How can people say this isn't his best album?

How can people say this isn't his best album?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=93HC4kv2JzU
youtube.com/watch?v=TigJYxitYLg
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

it is but i guess its inaccessible for his fanbase. since he doesn't sound "depress"

because salad says is better

I kinda feel for him, he's become nothing but a living meme

how so?
brother and let her go are the same song

Salad Days is basically the same album but with less consistent songwriting

Because contrarians

Salad Days is more popular though

i like rock and roll night club better, it's more fun

Salad Days is more popular because Pitchfork shilled his work hard during that year, but 2 is the best. 2 is way nicer pop and not as calm as the more recent albums. Not saying the newer albums suck, it's just that they are different.

2 = Salad Days > Another One > My Old Dog > Rock and Roll Night Club

Chamber of reflection is his best song but 2 is still better

no idea
he's been progressively transitioning from rock to folk over the course of his career and it's doing him no favors. rock and roll night club was good, 2 was great, salad days was not good, haven't heard the new one yet (it leaked right?) but he described it as stripped down songs with just him and a guitar, which sounds awful.

how can you rate an album that hasnt even come out yet

because we listened to the leak

Facts

leaked couple days ago newfag

hes incredibly shit. he sells the image of not caring about selling an image and his idiotic fanbase buys it. theyre the same people who think they can appear counterculture and anticapitalist by buying clothes from magacorporate clothing retailers like urban outfitters. its over the counter culture. and imo he epitomizes that phenomenon

let's hear it for user, our resident freshman year psychology major

Incredibly plebeian "critique". You completely failed to touch on any aspect of his music.
If I were this superficial I'd hope somebody would just kill me.

his music is just average. saw him live and reminded me of high school bands doing talent shows.

he has talent for sure. but recording everything by himself really shows how limited he is.

6/10 the artist relying on his personality thx to marketing

youtube.com/watch?v=93HC4kv2JzU
youtube.com/watch?v=TigJYxitYLg
How is this not excellent songwriting?

because salad days does what 2 does but also adds some cool synth stuff

2 had synths on My Kind of Woman and Sherril

its not
its just above average

Simply saying "it's not" isn't an argument. Try again.