerie
Equal. Solid 8/10
Hail to the Theif


> In Rainbows vs. OK Computer

in rainbows.

Sound of Silver or This Is Happening

LCW
Cop
Madvillainy
Remain In Light
TKoL

TKoL

In Rainbows

This is Happening

...

Not even close. TLCW is a verifiable classic and BTS never made anything close to that (Modest Mouse either, for that matter)

TBK because of consistency

MV

Remain in Light

TKOL easily

get off this board

...

TKOL

dopethrone

Left

Exuma

>History Will Absolve Me vs Atrocity Exhibition

Lonesome Crowded West
To Be Kind
Madvillainy
Remain In Light
The King Of Limbs

remain in light

hail to the thief

tough one, i'd have to go with Darkthrone

desu dopesmoker is closer to dopethrone than holy mountain
but I like holy mountain

BTS
Cop
Glow
Same, both 6/10
Talking Heads by a little bit
Both are really good, gotta say Mayhem though
Inflammable Material
Ok Computer
This Is Happening
Comus
Sleep, Dopethrone is really good too though
Swans

lonesome crowded west. long drive is better though

madvillainy

remain in light

httt (not even a bad album, just not the level of bends - amnesiac era)

Modest mouse
Glowing man
Madvillainy
Discipline
TKOL
Sound of Silver
Fishmans

PFNO
To Be Kind
Glow
Madvillainy
Remain In Light
HTTT
Mayhem
OKC
Comus
Dopethrone
not very comparable other than them both being live, but I'd say Fish

TKoL
SoS
Fishmans

This is Happening
Fishmemes

Lonesome Crowded West vs Perfect From Now On has to be the greatest album rivalry.
Literally 90% of "versus" threads have them within the first 3 posts.

Buffalo Springfield Again vs Moby Grape '67

Keep It Like a Secret stands up to Long Drive too imo

I love Modest Mouse's earlier stuff but overall BtS more I think

Lonesome Crowded West
Madvillainy
Remain in Light
De Mysteriis Dom Sathanas (ABitNS isn't even Darkthrone's best album)
OK Computer
Sound of Silver
First Utterance
Holy Mountain
Fresh Fruit

>Alien Lanes vs Bee Thousand

Lonesome
Cop
Madvillainy
Remain in Light
HTTT
Sound of Silver
Holy Mountain
Dead Kennedys
Deathconsciousness
Goddammit don't make me choose

Hoping for a true underdog story with this one.

Your original comment had nothing to do with anything dummy.

...

TKOL

Vulnicura vs Biophilia

TBK

...

...

>Get off this board

literally why? I posted the black metal btw

not nearly as fun comparing two albums from the same discography

bts
madvillian
remain in light
httt
this is happening
exuma
dopethrone
london calling
giles
f#a#
ys
vespertine
okc

...