How do you rank them?

How do you rank them?

Other urls found in this thread:

youtube.com/watch?v=iBSLBl-64fk
youtube.com/watch?v=uDAREiqjFoY
twitter.com/NSFWRedditGif

1>2>3 like everyone else with good opinions

1=2>3

1>3>2

just want to say whoever recommended the bailey jay jerk off instruction video earlier much appreciated, it was patrician viewing

1 > 3 > 2

this. 3 is pretty disappointing in certain places. the holes are beginning to appear in jackson's work. the ghost witch, the elephant jumping, lots of weird stuff that doesn't work. still it has a lot of great frodo/sam moments and gandalf being cool.

1>2>3 but I love them all.

i literally watch fotr every now and then and ignore the rest

should i give the other two a watch?

how many times bros?

3 for fellowship
2 for towers
4 for return

2>1>3

Rohan siege is the best battle scene in the series

1>2>3.

2's highs are higher than 1's, but it has 1 too many Legolas scenes.

7+ fotr
5+ ttt
4+rotk

1>shit>2>3

>2's highs are higher than 1's,
nice try

At least 8 times each, i watch them every year without fail.

I also watch the whole trilogy, dont see point in one at a time.

idiot

2>1>3
sorry Sup Forums

perfect, almost perfect, basically perfect

this

i often just watch fellowship only because it's pretty much perfect, and also leaves the rest open to imagination

Two towers are great but faramir was butchered and i wont forgive jackson for it

Return of the king is a great movie too but had more faults than the previous movie

Both movies are still far better than anything hollywood can make right now, though

Not going to lie, taking the extended editions into account I think I like ROTK the most, but just barely. Even though its long as fuck the scenes with Frodo and Sam and Mount Doom are pure kino to me.

pls no bully

>when Legolas injects himself in a timeless scene
youtube.com/watch?v=iBSLBl-64fk

Shit > 1 = 2 = 3

The Ride of the Rohirrim in RotK made me forgive a lot of its flaws.

3 = 1 > 2

I still love towers though

1>3>2

1>2=3

>not 2>1>3
How does it feel to have plebeian taste?

to me, it's really one movie. I only marathon it extended, anyway.

Oh gawd, I was so stoked for this trilogy when I heard about it around 99/00.
Queued outside a cinema to get tickets and had to sit in shit seats.
Then I realized they skipped the Tom Bombadil sequence...
My heart sank, I even told myself it would pop up later on, I waited, it never happened.
After that the whole thing died for me.
Peter Jackson is a hack and a crappy director who didn't understand anything...

I hope they do a proper trilogy one day.

I also hope Peter Jackson gets stung by a jellyfish and drowns

I do this also.
TT is a fun watch sometimes, but I don't like all the EE scenes in it.
Like the parts when the forest walks over to helms deep and kills the remaining orc? What the hell

Patrician: TTT
Plebeian: FotR
Contrarian: RotK

Patrician: FotR
Plebeian: RotK
Contrarian: TTT

1>2still liked 3 just didnt compare to the first two, which are closer in quality and both GOAT

>Like the parts when the forest walks over to helms deep and kills the remaining orc
Happens in the book. But yeah, apart from Fellowship the EEs aren't too clever.

Does your wife's son know you are gay?

15-20 fellowship
give or take 10 two towers
6ish rotk

>tfw didn't read the books before the movies
>loved the movies and faramir although i heard he was better
>read the books after and dont mind the difference much

which is different from GoT, which I read first and they butcher one GOAT character (well they butchered a bunch but also my favorite) and i cant enjoy the series anymore

1=2=3

>Happens in the book.
Yeah, but it's so badly executed.

There is also some dumb Gimili jokes in the EE.

But, EE TT also got some great scenes, like this one:
youtube.com/watch?v=uDAREiqjFoY

so yeah