ITT: Times P4k was absolutely right

ITT: Times P4k was absolutely right.

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=rlBskd3IaNw
twitter.com/SFWRedditGifs

Doesn't p4k always hate alt-J though?

who gives a shit

t. pitchfork shill

Alt-J is just shit.

I'd give it a 6/10, for 3WW, Deadcrush, and Adeline, alone. Some really great singles, but this album is a meme waiting to happen. Can't really argue with p4k here.

everyone does

This is just stupid, P4k always loves avantgarde bullshit and now they say "baah its too boring", or "haha, he sings from his nose", or they take the only song that speaks about sex liberation as a metaphor for playing whatever style of music alt j wants to play, and they say: "wow its just a song about sex" (and they ignore every other song that actually has a lot more meaning in the lyrics)... I dont even like this album (5/10 imo) but cmon, whoever wrote this article doesnt even know how to actually critique.

Damn I remember being tempted to give this a 4/5 and that's why I haven't rated it yet to let the dust settle. Guess I'll put it through the ringer again but I can't imagine giving this anything less than a strong 3/5

the singles were nearly perfect, 3ww was a perfect start and pleader a perfect end. Last year is slow but beautiful. Deadcrush is fun classic alt j (just like in cold blood). And House of the rising sun (w/ that awful new verse that adds nothing to the song) and hit me like that snare... crap