One of those threads

>best: Crack Rock
>worst: Lost
>overrated: Thinkin 'Bout You
>underrated: Sierra Leone

>best: Bad Religion
>worst: Lost
>overrated: Thinkin Bout You
>underrated: Bad Fucking Religion

>best: DUCKWORTH
>worst: LOYALTY
>overrated: DNA
underrated: FEAR

>best: The Good Life
>worst: Getchoo
>overrated: El Scorcho
>underrated: Tired of Sex

>best: Power
>worst: Hell of a Life
>overrated: Runaway
>underrated: Gorgeous

>Best
Vomitspit
>Runner-up
Potholderz
>Worst
Kon Queso
>Overrated
Beef Rapp (I guess idk)
>Underrated
Deep Fried Frenz

>Best
Crack Rock
>Runner-up
Lost
>Worst
Pilot Jones
>Overrated
Pilot Jones
>Underrated
Monks

>Best
XXX.
>Runner-up
DUCKWORTH.
>Worst
LOVE.
>Overrated
ELEMENT.
>Underrated
LOYALTY.

>Best
Across the Sea
>Runner-up
Tired of Sex
>Worst
El Scorching
>Overrated
Butterfly
>Underrated
No Other One

>Best
All of the Lights
>Runner-up
Monster
>Worst
It's a toss up between So Appalled and Lost in the World
>Overrated
Dark Fantasy
>Underrated
Monster

best: Weekend
worst: When In Rome
underrated: Ascension
overrated: Cut The Check


best: Super Rich Kids
worst: Monks
overrated: Pyramids
underrated: Crack Rock

>best
Suspended In Gaffa
>runner up
Houdini
>worst
All The Love
>overrated
The Dreaming
>underrated
There Goes A Tenner

you must be retarded

AND IF IT BRINGS ME TO MY KNEES
OKAY REMEMBER

>worst: Lost

da fuck

>Best
Light My Fire
>Runner-up
The End
>Underrated
End of the Night
>Overrated
Break On Through (To the Other Side)
>Worst
Take It As It Comes

>best
rainbows (there's too much to fucking choose from)
>worst
supervillain theme
>overrated
accordion
>underrated
hardcore hustle

>best
pyramids
>worst
white
>overrated
thinkin 'bout you
>underrated
crack rock

>best
XXX.
>worst
GOD.
>overrated
HUMBLE.
>underrated
XXX

>best
tired of sex
>worst
falling for you
>overrated
el scorcho
>underrated
tired of sex

>best
lost in the world
>worst
all of the lights
>overrated
runaway
>underrated
dark fantasy

JEEEEESUS FUCKING CHRIST, do you just like boring songs or something?
>best:
First half of Pyramids if it was separated from the rest. Lost, if it can't.
>worst:
Forrest Gump
>overrated:
Thinkin 'Bout You (it's still fucking great tho)
>underrated:
Bad Religion

>worst
all the songs because these are shit albums

>best
Pull Out the Pin
>runner-up
Sat in Your Lap
>worst
All the Love
>overrated
Suspended in Gaffa
>underrated
Get Out of My House
>best
The Crystal Ship
>runner-up
Light My Fire
>worst
Alabama Song
>overrated
Break On Through (To the Other Side)
>underrated
Soul Kitchen

best: night of the swallow
runner-up: there goes a tenner
worst: all the love??
overrated: suspended in gaffa
underrated: leave it open

Found the "le rong genarashion" faggot. Every thread has one.

the Doom albums have been out for 13 years and Pinkerton has been out for 20

super villain theme is dope

They're all popular albums released in the past 20 years, and the only albums you bothered to comment on are significantly older. You SERIOUSLY think there's nothing worth salvaging from MBDTF, the apex of hip-hop production, or Madillany, the apex of hip-hop lyricism? Are you just being contrarian, or did you legitimately just not listen to them because they're new?

>MBDTF
>the apex of hip-hop production
>Madillany
>the apex of hip-hop lyricism
hello whitey!

I'm fine with being white, as long as I don't have genuinely awful taste in music like you do.

>best
Techno Pop
>runner-up
Boing Boom Tschak
>worst
Der Telefon-Anruf
>overrated
Musique Non Stop
>underrated
Sex Objekt

>the apex of hip-hop production
What the fuck are you on about?
Radio, Paul's Boutique, The Infamous, Stankonia, The Score, Like Water for Chocolate, and more all have better production than MBDTF.
>the apex of hip-hop lyricism
What the fuck are you on about?
Fear of a Black Planet, Me Against the World, Illmatic, Only Built 4 Cuban Linx, Liquid Swords, Stankonia, The College Dropout, and Section.80 all have better lyrics.
>Are you just being contrarian, or did you legitimately just not listen to them because they're new?
They're shit albums that are pushed by mainstream outlets. I realized the albums I just listed are also hailed as some of the greatest as well, but it's not because they had cults of personalities that today's rappers enjoy every time they release an album. For fuck's sake, TLOP still had a 75 on Metacritic and that album is complete shit. The ratings are inflated.

nah, he's just one of those "le (c)rap xDDDD" kids

Bruh, if you make a graph of where hip-hop production is RIGHT NOW, Paul's Boutique is not anywhere close. For obvious reasons, it sounds dated compared to what we have today. It innovated a lot at the time, but other albums have eclipsed it's audio accomplishments, some of which you've listed. MBDTF is the latest in a long line of influential albums, and nothing since has detrhoned it.
Now for the lyrics. First of all, don't come here telling me that College Dropout has literary talent. Get the fuck out of here. It has good songWRITING, in that sense, but not good writing. And again, same as before, no one has actually came up with a new bell or whistle since Doom came along. Madvillany is the last work of genius we have that can stand with Illmatic and Fear of a Black Planet and shit. Before I forget tho, no, Section 80 does NOT have better writing than Madvillany, who filled your head with these lies?
The music industry has been pretty terrible, on the whole, since the singles era of British rock. Hip-hop has only been PARTICULARLY terrible during the bling era which, by the way, Kanye ended with MBDTF, so that album is important for THAT reason as well.
As for TLOP, uhh..... I really got no words for that. I said that it was a piss-poor attempt at a Death Grips-esque mainstream hip-hop album, and people didn't believe me until Atrocity Exhibition came out.

You're the kind of person that thinks older albums suck because they're old and that we are in the greatest era of music in human history. Paul's Boutique still has fantastic production.
>It has good songWRITING, in that sense, but not good writing.
What the fuck does this even mean? Kanye doesn't have the technical ability or complex rhyme schemes that Doom has but there's substance to his lyrics that Doom lacks.
>if you make a graph
Make one then.

>best
Smothered in Hugs
>runner-up
Echos Myron
>worst
Her Psychology Today
>overrated
Tractor Rape Chain
>underrated
Peep-Hole

>best : Trouble Sleep Yanga Wake Am
>worst : Question Jam Answer
>overrated : none of them
>underrated : all of them

>Best
Penny Dreadfuls
>Runner-Up
Alvin Row
>Worst
Everyone Whistling
>Overrated
Spirit They've Vanished
>Underrated
Untitled (unironically)

>Best
Super Rich Kids
>Runner-Up
Pyramids
>Worst
Lost
>Overrated
Thinkin' Bout You
>Underrated
Pilot Jones
>Best
FEAR.
>Worst
LOVE
>Overrated
LOYALTY
>Underrated
XXX
>Best
Money Folder
>Runner-Up
Accordion
>Worst
Shadows of Tomorrow
>Overrated
Curls
>Underrated
Funny Ways

I'm lazy af, but the graph would look like the world population or something, with various spikes during certain periods and then a leveling-off after. I would have used such a graph to point to, let's say, something that happened in the 1800's that significantly effected the population and say "this is what Paul's Boutique did for hip-hop production". Then I point to the fucking baby boom, and say "this is what MBDTF did for hip-hop production".
In other news, substance in lyrics is usually thought of as a section of words that, through a density in literary devices or references, has a larger-than-average NUMBER of meanings than other sections of words in similar length. Just because a Kanye song has meaning does not mean that it is MEANINGFUL, as that qualification applies when you can read it more than once and get different things.

>best: Da Art of Storytellin (Pt. 1)
>worst: Mamacita
>overrated: SpottieOttieDopalicious
>underrated: Skew It On The Bar-B

>best: Pink Matter
>worst: white
>overrated: Crack Rock
>underrated: Lost

>best: XXX
>worst: LOVE
>overrated: DNA
>underrated: LUST

>best: Lost in the World / Gorgeous
>worst: Blame Game
>overrated: Devil in a New Dress
>underrated: Monster

>best: All Caps
worst: Hardcore Hustle
overrated: Rhinestone Cowboy
underrated: Shadows of Tomorrow

>best
I Serve the Base
>runner up
Thought It Was a Drought
>worst
Colossal
>overrated
Where Ya At
>underrated
Blood on the Money

>best
Pyramids
>runner up
Pink Matter
>worst
Pilot Jones
>overrated
Thinkin Bout You
>underrated
Crack Rock

>best
DNA.
>runner up
XXX.
>worst
YAH.
>overrated
HUMBLE.
>underrated
GOD.

>best
Devil in a New Dress
>runner up
Gorgeous
>worst
Lost in the World
>overrated
Runaway
>underrated
So Appalled

>best
Strange Ways
>runner up
Accordion
>worst
Operation Lifesaver
>overrated
All Caps
>underrated
Fancy Clown

Yo if youre a fan of da art of storytellin pt1 then peep the single version that has a feature from Slick Rick. Amazing version of the song. Only ever seen it on Youtube tho not on streamin sites.

>best: Hey Mama
>worst: Crack Music
>overrated: Gold Digger
>underrated: We Major

>best: Forrest Gump
>worst: Pilot Jones
>overrated: Pyramids
>underrated: Pink Matter


>best: ELEMENT
>worst: HUMBLE
>overrated: DNA
>underrated: YAH


>best: El Schorcho
>worst: Getchoo
>overrated: Pink Triangle
>underrated: No Other One


>best: Runaway
>worst: Lost In The World
>overrated: All Of The Lights
>underrated: Devil In A New Dress


>best: Weekend
>worst:Jump
>overrated: ROS
>underrated: Perfect Circle/God Speed


>best: Curls
>worst: Harcore Hustle
>overrated: America's Most Blunted
>underrated: Fancy Clown

>best: Da Art of Storytellin pt1
>worst: Mamacita
>overrated: SpottieOttieDopaliscious
>underrated: Aquemini

PIC:
>best: Acid Rain
>worst: NaNa
>overrated: Favorite Song
>underrated: Everybody's Something

Best: suspended in gaffa
Runner-up: night of the swallow
Worst/overrated: the dreaming
Underrated: still night of the swallow
Best: rhinestone cowboy
Runner-up: operation lifesaver or supervillain theme
Worst: sickfit
Overrated: america's most blunted (still a fucking banger)
Underrated: figaro

best: pink matter
worst: Forrest Gump I guess
overrated: thinking 'bout you
underrated: fucking pink matter

>Best: Shadow Man
>Worst: Freedom
>Overrated: Diddy Bop
>Underrated: Forever

>Best
The Night Josh Tillman Came to Our Apt.
>Worst
Bored in the USA
>Overrated
Holy Shit
>Underrated
Strange Encounter

>Best
DNA
>Worst
Humble
>Overrated
Humble
>Underrated
Feel

>Best
Gorgeous
>Worst
Blame Game
>Overrated
Monster, Power
>Underrated
All of The Lights

>Best
Pull Out The Pin
>Worst
Houdini
>Overrated
Sat In Your Lap
>Underrated
Leave It Open

Pride is the only good song.

>best
thuggin
>worst
watts
>overrated
pinata
>underrated
knicks

>best
great day
>worst
sickfit
>overrated
rhinestone cowboy

>best
pride
>worst
god
>overrated
love
>underrated
feel

>best
chateau lobby #4 (in c for two virgins)
>worst
bored in the usa
>overrated
holy shit
>underrated
the ideal husband

>best
addiction
>worst
bring me down
>overrated
gold digger
>underrated
my way home

>best:History of touches
>worst: Black Lake
>overrated: Notget
>underrated: Quicksand