This movie had a decent plot/story. If there was better writing, acting, directing and a better love story, this would be a great movie.
>please be gentle
This movie had a decent plot/story. If there was better writing, acting, directing and a better love story...
Isaac Hall
William Flores
>This movie had a decent plot/story. If there was better writing...
just contradicted yourself
Nathan Thomas
faggot. prequels are gay
Gabriel Sanchez
>thinking movies need love stories
Kill yourself, facebook.
There's an entire board for people like you who don't know fucking anything about film. Plus you can talk to all you reddit friends there.
Lincoln Williams
Hayden Christensen was the perfect choice for Anakin Skywalker.
Daniel Baker
it's also pretty imaginative. Some nice visuals here and there
Levi Stewart
A movie's story and dialogue are independent. A movie can have the same overall story and different dialogue.
Nathan Long
Prequels suck because Mr. Plinkett said so.
Jordan Gomez
Appearance-wise yes. He looks exactly like what Anakin should look like.
Acting-wise hell no.
Nicholas Wright
The narrative was aimed at kids. The jokes were aimed at kids. Harden Christensen was a fine character, however the script was aimed at kids.
Parker Evans
>If the things that made it bad were better it would be good.
You don't fucking say
Ethan Rodriguez
You're the first person to mention dialogue. Learn to argue, dunce.
Parker Cooper
>Assuming I think all movies need love stories
This one was based on the love story, so yes it needed a good one.
Lincoln King
Writing = dialogue, not story. They are connected but not the same.
Robert Williams
The writing is the dialogue.
Hudson Walker
>>Assuming I think all movies need love stories
>it needed a good one
Holy shit you're stupid.
Xavier Campbell
Haydn Christisumimasen was awful. But at least he wasn't CGI
Samuel Ortiz
Writing isn't specifically dialogue. Try not to talk about things you aren't actually educated about. Or, just do a better job specifying what part of the writing to which you're referring.
Lincoln Ortiz
LEAVE HAYDEN CHRISTENSEN ALONE!!! HE'S NOT A BAD ACTOR, IT'S GEORGE LUCAS FAULT!!!
Leo Smith
How about you explain what the writing is then if it's not dialogue since you're the expert?
Alexander Rivera
Writing is both the story and the dialogue. If the story is good but the dialogue is shit, you can say the writing needed to be better because overall the writing was bad because of the 50% of it (the dialogue) that was shit.
Austin Garcia
I didn't say it wasn't dialogue. I said it's not JUST dialogue, as you implied. Learn to read, moron.
Brody Clark
But he was the CHOSEN ONE!
Bentley Davis
More importantly
>the writing isn't the plot
Jonathan Harris
I don't see no explaining...
Chase Walker
But if you say the story is bad but the dialogue is excellent, would you say the writing is needs to be better? I think not.
Adam Taylor
I mean it's certainly better than the dogshit that was Rogue One, but I wouldn't say it had a "great" story. It was basically just a string of scenes that looked and felt like future toy product placement.
>inb4 better direction
I mean yea but even with bad direction if the story was truly great the string of events still shouldn't feel pointless.
Aiden Hall
There's no such thing as a bad story. Only bad execution. If a movie has great dialogue but the "story is bad", it just means the director failed to capture it and probably fucked up the tone too.
Mason Hill
all this bickering over dialogue/story...
meanwhile, no one defends either.
Yeah, the movie is shit.
Jason James
Like most I feel the constant action scenes were trite. The love story could have been played out more, like some have said. The relationship between anakin and obi wan was nonexistent and gay. Also padme is barely a character.
Josiah Martin
Hey, retard, he argument is BECAUSE people are defending the story and not the dialogue, and other retards think the two things are one in the same. The movie IS shit but not because of the story.
Daniel Morales
Yea, the general story is actually good it's just the execution, for all the reasons you say here, is terrible.
Bentley Baker
where in this thread has someone said something positive about the story? aside from op generically saying it was "decent"
Bentley Smith
No, you're thinking episode 1.