One of these threads

>Best
Two-Headed Boy Pt.1 and 2

>Worst
Communist Daughter

>Overrated
Holland 1945

>Underrated
Title Track

>Best
So Real

>Worst
Corpus Christ Carol or Eternal Life

>Overrated
Hallelujah

>Underrated
Lilac Wine

>Best
Epitaph

>Worst
Moonchild

>Overrated
21st Century Schizoid Man

>Underrated
Title Track

>Best
Vertigo
>Worst
Please Remember
>Overrated
Dream House or The Pecan Tree
>Underrated
Sunbather

>Best
Thick as a Brick

>Worst
Thick as a Brick

>Overrated
Thick as a Brick

>Underrated
Thick as a Brick

>Best
We're A Happy Family
>Worst
Surfin' Bird or I Don't Care
>Overrated
Sheena Is A Punk Rocker
>Underrated
Rockaway Beach

I'm listening to that right now for the first time. I don't know if it's in my top 10 yet. I liked OK Computer a lot better when I was going through the Sup Forumscore list.

>Best
Paranoid Android

>Worst
Let Down

>Overrated
Exit Music

>Underrated
Subterranean Homesick Alien

>listening right now
>don't know if its in my top 10 yet

>Best
Stress
>Worst
TThhEe PPaARRtTYY
>Overrated
D.A.N.C.E.
>Underrated
One Minute to Midnight

I'm 45 minutes through my dude, I can usually tell before the end.

I'm friends with someone who always listens to these Neutral Milk Hotel guys. Around 2014, the band was playing at Coachella so, being the great friend that I am, we both go to the show.

Well we were there among the sweaty thrall of people, waiting for the band to come on. There was some loopy guy with a blue toddlers cap who made it on stage and was spinning around a mic stand for about 15 minutes straight and repeating something to himself. Occasionally he'd grimace and smack his closed fist against his forehead. For 15 minutes he did this, and no security stopped him.
Then the band comes out.
Jeff Mangum, the singer, proceeds to flick off the entire crowd as he walks on stage. "Okay," I think, "so he's like a punk frontman type of guy."
Meanwhile, that tripping guy who was on stage spinning? He picks up a saw and violin thingy. Hes in the band!

They played a few songs, it wasn't bad. The lyrics were completely different than what everyone around me was singing along with. What really was bizarre though, was that the frontman would go up to the mic between every song and say "muh naym is yeff!" And then burst out laughing and hobble away from the mic in hysterics. He kept doing it. It's as if he thought we didn't hear him the first time he did it.
Eventually he started doing it in the song during instrumental sections, and later, he started saying it mid verse! I remember during the climax of one of the songs about a Two Headed Boy, one that was very emotionally impacting on the audience, he sang
"But doooon't hate her, when she gets up to - MUH NAYM IS YEFF! - leave."
I was baffled. This is this guy's job. He's like 45 and this is his job yet he can't be serious for an hour or two. What the fuck.

It was all hideous to behold. Never waste your time with these guys.

>worst
>not windows
Imo please remember feels cathartic af with that saw sound. Great segue into vertigo too which I agree is best.

>Best
Kill The Switch
>Worst
Same Shade As Concrete
>Overrated
Crowquill
>Underrated
In The Nervous Light or Interview At The Ruins

>Worst
>Moonchild
pleb spotted

>Best
Space Dementia

>Worst
Darkshines

>Overrated
Citizen Erased

>Underrated
Micro Cuts

I actually like Moonchild, it's just the worst song on a masterpiece.

>Best
Rock n Roll Suicide
>Worst
It Ain't Easy
>Overrated
Starman
>Underrated
Soul Love

I'd say Plug in Baby for overrated

Listen to more music

One Minute to Midnight that song fucks

Add Oh Comely to best and get Holland 1945 the fuck out of overrated and that's correct.

>The title track
>underrated
That's the most popular song off that album though.

To who? No it isn't.

Not OP btw.

lol so random xD

I saw them right after the 'comeback' when Jeff was doing solo gigs and it was a flawless performance

What is this 2014? Go complain about anti-vaxxers.

...

it literally is

>Best
Dollar Days

>Worst
Girl Loves

>Overrated
Lazarus

>Underrated
Sue

In what way is it random? Pretty straightforward comedy.

*Girl Loves Me

shut up

>Worst: Let Down
Going to have to disagree there

>Best
Got To Be Free

>Worst
Top of the Pops

>Overrated
Apeman

>Underrated
Powerman

This

>worst: communist daughter
Strongly disagree with you there, mate

>best
>not mojo pin

Worst: let down
Strongly disagree, my dude

kek

>Best
30

>Worst
Die Like a Rockstar

>Overrated
I Will

>Underrated
Outer Space

Wow you are trying to being contrarian too hard

>Best
My God Is The Sun

>Worst
Kalopsia

>Overrated
If I Had A Tail

>Underrated
Smooth Sailing

>Overrated
I Will

It may be overrated but goddamn if it isn't my favorite to sing obnoxiously

>Best
Bipp

>Worst
L.O.V.E

>Overrated
Lemonade

Underrated:
Vyzee

>>Worst
>Die Like a Rockstar
haha no

SHAKE SHAKE SHAKE IT UP AND MAKE IT FIZZ

I disagree sir, Darkshines is the best and Screenager is underrated

Funny cause I disagree with everyone of these haha.

pleb spotted

I saw Danny Harle a couple months ago and he dropped Vyzee out of nowhere and I absolutely lost my shit. The shitter hipster chick next to me asked me what song it was and I just yelled SHAKE IT UP AND MAKE IT FIIIIIZ in her face.

i think the whole album is overrated but i agree on Two Headed Boy being the best track, but cmon Holland 1945 is the certerpiece.

if you say Holland, 1945 is overrated then you're saying the whole concept of the album is overrated.
Nice one champ.

Worst - Let down
Who you tryin to kid, kid?
Projecting pretty hard here. You'll cut yourself on that edge.

>Best
For Free?

>Worst
Institutionalized

>Overrated
Alright

>Underrated
You Ain't Gotta Lie (Momma Said)

>Best
Shiny Happy People

>Worst
Low (I guess)

>Overrated
Country Feedback

>Underrated
Texarkana

>Best
Lovely Rita

>Worst
Being for the Benefit of Mr. Kite

>Overrated
When I'm Sixty-Four

>Underrated
Good Morning Good Morning

>Best
Two-Headed Boy Pt.1 and 2, Communist Daughter

>Worst
Untitled

>Overrated
In The Aeroplane Over the Sea

>Underrated
Ghost

Fixed for you pleb

>best
Blue Ridge Mountains

>worst
Quiet Houses

>Overrated
White Winter Hymnal

>Underrated
Heard Them Stirring

>Best
Sleeping In

>Worst
Brand New Colony

>Overrated
Such Great Heights

>Underrated
Natural Anthem

>Best
Porn Mountain
>Worst
Tathatagabartha, or however you spell it
>Overrated
Those Who Can't, Cheat
>Underrated
1-800-WORSHIP

>>Worst
>Communist Daughter
What the fuck did I just read
Hang yourself insensitive piece of shit with no taste

>Best
New Grass

>Worst
Ascension Day

>Overrated
New Grass

>Underrated
After the Flood

Worst is For Sale?
Otherwise correct.

To extend this to the band as a whole
>Best
Discipline
>Worst
The ConstruKction of Light
>Overrated
Three of a Perfect Pair
>Underrated
THRAK, Beat

>Best
All of the Lights + Interlude

>Worst
See Me Now

>Overrated
Power

>Underrated
Hell of a Life

Your an evil person if you don't like "communist daughter"

>Best
When we Two Parted
>Worst
If I were Going
>Overrated
What Jail is Like
>Underrated
the whole album desu. specifically Be Sweet

>Best
Holland, 1945
>Worst
untitled
>Overrated
King of Carrot Flowers pt. 1
>Underrated
Oh Comely
>Best
The Court of the Crimson King
>Worst
Moonchild
>Overrated
21st Schizoid Man
>Underrated
I Talk to the Wind
>Best
Moonage Daydream
>Worst
Lady Stardust
>Overrated
Starman
>Underrated
It Ain't Easy
>Best
If I had a Tail
>Worst
The Vampyre of Time and Memory
>Overrated
I Sat By the Ocean
>Underrated
...Like Clockwork
>Best
Wesley's Theory
>Worst
You Ain't Gotta Lie
>Overrated
King Kunta
>Underrated
How Much a Dollar Cost
>Best
Dark Fantasy
>Worst
Devil in a New Dress
>Overrated
Monster
>Underrated
Blame Game

forgot pic

>Best
I Will Dare
>Worst
Sixteen Blue
>Overrated
Androgynous
>Underrated
Answering Machine

>Best
Bombenhagel
>Worst
Electrocution
>Overrated
Nuclear Winter
>Underrated
Enchanted Land

I think Ghost is the really underrated one. That song is pure build and energy with the tempo increase and I NEVER see it get any love.

Best: Mojo Pin

Worst: Lilac Wine

Overrated: Last Goodbye

Underrated: You Should've Come Over

>Best
Meet Me Halfway

>Worst
Imma Be

>Overrated
Boom Boom Pow

>Underrated
Party All The Time

Worst is Devil in a New Dress

WHEW LAD

>Best
Sheena Is A Punk Rocker
>Worst
Surfin' Bird
>Overrated
Rockaway Beach
>Underrated
Why Is It Always This Way? or Do You Wanna Dance?

>Actually believing that thick as a brick is better than thick as a brick

holy shit this board is fucking retarded

>Best
My God Is The Sun
>Worst
Keep Your Eyes Peeled
>Overrated
I Appear Missing
>Underrated
Fairweather Friends

>Best
The Blacker The Berry
>Worst
Mortal Man
>Overrated
i
>Underrated
For Free?

>Best
Radio Song
>Worst
Country Feedback
>Overrated
Shiny Happy People
>Underrated
Texarkana

>pic related
>Best
Hard Times
>Worst
26
>Overrated
Told You So (i guess)
>Underrated
Fake Happy

>Best
Lowdown

>Worst
12XU

>Overrated
Ex Lion Tamer

>Underrated
Different to Me

Power's still the best song even if it is overrated. Hell of a Life does need more love though

>Good Morning Good Morning
correctly rated it's fucking awful

>Shiny Happy People
>Best
kek

completely accurate thanks user

>Best
Let Down you contrarian

>Worst
Electioneering

>Overrated
Paranoid Android (still a great song), but Exit Music is close

>Underrated
accurate

>Best post
>Worst post
>Overrated post
>Underrated post

>Best
Rejoice

>Worst
A Song Dedicated to the Memory of Stormy the Rabbit

>Overrated
People II: The Reckoning

>Underrated
Survival Song

>Best
Nowhere Fast

>Worst
Meat is Murder

>Overrated
The Joke Isn't Funny Anymore

>Underrated
Well I Wonder

>Best:So Real
My nigga

>Best
Title Track
>Worst
Ghost
>Overrated
Ghost
>Underrated
Communist Daughter

>Best
Epitaph
>Worst
21st Century Schizoid Man
>Overrated
21st Century Schizoid Man
>Underrated
Moonchild

>Best
Samurai Sword
>Worst
My Warm Blood
>Overrated
Title Track
>Underrated
Everything besides the first three songs

>Underrated post

see me now isn't part of the album its a bonus track

this

bump

>Best
3rd Planet
>Worst
What People Are Made Of
>Overrated
Gravity Rides Everything
>Underrated
The Stars Are Projectors

>Labeling Ghost as the worst and most overrated track on ItAOtS

>Best
New Grass
>Worst
Ascension Day
>Overrated
After the Flood
>Underrated
Runeii

Hard to rate as album is legit 10/10

>Best
A Pair of Brown Eyes
>Worst
Wild Cats of Kilkenny
>Overrated
Dirty Old Town
>Underrated
And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda

patrician af

Worst is Alone Down There

>Best
Night Falls on Hoboken
>Worst
Saturday
>Overrated
You Can Have It All
>Underrated
Let's Save Tony Orlando's House

>Best
Homesick
>Worst
Closedown
>Overrated
Lullaby
>Underrated
Prayers for Rain

>Best
Oh, Comely
>Worst
Untitled
>Overrated
King of Carrot Flowers Pt. 1
>Underrated
Ghost

>Best
Runaway
>Worst
Gorgeous
>Overrated
All of the Lights
>Underrated
Dark Fantasy

>Best
A Song Dedicated to the Memory of Stormy the Rabbit
>Worst
Bad Bad Things
>Overrated
Rejoice
>Underrated
Randy's House

The Ramones are shit
Kill yourself

I was stuck between that and mine desu

wait what why the fuck did "desu" autocorrect to "desu"

best post

W H A T T H E F U C K I'm new to Sup Forums but why does T B H go to desu what is this gay shit

/brit/