Who else is /onthefence/ here? Really not sure what to make it of it after the second trailer.
Pros: >battle scenes look more gritty, in the trenches with the AT-AT's >reinforcing that the Force isn't just for Jedi/midichlorian nonsense, it's a mystical energy field that binds the universe >makes the Empire seem insurmountable and gigantic in scale(shadow shots of the Star Destroyers/Death Star) >Ben Mendelsohn is great and his character looks amazing >costume design is spot on, all new Storm Troopers look fantastic
Cons: >protagonist seems like a generic teenage-ish sassy rebel character with super snappy dialogue >dialogue in general sounds really poor("Good." "Good.") >Spanish Poe Dameron character looks boring and the actor playing him seems pretty terrible >potentially using Vader as a prop and not as an actual character/force of nature >directors/producers having no clue what to do with the first non-mainline Star Wars ever >no fucking Bothans
I'm guessing low 70's for Rotten Tomatoes based on everything we've seen so far.
Gareth Edwards is not good. Monsters was not good. Godzilla was not good. Why would this be good?
Dylan Foster
Eh, Monsters was decent. Keep in mind that before they directed Captain America: Winter Soldier the biggest movie the Russos had done was a poop comedy movie starring Owen Wilson.
Leo James
Who else is /angryit'llbeshit/ here?
>Cast first asian in starwars >HAVE to fucking use Donnie Yen as some retarded martial artists against SPACE NAZIS.
>Make a bad ass slasher-tier darth vader >Get it all cut and reshot because its too "scary" and "warlike" instead of being "LOL ADVENTUROUS XD"
And the fucking quips...
I actually really dig the cinematography, and the cast should be good, but for fucks sake it will be such a huge lost opportunity because of fucking disney.
Ethan Perry
Wasn't too interested until I learned Diego Luna was going to be in it, but still looks just okay. The trailer was darker than I expected, which is a welcome change to the Star Wars >quips and fun. Still afraid the dialogue will be shit, which it kinda seems like from the trailer. Reaaally happy to see assassin droids
Logan Wood
looks like diversity one the show. inb4 a white male is the villain
Xavier Bell
>Spanish Poe Dameron Poe is Spanish.
James Reyes
I stopped caring when Disney announced they'd release a new Star Wars every single year. It's a shame they've reduced the best sci-fi franchise in history into summer popcorn capeshit.
Daniel Howard
>best sci-fi franchise in history
Not since '99, my friend. Jorge and his pottery went too far.
Luke Myers
SW is that hipster that brags about how if was capeshit before capeshit was cool.
Jaxson Scott
you still shilling here, fatty?
Juan Turner
*how it
Jayden Hall
Im a lot more hyped for it than I was for ep 7.
Andrew Nguyen
after hearing Dinsey calling for massive reshoots I lost all hope for it.
Brody Bailey
A white guy is always the bad guy in star wars
Wyatt Sullivan
Every movie this size goes through reshoots. It's not 40% or what ever number you might of read or heard.
Grayson Harris
Who is Ira Belle? Can someone pls explain?
Caleb Diaz
Star War and trek are the plebs of sci-fi. hell star wars is not even sci-fi, its fantasy
Jacob Sullivan
TFA was kino (prequelbabbies, Sup Forums and contrarians fuck off) so I'm sure Rogue One will be another great flick
Wyatt Bailey
EUfags leave.
Ayden Thompson
+1
Justin Torres
The main actress can't act and has soulless, dead eyes. If your protagonist is shit, your movie is going to be shit.
Also, why the fuck are BOTH new Star Wars movies featuring a lead female protagonist? Girls don't like Star Wars.
Adrian Sanchez
I expected it to be a bit more gritty rather than warfare on a sunny beach with palm trees in the background.
Nathaniel Hughes
Yeah me too. "Stealing the plans to the Death Star" should entail much more sleuthing and Indiana Jones-esque adventures, not giant battles and shit.
Gabriel Davis
It looks far better than ep 7. Will def go see
Henry Lewis
it's going to be Star Wars presents: The Hunger Games: Mockingjay
