Since when are comeback albums this good?

Since when are comeback albums this good?

Why is 2017 such a good year for reunion releases?

Other urls found in this thread:

open.spotify.com/user/androol_/playlist/1ObWSj7I4uhy9Nilw0WtLY
twitter.com/NSFWRedditImage

I loved Narkopop, Slowdive s/t was hit or miss, mostly miss and I'm not listening to a Brand New album.

>I'm not listening to a Brand New album.
your (huge) loss, it's better than their other albums by a mile

It's better than Daisy and YFW but not TDAGARIM and Deja.

Wasn't too impressed w/ narko. Nothing tops Zauberberg for me.

open.spotify.com/user/androol_/playlist/1ObWSj7I4uhy9Nilw0WtLY

First album in 15 years

Zauberberg is definitely my favorite as well. But I felt like Narkopop is the most similar to Zauberberg, which I really liked.

go home sp*tify shill

How would you propose I post revised track orders?

Slowdive s/t was the only one of those I enjoyed but desu I'm just not that into Brand New or Gas generally.
There have been some incredibly mediocre reunion releases/attempted comebacks this year though:
>Ride - Weather Diaries
>Depeche Mode - Spirit
>Wire - Silver/Lead
>LCD Soundsystem - American Dream
>The Jesus & Mary Chain - Damage & Joy
>Spoon - Hot Thoughts
>The Magnetic Fields - 50 Song Memoir
>GY!BE - Luciferian Towers
>Lupe Fiasco - DROGAS Light

also predicting that the new albums from U2, Eminem, Beck, Björk, and Judas Priest will get a lukewarm reception at best

on a positive note though, Nine Inch Nails has been on a roll with these EPs. and I'm looking forward to the new St. Vincent album, the singles are great

Judas Priest just put out an awesome album in 2014

The cutoff was set at 8 years

they haven't been relevant or doing anything notable since Painkiller

Their 2014 album was very notable and relevant. New guitarist as I recall and he worked out really well.

Lots of others listed there also don't qualify. Brand New set the cutoff at 8 years. Otherwise this would be just an ordinary 2017 thread.

Deja is overrated as fuck mall-emo garbagio. Daisy better than each record on that list.

>There have been some incredibly mediocre reunion releases/attempted comebacks this year though:
>>Wire - Silver/Lead
>>GY!BE - Luciferian Towers
>>Lupe Fiasco - DROGAS Light
How are these comebacks? Lupe and GYBE had albums in 2015, Wire had one in 2016

maybe not GY!BE, Allelujah came out a lot more recently than I thought, but it's been a minute since Lupe or Wire released anything very well-received.
I liked Silver/Lead more than I expected to though, they might still have a great late-career album left in them. probably their best album since Bruce Gilbert left

that's true, taking Brand New as the standard for a comeback/reunion most of those examples are pushing it

wait that's not right, best album with Matthew Simms. Red Barked Tree was great

Wait Ride had a fucking comeback too? Holy shit.

Last year had some great comeback albums too. ATCQ had a wonderful final album.

>ATCQ had a wonderful final album.
overrated

Gas 8/10
Slowdive Haven't listened yet. excited.
Brand New 2/10, sorry it's fucking awful.

>Brand New 2/10, sorry it's fucking awful.
It's fucking great

>Brand New 2/10, sorry it's fucking awful.
imagine having taste this bad

>American Dream
>Bad

and the GY!BE album is not even out

American football wasnt good