Who was in the wrong here?

Who was in the wrong here?

Roger, he has always been a total twat

Why is David Gilmour turning into Ernest Hemingway?

Fuckin hell, they really did a reversal looks wise didn't they?

Roger. This is a no-brainer, OP. Roger had no right to try and force his bandmates to discontinue a band he wanted no part of.

Roger ''bad news for jews'' Waters

Roger feeds on Israeli tears.

Roger is clearly the better songwriting between them but he's acted like a fucking dick for no reason.

I don't trust Dave Gilmour

Seems like a really chill guy from the interviews

she trusted him and look what she achieved. you should trust dave too.

This is true, that he was the better songwriter, but he effectively disallowed David and Richard from writing material even after they had continuously proven themselves to be very good, and even lied about Richard's level of input on Animals because of his bloated ego. It hurt everybody's skill.

Dave and Kate. It's biblical cunt masters.

uhhhh this

roger is to PF, as Mike Love is to the Beach Boys

Only in attitude, completely the opposite in vision.

kek

Roger looks far better in his old age than he did when he was young. The reverse is true for David. Who is the real winner here?

The winner is the man who's spent his whole life transcending mere "looks", human

>David will never be your pal
need death

>Beach boys let brian wilson take over creative control which led them to become more than a novelty act, releasing their most acclaimed material in the upcoming years, after he left the rest of the band released some truly terrible stuff

>Pink Floyd let roger waters take over creative control which led them to become more than a novelty act, releasing their most acclaimed material in the upcoming years, after he left the rest of the band released some truly terrible stuff