Is he right?

Is he right?

yes

always

Yeah pretty much. Boring ass band.

Scruffy is always right

scaruffi is a pretentious fag

He’s never right about anything.
His fans are worse than Radiohead’s fans ever could be.

Yes. Radiohead have a couple of good albums and the rest is trash

kid a is a 7
in rainbows is a 7
and also

Idk how he could get his own opinion wrong

>Gives Codeine's Frigid Stars an 8
>OK Computer gets a 7
?????

no they should be lower

He's right about half the time. He just happens to be right about Radiohead and Bowie but he's wrong about The Beatles.

Giving OK Computer anything but a 10 is just wrong

>good music
>bad music
whats your point

>thinks ok plebutor is good

*goes on rym once*

I agree that OKC's too low but let's not bring Frigid Stars into this.

reminder that 6/10 on the scaruffi scale is pretty good

...

Serious question. If Scaruffi is supposed to be some artistic genius that also classes himself as a visual artist, why does his website look like utter shit?
I mean I've seen websites from the 90s that looked better than this.

bro you're on Sup Forums. Function > form. The website works well.

Allegedly it's to make his website easier to load.

>Electioneering
>The Tourist
Let's just drop it to a 9 and call it even alright?

always

reminder that there is no right or wrong because music quality is subjective

t. fox news bimbo

He is so fucking retarded jesus christ

gullible

is he employed? what publications has he worked for

out of all the retarded pseudo "reviewers" to choose from this place really had to pick him huh

Yes.

I've never understood how so many people on this board seem to think that taste in music is an objective thing.
As if there can be a right or wrong to what one thinks of an album.
Sure, it's mostly agreed that OK Computer is a great album, but if you disagree, so fucking what? Taste is subjective.
Are people just scared to try and form their own opinion or something?

>implying The Tourist is bad
>implying Let Down isn't worse
>implying OKC is a 9

I don't know how the guy rates something but...
>In Rainbows: 5/10
Nigga what?

Music reviewing seems to be more of his hobby, his career is in computer science.

He doesn't know anything about music from his own motherfucking country, his opinion is no more valuable than any other user on Sup Forums

It is
It absolutely isn't what the fuck
It is

Sometimes I think “this guy is a pretty good critic” and then I remember he gave Frank Zappa six 8.0s and one 9.0

With this in mind, I would make In Rainbows a 7/10 and leave the rest as is.

And the 9 was fucking Uncle Meat

It's not good

It's more of a 5/10

...

That's accurate though

>in rainbows
>lower than pablo honey

It’s really not, Zappa deserves two 8.0s maximum. The only reason he’s rated so high is because Scruffy was obviously a fan of him in his youth.

Pretty much

Wrong

he never said this btw, it is edited
also, shit edit

>Lumping the Bends in with Pablo Honey
Absolutely disgusting.

pablo honey's got some good songs on it. Lurgee is one of Radiohead's better songs

As a Radiohead fan, OC is completely overrated and not even in the top half of their discography for me.

his description of Amnesiac is so good and I unironically agree with everything he said for it