What's pink floyds best album?
Pic not related obviously
What's pink floyds best album?
Pic not related obviously
Other urls found in this thread:
atom heart mother>animals>the man and the journey live show>1970s live shows>obscured by clouds>>>>>>>everything else
thats a pretty interesting list
what would your ranking be? I always like seeing others opinions on floyd as they used to be my number 1
According to Sup Forums, the least famous one.
This applies to every artist ever.
My teenage years band, still my fav, would probably rank them way differently back then than now (thanks for the man and the journey totally forgot about that)
As Im thinking about ranking them right now I realise I cant really, they're all 10/10 for me, some being 9.8/10 or so
The only album I wouldnt consider a Floyd album is FinalCut (didnt listen to endless river yet)
I really cant rank them, impossible for me, just found out.
Top5 songs tho in no order - Time, Echoes, Dogs, Greenisthecolour, Terminal Frost, probably. The entirety of Pompeii also.
Wish you were here
Ofcourse it's DarkSide dummy
the wall is probably the best one. if not that one then maybe their first album.
Green is the colour live is such a beautiful thing to hear, I wish I could actually see it
Atom Heart Mother is my favorite.
Atom Heart Mother > Meddle > Wish You Were Here > Animals > Dark Side Of The Moon > (Pink Floyd with Syd) > the rest
second that, time machine ----> any of the older PF lives is my biggest 'unrealistic' dream
I legitimately do not understand how anyone over the age of 16 can think that DSOTM or the Wall even come close to being their best albums.
A ranking of each era is needed
>barrett floyd
>waters/gilmour/wright
>waters
>gilmour
And the endless river would count as wright
They have great moments and make good single setting listens while even their lowest points are better than the vast majority of many artists entire catalogue
>all these contrarians underages thinking AHM is anything but shit
Even the band members hate it
Not even relevant to what I said, but okay.
>barrett era
psychpop trash
>collaborative
meddle>wywh>dsotm
>roger solo albums with pink floyd
animals>the wall>final cut
>gilmour
division bell>amlor
Nigga theyre the first floyd albums everyone heard because theyre easy to digest
Yeah, that's why 16 year olds like those albums. Are you agreeing with me or trying to disprove my point?
This. It's the best negotiation between Waters' input on their later albums which becomes too melodramatic for my taste, and their earlier psychedelic rock which can get kinda schizophrenic
This
forgot pic
piper>rest
i legitimately dont understand how they couldn't be someone's top albums, regardless of age. people have different opinions.
and they're not easier to than something like meddle or obscured by clouds.
bitches... no one believes you when you're saying that meddle and obscured by clouds are their best albums. you're only fooling yourselves.
Piper At the Gates, Atom Heart Mother, Meddle, and The Wall are the good ones. Dark Side is ok. everything else is shit.
Meddle is the best Pink Floyd album for those who don't suffer from mental illness, seriously. It's their most coherent album to listen to in its entirety.
except no one actually listens to meddle in its entirety. they just start the album on side b.
the best floyd is their live songs honestly
live floyd > studio floyd
bitch how is animals a roger waters solo album when dave wrote 1/5 of it
If you can't handle Meddle at its side A, you don't deserve it at its side B
Syd Barrett wasn't even in anything past Saucerful. Ummagumma-Wish You Were Here go under collaborative.
Best to worst:
Pompeii
Atom Heart Mother
Saucerful of Secrets
Meddle
Wish You Were Here
Animals
Obscured By Clouds
Dark Side of the Moon
The Division Bell
Piper at the Gates of Dawn, The Wall, A Momentary Lapse of Reason
Ummagumma
More
The Final Cut
The Endless River
Animals>DSOM>Meddle>WYWH>PATGD>Saucerful>AHM>The Wall>OBC> Everything Else
Endless River is basically a B Side album that no one asked for
Those are just the contrarians, ignore them
Wall>DSOTM>>>>everything else
was there ever a more based man?
Dave a cute!
WYWH>Meddle>Pipers>The Wall>DSOTM>Animals>Atom Heart Mother
havn't heard the rest
>The Division Bell above Piper and The Wall
The Division Bell is their worst album it's actually one of the shittiest album I've ever listened to. You're right about Pompeii and Atom Heart Mother tho.
A Saucerful of Secrets>everything else
But OP that IS their best album
BEST PF COMP. EVAH!
Out of the ones I've listened to:
1. Dark Side Of The Moon
2. Saucerful Of Secrets
3. Wish You Were Here
4. Piper At The Gates Of Dawn
5. The Wall
6. Animals
7. Meddle
8. Atom Heart Mother
9. The Final Cut
Special mention goes to their early singles. See Emily Play is one of their best songs.
So underrated