Is this better than Pet Sounds or Sgt. Peppers?
Opinions?
Eli Nelson
Other urls found in this thread:
albumsthatneverwere.blogspot.com
twitter.com
Oliver Allen
It's better than a lot of recorded music
Noah Gray
not as good as pet sounds, because it's an unfinished album. if it was finished properly and released in 1967 it probably would have been.
better than sgt. peppers? definitely
Leo Johnson
no it is not
good vibrations is a really good song tho
Jace Miller
I'd put Smile behind Sunflower and Surf's Up desu
Ryder Richardson
sunflower is overrated
Bentley Foster
Listen to it again.
Anthony Allen
i think the snl version of smile is the most accurate to 1967, and probably my favorite, but the 2011 release from the smile sessions is probably my AOTD. i think pet sounds is better, but it's better than any beatles album
Hunter Murphy
Arguably the greatest piece of music ever, and definitely better than those albums.
Bentley Nguyen
snl version of smile?
Christopher Stewart
could have been better than Pet Sounds. It's honestly so goddamn good, but too rough around the edges, if they let Brian go through with his vision it might have been the best album ever.
Zachary Howard
They mean SonicLoveNoize, of the blog Albums That Never Were
Brayden Reed
Better than Pet Sounds, worst than Sgt Pepper.
Adrian Hernandez
Do you guys think a "Sup Forums makes a SMiLE mix" project could ever work?
Mason Rogers
Is it weird that I love the 2011 SMiLE Sessions but I've never been able to get into Pet Sounds?
John Baker
>Do you guys think a "Sup Forums makes a SMiLE mix" project could ever work?
it would be one of the worst albums ever made
Matthew Walker
This isn't a very good version on SMiLE to be honest.
Luke Morales
>remove the old master painter
>move child is father of the man to 6
>put look (song for children) at 5
>replace im in great shape with holidays
perfect
Bentley Fisher
>removing Gee
baka desu
Leo Jenkins
I genuinely think it's the best pop album ever recorded, and it would be as revered as Sgt. Pepper had it been finished in the 60s. It is the funnest album to listen to, it's a shame that it was thrown away.
Jack Martinez
>Not using the 2004 version with a version of Good Vibrations with the original lyrics and the "hum de dum" passages
Best way to listen to SMiLE.
Xavier Wood
gee was made too late to be accurate to a 1967. but i like hearing it in the smile sessions's version of smile
i prefer the lyrics how they were originally released
Jacob Rogers
>i prefer the lyrics how they were originally released
That's what I'm talking about. The version of Good Vibrations used by SLN uses Tony Asher's lyrics. I think it's rather clumsily edited.
Colton Green
no it doesn't. i just listened to the first verse of sln, smiley smile, and smile sessions and they all have the same lyrics
Juan Long
>the fade out to holiday
Isaac Perez
Why not?
SLN used the mix that Brian prepared for the album, and Gee wasn't in it.
No, you are mistaken. He uses the regular single version in his 1967 mix
Xavier Perry
>No, you are mistaken. He uses the regular single version in his 1967 mix
they all have the same lyrics. what are you referring to?
Grayson Nelson
No sorry, meant to reply to
Oliver Mitchell
no sweat dawg
Liam Peterson
mrs o learys cow is a fucking jam.