ITT: Artist's ACTUAL Best Album

...

Other urls found in this thread:

reddit.com/r/Music/
dictionary.com/browse/objective
dictionary.com/browse/subjective
twitter.com/NSFWRedditVideo

...

For the first time I agree with OP

...

demon days is a close second

only plebs will disagree

...

syro

TPaB hasn't aged well at all

I respect this opinion, but I think Demon Days is unbeatable

...

>33
>III

trufax

...

ok reddit

...

I can't tell if you're baiting me or serious.

these are correct

This is wrong.

...

I don't see how this is objectively true at all. IV is better. Hell, even I, physical graffiti and houses of the holy are better.

>objectively true
pro tip this isn't a thing

agreed

It is when you have taste faggot

First and best.

No.....

>it's objective when i agree with it
ok

again, it's called not being a pleb. you wouldn't understand.

not that user, but your stupid, thats all

how does pleb taste = objectively bad

>feeding the trolls

Because when you have taste you are able to accurately figure out what album is an artists most objectively good/important without letting your personal preferences get in the way. Led Zep 3 is a great album, my personal favorite is PG, but IV is objectively the best. now get the fuck off this board you faggots.

why wouldn't your personal favorite be "the best"
ie why is iv better than pg

>why wouldn't your personal favorite be "the best"
are you new here?

ugh. this again.

i'm sorry it's too tempting
seriously, why would you argue for an album that's not even your favorite in a band's discog over your personal favorite

to give you a not dick answer: I like PG because some of my favorite lz songs are on that album. But in terms of artistry, impact on the genre and industry, and overall song quality, IV is regarded my most critics to be Led Zeppelins best album. For example, MOST people don't play Captain Beefhearts Trout Mask Replica in their car on a regular basis, but you'd be hard pressed to find a more 'important' album. This is the essence of Sup Forumscore in many ways.

Actual answer

>artistry, impact on the genre and industry
a buzzword and two factors totally independent of the quality of the music
fucking sick

because i'm on Sup Forums, not talking with my friends. everything here is objective unless stated otherwise.

so you define "objectively good" as what record is more important in terms of influence? ok
i just don't understand the difference between 'song quality' and 'favorite songs'
because i don't understand why you would like a song that isn't a song of good quality

The only one wrong here is you two

>i just don't understand the difference between 'song quality' and 'favorite songs'

please get the fuck off Sup Forums, seriously. this is not a place for you. You'll find a nice home at reddit.com/r/Music/

...

or don't address my argument you know that's fine too

...

dictionary.com/browse/objective
dictionary.com/browse/subjective

you dumb fuck.

Fight me

Pinkerton fags BTFO

news flash: art's not a fucking science
there aren't any facts to judge when you're listening to a song

vomit definitions with no context too, another delicious substitute for using your brain and typing out an argument

why are you still on this board.

to torture you

yo you're a fucking idiot too

ok guy
please tell me the qualities i should be using to determine """objective""" quality

nah you're alright.

Aw man, you sankt my otten!

It's real fucking good but I will always prefer Sky Valley. It's one of my all time favorites.

...

...

correct

...

still sounds like the future

>

>most people wouldn't call it a "good album"
>but that's why so many people like it

ok

...

...

you literally aren't even quoting me you god damn stupid faggot. can you please go to reddit with your pleb taste so the adults can talk here?

>not literally the best album of all time

This. Makes me laugh when people try to deny Revolver is their best album.

the fall
the crybaby
untitled unmastered
hesitation marks
pablo
load
hurley
white
mega

agreed

I don't think anyone argued this

Warning a close 2nd

>the fall
>untitled unmastered
>pablo

It is almost impossible to have THIS much level of shit taste

Rayfags btfo

>tfw no one else agrees with this

...

...

...

...

wtf? you are, unironically, a fucking pleb. Warning is one of the worst pieces of shit Green Day's ever shit out, it's just schmaltzy pop rock bullshit with lukewarm, disingenuous lyrics the whole way through. it's fucking garbage. nimrod's pretty shitty too, Hitchin a Ride and King For a Day are terrible fucking songs

Warning: 0/10
Nimrod: 4/10

uhh try again sweetie that wasnt an argument ;)

This album is amazing. Frakctured is the greatest guitar composition to ever come out of rock music imo

>sweetie
>emoticon

No argument necessary

Neither is that

terrible album art though

Plastic Beach
Me Against The World
TPAB
IV
Illinoise
The College Dropout
correct
correct
And Justice For All
Pinkerton's their only good album
Rubber Soul
Kerplunk
Ray of Light
SSLP
The Black Album
It Was Written

...

I prefer Hammerheart.
Agree.
Yeezus is goat.

Bonus points to whoever guesses it

>mega
It's actually 0 kiddo

...

It's actually Purest Feeling

I thought we could make it through this without mentioning NMH but I guess not. You have failed us user

>Hurley best album

hot take, i think it's more focused than pet sounds.

...

...

I agree. I actually think Holland gives PS a run for it's money as well, though I still think SU>PS>Holland

...

well all his album art except Illmatic is pretty terrible desu