Which one is better, Sup Forums?

Which one is better, Sup Forums?

blue, everyone knows this

agree

Pinkerton

Both are 0/10

This post is bait.

then why did you respond?

Pinkerton, it's catchier

Blue when you're a virgin, pinkerton post virginity loss

Both are amazing but i prefer Pinkerton
Blue is great too but for some reason i think Pinkerton is a flawless album
Shut up pleb

Blue, by a lot. Pinkerton is good too, their second best album.

pinkerton.
the album is full of the best songs in there discography

Finn Wolfheart was right

I think pinkerton is the more expressive record but it never happens without the blue album first setting the scene for the band. It was such a radical departure. They made a move to self produce it. that's career suicide if its wrong and usually that happens on the third album.>"It kind of was career suicide."Exactly. They were lucky to make it back at all much less with a long awaited super produced 3rd record. Wtf they should be a foot note in the archives of pop up video but somehow they're still relevant to the MOR crowd.You know, maybe they were the benefactors of the early internet fandom. I remember fan pages begging for them to reunite. They may owe everything to geocities and AOL.When they reunited it was a total shock

Blue=Pinkerton.

Blue of course

I still got baited, self aware.

I think I habe the blue album memorized though... pinkerton ends with butterfly which is an emotional exorcism.... hard to say
....

Blue is the band at the height of their powers. Pinkerton is a more personal record but it never struck me as the superior one.

b i n k e r b u b

Blue, and in all honesty, I prefer Maladroit to Pinkerton. It's not by a great margin, but I still think it's better. Pinkerton is great though. It's such a personal album. Across the Sea and Pink Triangle as well as Butterfly are some of their best songs. I just don't care much for a couple of tracks on it.
But you eventually come back to Blue.

Old Sup Forums: Pinkerton
Current Sup Forums: Blue

What changed?

Blue just had solid hit after hit of fun indie rock songs. The worst song is what, The World Has Turned? Still a great song. The whole thing might as well be a greatest hits album.

Pinkerton is a close 2nd though.

Neither.
both are trash cringecore for underage misogynists

Blue overall has better singles and appeal for a debut album but I love pinkerton for being kind of reckless and not caring

definitely couldn't have been because of melon

Bot are 10/10

but BLUE