was punk originated in the united states?
Was punk originated in the united states?
Nicholas Watson
Other urls found in this thread:
mtv.com
youtube.com
youtu.be
youtu.be
youtu.be
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
youtube.com
twitter.com
Jordan Hall
Yes although it wasn't until 1972 when they recorded their demo of I Got A Right
And technically that was the 2nd punk song and the first was actually Beatles 2.0 in 1970 with Lennon, Ring and Yoko
Tyler Adams
Go back even earlier. Punk began in the 60's.
Logan Jenkins
Garage =/= punk
Power chords =/= punk
I Got A Right is literally the blueprint
Landon Scott
Actually it originated in Prussia.
Chase Russell
>Garage
A name slapped on decades later.
Like it or not, it's where it all began.
Colton Jones
Why because they use power chords? Gonna take more than that. Gonna take drums.
Brandon Martinez
What is your point instead of taking me to some rambling article on a horrible site
Aiden Myers
Read the article and educate yourself.
You might learn something.
Owen James
lmao you're retarded
Jonathan Martinez
Germany actually, listen to Black Monk Time
Luis Thomas
Maybe later but I doubt I'll change my mind that it took drums to invent punk. Otherwise it took psycho Beatles 2.0 guitars to do it No Wave style ten years before the fact.
Lucas Thompson
well they were still american
Gavin Rivera
The sonics came before them and were from seattle. But imho the first punk album (not proto punk) was the dictator's go girl crazy, and it was USA too
Samuel Brown
Maybe but The Ramones were already playing full albums worth live the year before. There's video from CBGb in 1974
Aiden Jackson
yes, and anybody who says otherwise is a mouth breathing, usda inspected, grade A fucking retard of the highest rarity
David Morales
Australia, actually
youtube.com
Adam Hughes
stooges - i got a right (heavy liquid - track #1)
youtu.be
Recorded July 1972
Zachary Howard
GONN 1966 Keokuk Iowa
youtu.be
youtu.be
Imagine being a corn farmer and hearing this at the county fair.
Jordan Ramirez
Started in Peru
Justin Flores
>I'm Stranded, Released Sept. 1976
>Blitzkreig Bop, Released February 1976
Adrian Hernandez
Punk was just lofi rock n roll so yes
Cooper Hughes
>I just read wiki
Josiah Perry
>I'm Stranded, first known performance early 1974
>Ramones, first live performance September 1974
Saying when they were released as singles is like saying Smile ripped off Neo-Psych because it came out in 2011
David Bailey
Didn't know, thanks for the fact
Alexander Watson
My pleasure, and by full album I just mean enough to qualify for an album like over 20 minutes of material
Isaiah Scott
I knew that ramones had a lot of songs before their s/t but didn't know they had so much already lol. Do you know other very early punk/protopunk bands? I'm really into shit like this lately but you know I feel there are the big legendary names like new york dolls, monks, stooges, etc or bands like rocket from the tombs and radio birdman that are really not known
Benjamin Edwards
See
That's all I know other than Lennon, Ringo and Yoko in 1970 but that's No Wave style of punk
And Death apparently copied that Stooges song's style but I'm not sure of the first date they recorded or performed one of these specifics songs although I assume it wasnt before 1974 but maybe.
Brody Thompson
Cool, thanks
Juan Ramirez
youtube.com
This song from 1969 is pretty punk. Even the lyrics.
Kevin Sanders
pretty cool
Chase Carter
I Got A Right is pretty much exactly what punk eventually became, but i'd say that Raw Power (the whole album) made that message much more clear and was probably more widely available for young people who became punks.
Nathan Rodriguez
Right but apparently they are playing it that way live or ot got out somehow and that's how Death got their sound. It's too much of a coincidence that they're from the same city. In addition to whoever else may have heard it. Unless I'm confused about when Death write similar songs. I'm not very familiar with them at all except when I heard all their stuff many many years ago when I decided they simple copycats and moved on. Not that there's anything wrong with that but they're compositions aren't historically important.
Jason Turner
Fucking autocorrect I swear
were playing
Julian Jenkins
what's this about Lennon, Ringo and Yoko doing no-wave in 1970? I've never heard about anything like that
Connor Lewis
Just turn it off dude, it's so fucking pointless honestly. Half the time it corrects into words i don't even want. I turned that shit off years ago
Bentley Walker
How does anyone buy this popularly spouted opinion
its not very fast or energetic at all
its more of a soul or RnB groove of a song than punk
youtube.com
this is more punk and was way earlier, probably the first song with power chord riffing
Brayden Walker
Well No-Wave in its most extreme like I think they were called Stretchheads and they paved the way for Melt Banana to move way past that. Plastic Ono Band (Beatles 2.0) did that in 1970 with the song Why
Andrew Taylor
Yeah I should at least try it
David Clark
youtube.com
youtube.com
these are way more punk than louie louie
youtube.com
another candidate
Jeremiah Brown
youtube.com
Oh boy, this is some shit right here. Yoko fucking losing it in the background of course. The song is cool but her dumb voice kinda ruins it for me. Could totally be a Devo or B-52 song without the insanity that is Yoko singing.
Jaxson Gomez
Here are the facts: Rock and roll originated in the U.S. and since punk is an off shoot of rock and roll then the logical answer is that yes punk originated in the U.S. End of discussion. End of thread!
Kayden Evans
rock and roll came from africa
Jackson Mitchell
Post links to prove your point and further your argument.
Gabriel Turner
Came here to post this
Eli Clark
Rock n Roll came from blacks
Blacks came from Africa
Therefore Rock n Roll came from Africa