What do you think about this? Ive seen this image circling around Sup Forums for some time
I love how "bosnian serbs" and "bosnians" are almost entirely inside "Croatian". Also shows that we are mostly similar to Magyars and Germans. It doesnt surprise me much considering we shared countries for almost 1000 years. There was enough time for all kinds of mixing.
If you look at the most PCA maps there will be a few Swedish outliers that group near finland, but I did find one other map where a few swedes grouped near poles. It was more detailed and showed they grouped near Belorussians too, so they were probably east poles
Zachary Brooks
But why? What does a random Croat from Zagorje, Međimurje, Istria, our islands have in common with a random Serb from the south around Niš? Nothing.
I bet even Slavonia and closer regions... There were so many Hungarians and Germans here when we shared countries. And we did for almost 1000 years!
In Hungary, 2nd most common surname is Kovac, and 5th is Horvath
Alexander Diaz
Eastern Polacks(now living in Western Poland) clustering with Russians doesn't suprise me. They were polonised Ruthenianas.
Camden Roberts
well i'm not talking about extreme cases, like north croatia and south serbia. overall we have the same mixtures if you look at haplogroups i'm not trying to say that we overlap entirely, but little overlaping also doesn't seem correct
Brayden Phillips
I dont know. Even Vojvodina was full of Hungarians at some point, so I guess some Serb from there might have more common genetics with a Croat from Slavonia than with a Serb from the south. Same goes with Slavonian and Dalmatian
This is really fascinating to me. Just shows how nationalities are actually weak concepts. Wish we could all take DNA tests from the moment when we are young
Fun fact: In Croatia first political party was, horvatsko-vugerska stranka (croato-hungarian party) opposing the Illyrian panslavic movement
Grayson Phillips
>In Hungary, 2nd most common surname is Kovac,
Actually, the second most common surname is Horvát.
Brayden Flores
yes, but even that map is inaccurate regarding us because Kosovo is also included in the final result and you know that it's majority albanian but whatever i agree with you, at the end of the day there's no ethnicity in the world with "clean" genetics or whatever you call it, especially here in the small balkans where there were many ethnicities who later assimilated into today ones
you got croat'd
Carter Diaz
eh, ever source shows it different. Lets say they are both in top 5
In Croatia, Horvat is the most common surname, while Kovačić is 6th, and Kovač 17.
Horvat is also the most common Slovak surname and 2. or 3. in Slovenia
Gabriel Collins
and Kovačević 4th kek
Carson Moore
another one
Christian Roberts
>Sardinia
Hudson Fisher
What is point of putting portugal? Theres nothing unique in portugal it is just a remnant of feudal politics.
Luis Morales
Croats look very different from us, desu
Jacob Roberts
Lamoing at "basically Austrian" polentazzi
Noah Sanders
>were people too tanned in your trip to our coast? kek hm could be, this guy looks pretty German
>tfw not being an immigrant in Germany and getting free gouvernemnt welfare sometimes I wish I were some dirty Syrian muslim
arent Croats like the biggest immigrant group in Bavaria? Do you know any Croats there?
Nicholas Garcia
>arent Croats like the biggest immigrant group in Bavaria? Do you know any Croats there?
They are not the biggest, but pretty big. I know several Croats. Croats are very unproblematic as immigrants.
Josiah Clark
I've never heard anyone complaining about Croats thb, Turks and to some degree Italians are somewhat disliked
Christian Sullivan
...
Noah Myers
...
Carson White
What's your point? portuguese cluster with spaniards for obvious reasons, then with north-italians, french, austrians, west-germans, south-english..............
The genetically closest pops in the world, to the portuguese:
Eurogenes # Population (source) Distance 1 PT 3.63 2 ES 4.84 3 North_Italian 7.41 4 FR 8.04 5 Tuscan 12.59 6 AT 15.61 7 Cornish 16.71 8 West_&_Central_German 17.07 9 NL 17.43 10 RO 17.55 11 Serbian 17.67 12 English 17.99 13 HU 18.78 14 French_Basque 18.93 15 Orcadian 19.53 16 IE 19.58 17 Scottish 20.62 18 DK 21.06 19 South_Italian_&_Sicilian 22.6 20 NO 22.9
Hudson Clark
>France, Britain and Hungary
Now that's a thing
Blake Torres
>19 South_Italian_&_Sicilian 22.6 damn
Luke Walker
I've heard that Central Europeans have a larger genetic distance from negroids than poodles have from wolves. Is this substantiated by reputable publications and research or just a stormfag meme?
Landon Cruz
>RO
Brayden Adams
Which Central Europeans and what did you mean by this.
Landon Cox
Nothing a serb from Nis is genetically Bulgarian or Albanian
Angel Edwards
This map says that Romanians, Bulgarians and Albanians are on the level of whiteness like north Italians. It also says Portuguese and Spaniards arent genetically close to North Africans which they are.
Nathaniel Kelly
They're closer to Arabs than they are to Europeans though. The map doesn't include poo in loos and Iranians are partly related to them.
Adrian Peterson
that's because you have higher WHG input, which pulls northwest on a west Eurasian PCA too bad that won't override the African admixture
Cooper Morgan
Intredasting. What should i learn from all these pics?
Lincoln James
>It also says Portuguese and Spaniards arent genetically close to North Africans which they are.
The suebic/visigothic rape compensated the later berber rape.
Dominic Rogers
That's the black admixture not the african in general.
Nolan Lopez
Even worse.
Noah Brown
Yeah is not right, you're mixed with blacks
Lincoln Martinez
Well, according to Gedmatch I have 0% subsaharan admixture. I don't know how reliable is this map.
Alexander Myers
You're an exception, not the rule user
Blake Scott
But I live in the orange area.
Landon Miller
depending on the test it might be grouped under NW African, since the SSA in Iberians seem to be mediated by those
Jacob Green
That map it is not deep run's, those samples they incorpore north-african caucasoid, iberians score zero to noise SSA
Isaac Turner
I got 3% NW african and 0.45% poo in the loo
Kevin Gray
interesting how portuguese cluster closer to italians than to spaniards. one would expect it to be the other way around.
Chase Barnes
indeed, but the fact that at low Ks it is attributed to SSA rather than caucasian groups is still interesting after all, it is perfectly in line with the high(by European standards) frequency of mtDNA L in Iberia
Dominic Miller
Intredazting, Galcia got the highest north sea score in the Peninsula. Is there any study about northern Portugal?
Ryan Diaz
Well, autosomal already debunked, those exagerations, and you can see. mtDNA L makers have been found in all Europe, even in Norway, Russia and Uk, they only give you a line, And we have seen so much confusion and even disonesty about it, reaching to a point where non-native samples were taken.
James Ross
btw, anyone knows who the fuck where the baltic hunther-gatherers and how can I have a 36%?
Michael Reed
nothing is debunked, of course at higher number of clusters it's going to be more specific, but as I said, it is still interesting that at lower number of clusters it is attributed to SSA africa
and mtDNA L is found in Europe almost always at percentages of 0.x%, meanwhile in Iberia it even reaches 7.4% in Andalusia and 6.4% in Portugal
Nicholas Taylor
Goths probably, they absorbed a lot of Balts and Slavs.
Mason Gomez
what test? might just be a proxy for WHG-EHG aka mesolichi European foragers
Jordan Lewis
I don´t know. North-sea in iberia is higher in galicia, portugal and catalonia. Portuguese samples are grouped together
Jaxon Sanchez
hunter-gatherer versus farmer from Eurogenes
Galicia barely recevied visigoths, we got suebi
Colton Powell
It was found in Norway,Uk, France, etc above 1% And yes, autosomal debunked many of those myths about iberians. Iberians are europids, only cluster with europids, are far away of non-europeans, the berber levels % are small, and ssa tend to be none to noise levels.
Henry Flores
Are all your ancestors from Galicia?
Jayden Green
>It was found in Norway,Uk, France, etc above 1% sauce? Going by Eupedia(which sources all its claims), Norway is at 0.3% with sample size 628, England 0.2% with sample size 2333, France 0.9% with sample size 1216 Greece is even at 0.1% with sample size 996
Iberians of course are mainly Europids, but those signals are real, even if in fact mediated through some NW African population
Jose Ward
Yes, afaik from the same small area in the north of Galicia for the last 400 years.
Camden Ward
>some NW African population most likely related to the early megalithic cultures, btw, I don't think it's recent stuff given its pattern
Dylan Powell
Norway n = 1/74 1.40% Passarino et al 2002 France 1.40% Gónzalez et al. 2003 British n=1/100 1.00% Piercy et al. 1993 Finnish n = 1/50 2.00% Sajantila et al. 1995 Tuscany n= 6/322 1.86% Achilli et al 2007 Slovaks n = 2/207 0.97% Malyarchuk et al.2006
mtDNA only gives you a line,and sometimes they cant even define it, where it came from.
James Thomas
>Kargopol Russians that closer to Erzäns Northwestern Russia is Finnic
Isaac Garcia
Wtf, going by that russians are european. Were we mistaken in calling them asiatics all this time?
Parker Jenkins
That doesn't make any sense at all.
Adam Taylor
very poor sample size on those, mine are far better sampled
still, the fact that those frequencies are much higher in Iberia and correlate with African affinity is certainly not a coincidence
Easton Butler
Caucasian and middle-eastern part of this map is bullshit. Total and utter bullshit.
Jacob Reed
I got 3% north african in FamilytreeDNA and I am half Spanish. I guess that means my mother (her parents were from Galicia) would have gotten 6% My father is Volga German. I got haploshit I2a2